A candidate submits his first licence application with a complete folder: certificates for every module, signed and stamped, and a letter from the school confirming completion of the course. The file comes back with two findings. One module was examined on a date when the organisation was not yet approved for that sub-category; the practical training record carries no assessor’s signature. Nothing this candidate learned is false, and everything he can prove is inadmissible. Knowing what an approved organisation must establish, document by document, before handing anything to a student, is knowing what the authority will recount behind him.
The school does not attest to knowledge, it attests to traceability
An organisation approved for basic training issues no licence and grants no exemption. It produces two things, and two only: a certificate of recognition of the training and examinations it has conducted, and the file that supports it — approved syllabus, attendance sheets, question papers drawn, marked scripts, practical assessment records. The competent authority, for its part, processes an application for a maintenance licence. What it examines is not the candidate’s actual level, which no document can measure, but the solidity of the chain running from the approved syllabus to the signature at the foot of the certificate.
The consequence is brutal and recurs regularly among the grounds for rejection: a certificate is never worth more than the approval that covered it on the day of the examination. An excellent organisation examining outside its scope produces a worthless document; a modest organisation, every link of which is dated and signed, produces a file that passes. What a student is buying is therefore not only teaching — he could find that elsewhere — it is the organisation’s ability to document that teaching in a form the authority agrees to recount.
The school doesn’t prove you know things—it proves it followed all the rules when teaching you. Every document must show the right approval was in place on the exact day you were examined, with proper signatures and dates. If one link in this chain is broken, your whole file might be rejected, even if you actually know the material.
A student passes a module on 15 March 2024 at an organisation approved for that sub-category. The school issues the certificate on 1 April 2024, but by then, the approval had been suspended for that module. The certificate is invalid because the approval wasn’t active on the examination date, even though the school was approved when the certificate was issued.
Approval scope, the first line to be recounted
A maintenance training organisation’s approval certificate says almost nothing on its own: everything hinges on the specifications appended to it. They list the categories and sub-categories covered, the modules actually authorised, the sites where training and examinations may be held, and the nature of the privileges — basic training, examinations, type training, or only part of that set. An organisation may be authorised to examine a module it does not teach, or to teach a module whose examination it cannot conduct. Both situations are lawful; they simply do not produce the same document.
Three checks are essential before any application. The exact category first: a certificate bearing one sub-category cannot be recycled into another, and the module devoted to aerodynamics, structures and systems exists in distinct versions depending on the sub-category targeted. The site next: an examination conducted somewhere other than an approved site, without the provisions set for remote sessions, is a classic oversight finding. The date above all: an approval lives, it extends, it is restricted, it is suspended. What matters is not the scope on the day the candidate applies, but the scope on the day he sat the examination.
From the approved syllabus to the question asked
The knowledge base is described module by module and category by category, with an expected level attached to each point. The first level requires only familiarisation: locate, recognise, know that the function exists. The second requires general knowledge: describe, explain a principle, apply a standard procedure. The third requires detailed knowledge: analyse, combine theoretical elements, reason about a case not covered in class. A single module title therefore changes entirely in nature depending on the category it serves, and that is what the audit checks first.
The organisation must establish a complete, two-way correspondence: from each syllabus point to the session that covers it, its duration and its support material; and from each point to the questions that assess it, at the required level. This matrix is among the most closely examined documents during an oversight visit, because it immediately reveals the two usual defects: a syllabus point taught but never assessed, and a question set at a level lower than the category requires — recall where the text demands analysis.
The question bank is itself an object of proof. The organisation must show how it is compiled, who can access it, how a paper is drawn and how a defective item is withdrawn: a question everyone answers correctly measures nothing, a question no one answers correctly mainly measures its own ambiguity. Statistical monitoring of items is not a pedagogical nicety, it is what allows the organisation to argue before the authority that a failure belongs to the candidate and not to a poorly worded question.
Multiple-choice tests work well for basic knowledge (level 1) and general knowledge (level 2). But for detailed knowledge (level 3), you need written answers or practical tests. A test where everyone gets the same answer right might mean the question is too easy or too vague, not that everyone actually knows the material.
For a Category B mechanic exam, a question asks: “Explain the torque sequence for removing a landing gear bolt.” A level 1 question would ask “Where is the torque wrench stored?” (locate). A level 2 question would ask “What is the correct torque value?” (describe). A level 3 question would ask “Analyze why the sequence matters if you skip a step” (analyze). Only level 3 can’t be tested with multiple choice.
The examination: conduct, separation of roles, minutes
The conduct of examinations follows written rules that the organisation must be able to show are applied, not merely drafted. Questionnaires include one correct answer and plausible distractors, a time allowance per question, and a single, high pass mark — of the order of three quarters of the points — that does not flex according to the perceived difficulty of the module. No reference material is allowed in the room. For mechanic categories, some modules add written questions marked against a model answer and written criteria: these are what allow checking what a questionnaire cannot see.
Two points regularly tip a file over. The first is separation of roles: whoever instructed a candidate in a subject must not be the one who examines him on that subject, and the organisation must be able to establish this through its staff assignments rather than merely assert it. The second is the session minutes: identity checked, opening and closing times, incidents recorded, scripts retained, result notified. A results sheet with no trace of the session that produced it proves nothing but its own existence.
Failures are documented too. A waiting period applies between two attempts, shorter when the candidate takes a course at the organisation and resumes instruction on the module concerned, longer after a series of consecutive failures. The sequence of attempts is part of the file and the authority reads it: a module passed a few days after a failure, at an organisation whose ordinary waiting period is longer, is an anomaly that calls for a written explanation.
Practical training, the link most often incomplete
For mechanic categories, basic training is not limited to theory. A practical component, conducted on real equipment or on representative means, must cover a set of tasks: removal and installation, visual inspection, measurement, wiring and crimping, braking and securing, application of a work card, use of maintenance documentation. Each task is recorded individually, with its date, the means used, the degree of autonomy — observed, performed under supervision, performed alone — and the signature of the authorised assessor.
This is where files become fragile, for reasons more material than pedagogical: bench availability, group rotation, an assessor’s occasional absence. The classic drift is to validate a list of tasks in one block at the end of the session, which produces records that look consistent but read as inconsistent: tasks signed on a day the workshop was closed, the same assessor signing simultaneously at two sites, a task requiring a means the organisation only acquired later. Cross-checking dates is among the least costly checks available to an authority, and among the most productive; it is also one a candidate can perform alone before applying.
Two routes to application, two different files
Two routes lead to a first application, and they do not produce the same file. The first goes through a complete basic course at an approved organisation: theory, examinations and practical training are all conducted under the same approval, and the resulting certificate recognises the whole. The second consists of working first and sitting the examinations as an independent candidate, at an organisation whose approval covers examination of the targeted modules, or under arrangements the authority organises itself. Both are admissible; they simply do not require the same amount of supporting experience, and they are not checked the same way.
The rule governing the gap can be stated in one sentence: the more the training received is documented under approval, the less experience is required. An approved basic course brings the requirement down to the shortest value provided — of the order of two years for mechanic categories; recognised prior technical training gives an intermediate value; the absence of both leads to the longest value, of the order of five years. These durations are not a favour scale: they exactly compensate for what the file does not contain.
| File element | Approved basic course | Examinations only, outside a course |
|---|---|---|
| Proof of theory | Certificate of recognition of training and examinations, module by module | Examination certificate only, with no recognition of training |
| Proof of practice | Record of tasks assessed and signed by the organisation | None: practical competence is demonstrated through maintenance experience |
| Supporting experience required | The shortest of the values provided, of the order of two years | The longest, of the order of five years, reduced if prior technical training is recognised |
| What the authority recounts first | Scope and dates of the approval, syllabus-to-examination matrix, practical records | The organisation’s examination scope, dates, then the entire experience logbook |
| Usual point of weakness | Practical training validated in one block and poorly dated | Descriptive logbook but not countersigned, or too generic |
| What drives the timeline | The length of the course, then the residual experience | Experience, with examinations slotted in alongside employment |
A third case deserves to be set apart, because it is the source of most disappointments: that of the holder of a national technical diploma who has been led to believe he ‘will get exemptions’. A module credit is not decided at a school’s front desk. It requires a formal comparison between the diploma’s content and the regulatory knowledge base, point by point and level by level, conducted at the authority’s level and thereafter binding on every organisation. As long as that comparison does not exist, the promise commits no one.
The trap of the promised exemption. No school grants examination credit. Ask what the claim rests on: an existing comparison report, published and dated, or a mere sales pitch. A candidate who has built his financing plan around modules he believed exempted, and discovers on enrolment that he must take them after all, loses several months and sometimes his entitlement to funding.
The validity window, the mechanism that catches out old files
Examination credits are not eternal. The text assigns them a period of validity — of the order of a decade — and that period is not counted from the end of the course, but backwards from the moment the application is processed. The window therefore slides with the filing date: a module passed very early and a file lodged very late never meet. The same reasoning applies to experience, a fraction of which must be recent: a dense logbook interrupted long ago does not satisfy the condition, even if the total is comfortably exceeded.
This mechanism explains refusals that look absurd from the outside. A candidate who spreads his modules over many years while working, then waits for a place in type training before applying, arrives with a theoretical base partly fallen out of the window. The text provides no seniority waiver; what exists is a resit, under the same conditions as the first time. The only variable a candidate keeps control of is the filing date: filing as soon as the conditions are met, without waiting for a type-training opportunity, keeps the window on the right side.
The trap of the two dates. The date that matters is not that of the certificate, it is that of the examination: it is what determines the applicable approval scope and the starting point of validity. Yet many certificates are issued weeks after the session, sometimes in a batch at the end of the course, and prominently display the issue date. Check that the examination date also appears there, module by module, before leaving the organisation.
One last, rarely anticipated side effect: the disappearance of the organisation. A properly issued certificate remains valid in principle if the organisation ceases activity, since it was produced under an approval then in force. But the documents that support it become inaccessible, and it takes only a discrepancy over the sub-category or an illegible date for the authority to ask for the underlying evidence. That is the most concrete reason to keep a copy of everything, including what seems incidental at the time.
What to cross-check in your own file
Before any application, four cross-checks can be made alone, without asking anyone, and they avoid most of the back-and-forth. The first compares the examination date shown on each certificate with the organisation’s approval scope on that date, sub-category included: this is the check that invalidates the most documents, and the only one that can never be fixed after the fact. The second compares the level at which each module was examined with the level the targeted category requires, line by line, without trusting the resemblance of titles. The third rereads the practical training record as a calendar rather than a list: does every task carry a date compatible with the assessor’s actual presence, with the workshop being open, with the availability of the means it requires? The fourth projects the validity window not from today, but from a realistic filing date, including the time to compile the file and the processing time, to know which modules will have fallen out of it by then. All of this comes down to rereading every document asking not whether it looks good, but who produced it and what the authority expects of it.

| Document | Produced by | What is recounted |
|---|---|---|
| Module certificate | Approved organisation | Category and sub-category, module and its version, examination date, approval reference in force that day |
| Practical training record | Organisation’s authorised assessor | Tasks covered, dates, means used, degree of autonomy, named signature |
| Session minutes and scripts | Approved organisation | Retention, sequence of attempts, separation between instructor and examiner |
| Experience logbook | Candidate, countersigned by the employer | Nature of the work, not only its duration, aircraft concerned, continuity, recent fraction |
| Recognition of a technical diploma | Competent authority | Correspondence of content and levels, never mere resemblance of titles |
| Maintenance licence | Competent authority | The whole chain, plus identity and the conditions specific to the category |
The right reflex. Build your mirror file as you go, never at the end. For each module passed, file the certificate after checking four fields: exact category and sub-category, module and its version, examination date distinct from the issue date, approval reference. Add the copy of the signed task record. A discrepancy is corrected within days while the organisation still remembers the session; it becomes intractable two years later, and unsolvable if the organisation has closed.
One grey area remains that no one will settle for you: bridges between categories. Module titles look alike from one category to the next, but the required level differs. A holder of a basic category who later targets a mechanic category sometimes discovers that his shared modules were examined at the lower level, and that he must resit what he believed he already held. The only way to know in advance is to compare, before enrolling, the level shown on the certificate with the level the targeted category requires — the organisation can tell you, but the question must be put in those terms rather than in terms of titles. Exchanges between practitioners on these bridges, on the FL330 forum, are often worth more than a brochure.
For anyone preparing a type rating, finally, one thing must be clear: type training makes up for none of the base. It is added to an already issued licence, or to a basic file already admissible, and it is lost if the base does not hold. The order of construction is therefore not negotiable, and it is that order which must be settled before choosing an organisation, just as much as the schedule of FL330 training pathways.
The applicable regulation, the specifications appended to the organisation’s approval, and the competent authority’s instructions prevail over this article, which describes a general mechanism: neither a given organisation’s manual, nor a training office’s local practice, nor the age of a habit, take their place.
Questions fréquentes
My school lost its approval after my exams: are my certificates now void?
No. A certificate issued under an approval in force on the day of the examination keeps its value, even if the organisation later ceases activity. The risk is not validity but access to the underlying documents: if the authority asks for the session minutes or the practical record, no one will be able to produce them any more. That is why you must request and keep your copies during the course, not afterwards.
Can I sit examinations at an approved organisation without taking its course?
Yes, if its approval covers examination of the targeted modules: this option exists and is commonly used. The resulting file then proves the examination, not the training, and it contains no practical training record. As a result, the longest experience requirement applies, unless prior technical training is recognised by the authority.
Does a certificate obtained for one category count for another?
Not automatically, even when the module bears the same title. The knowledge base sets a different level depending on the targeted category, and a module examined at the lower level does not satisfy the requirement of a higher category. Compare the level shown on your certificate with the level the category you are targeting requires before enrolling for a top-up.
How long do my modules remain usable?
Examination credits have a limited period of validity, of the order of a decade, and it is counted backwards from the processing of the application, not from the end of the course. A late filing can therefore push the earliest modules out of the window, with no possible waiver. The exact rule appears in the applicable text and in your authority’s instructions: check it before delaying a filing to wait for type training.
How can I know the examiner was not my instructor?
The organisation must be able to establish this through its staff assignments, and it is a point examined during oversight. On the candidate’s side, the session minutes and the results sheet normally carry the name of the invigilator and of the marker, which you can compare with that of your instructor for the subject concerned. If these names match, ask for a written explanation before filing your application: better to deal with it while it is fresh than at the processing stage.

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.