Competency check and offline check: two exercises, two distinct purposes

Poste instructeur d'un simulateur, deux chaises vides devant des pupitres éteints et casques accrochés

A co-pilot exits a session with a renewed type rating valid for twelve months, only to be removed from the schedule the following week: their line check had expired. The reverse also happens—a successful line check has never extended a rating by a single day. Both exercises often take place in the same simulator, sometimes on the same day, in front of the same person; yet they serve different purposes, have different evaluators, and different outcomes. Understanding what each proves, and why neither can substitute for the other, avoids costly surprises in scheduling and recruitment.

Two regulatory frameworks, two questions asked

The proficiency check answers a question posed by the aircrew licensing regulation: does the holder still meet the standard of their type rating? The exercise belongs to the world of aeronautical certification. It is conducted by an authorized examiner, whose act binds the authority that authorized them, and it concludes—when successful—with a signature on the license and a report. The current employer is not part of the equation: a pilot without a contract can renew their type rating.

The line check answers a question posed by the air operations regulation: does this crew know how to execute the normal, abnormal, and emergency procedures of this operator, as described in its manual? The exercise belongs to the operator’s training and evaluation program, detailed in the dedicated section of its operations manual and validated by the authority. It cannot exist without an operator, and it is recorded in a file maintained by the operator—not on the license.

Two parallel regulatory chainsLicence chain: type rating, proficiency check, endorsement of the licence. Operations chain: manual, off-line check, operator’s records. A dashed line separates them, with no bridge.Licence axis — follows the pilotQualificationProficiency checkLicence endorsementOperations axis — stays with the operatorManuelOff-line checkDossier exploitantNo automatic bridge from one chain to the other
Two chains that never touch. An examiner’s endorsement on the licence on one side, an entry in the operator’s records on the other: neither outcome has the effect of the other.

The confusion arises from the shared surface: same cockpit, same simulated failures, often similar scenarios. But one assesses a license holder against the standard of their type rating, while the other assesses a link in the operator’s system against the standard of that system. The two verdicts do not apply to the same object.

The proficiency check is about whether a pilot meets the general flying standards for their aircraft type, while the line check is about whether they follow their airline’s specific procedures. One is for the pilot’s license, the other is for the airline’s rules. They’re different tests with different goals.

A pilot flying an Airbus A320 passes their proficiency check with perfect flight performance, but fails their line check because they didn’t use the airline’s exact checklist wording during an engine failure drill. The flight skills were fine, but the procedure adherence wasn’t.

The same action, two possible outcomes

The evaluation criteria make all the difference. In the proficiency check, the crew is assessed against the standardized program of the type rating: trajectory tolerances, takeoff failure management, instrument approach with one engine out, go-around—items defined at the regulatory level, identical across operators. In the line check, the same crew is assessed against the operator’s documentation: standard announcements, task distribution, use of checklists, stabilization criteria, automation policy.

Hence a situation every instructor has encountered: a technically flawless go-around—trajectory held, speeds within tolerances—that fully meets the certification standard, but whose announcements do not match the manual, or whose task distribution contradicts the airline’s procedures. The same action passes one check and fails the other, without contradiction: they measure different things. Knowing how to fly and knowing how to operate for a given operator are two skills that overlap, but never completely.

Proficiency check and off-line check: a point-by-point comparison
Aspect Proficiency check Off-line check
Corpus d’origine Aircrew licensing regulation Air operations regulation
Question asked Does the holder meet the standard of their rating? Does the crew meet this operator’s standard?
Assessment standard Standardised rating check programme Operations manual, procedures and approved programme
Who conducts it Authorised examiner, by delegation from the authority Personnel nominated and trained by the operator
Where it is recorded On the licence, with a report In the training records kept by the operator
Validity cycle Twelve months for a multi-pilot rating Six calendar months
Effect of a failure Rating not revalidated: retraining then a new check Removed from line flying: retraining under the operator’s programme
Portability Follows the pilot, whoever the employer Stays with the operator, to be redone with the next one

Who conducts the exercise, and in whose name

The proficiency check requires an examiner holding the corresponding authorization. Their legitimacy comes from the authority: it authorized them, they answer to its standards, and they sign for it. The line check, however, is conducted in the operator’s name by personnel designated and trained by the operator: often examiners, but also, depending on the framework, instructors or captains qualified for evaluation—including non-technical skills, which weigh heavily in the exercise. What grants legitimacy is not the examiner authorization: it is the operator’s designation and training in its framework.

In a combined session, the same person thus holds two roles, with two distinct responsibilities and two different avenues for appeal. Cabin crew experience a similar duality, between the attestation that follows the individual and the recurrent checks specific to each operator: the two-tier logic applies to the entire crew.

Two clocks that do not beat the same measure

The multi-pilot type rating is renewed by proficiency check on a twelve-month cycle. The line check operates on a six-month calendar cycle. For reference, the line training check also has a twelve-month cycle—three clocks for a single pilot. The anticipation mechanism is the same everywhere: an exercise passed in the window before the deadline extends the new period from the deadline, not from the session date. This keeps annual deadlines stable rather than shifting upstream.

Two validity cycles over twenty-four monthsAxis graduated from 0 to 24 months: the type rating in two twelve-month blocks, the off-line check in four six-month blocks. The due dates coincide at twelve and twenty-four months, where the combined session becomes possible.Type rating — 12-month cycleOff-line check — 6-month cyclealigned due dates: combined session06121824mois
Four operator checks for two revalidations. The six-month cycle crosses the twelve-month one; the due dates align every other time and open the combined session. The triangles mark the exercises.

The arithmetic consequence is visible on the timeline: four line checks for two type rating renewals over twenty-four months. One session in two can be combined with the proficiency check; the other is purely operator-specific. It is this intermediate session, without license implications, that personal tracking most often overlooks—and its deadline closes the line just as firmly as the other.

The trap: inferring flight readiness from the license. A perfectly up-to-date license says nothing about the line check deadline, which runs twice as fast; and a successful line check has never renewed a type rating. The two tracks are distinct, and the gap usually surfaces at the worst time: during scheduling or in front of a recruiter.

The combined session: one session, two acts

Regulation allows covering both programs in a single session, and many operators organize one of their two annual appointments this way. The savings are real: one simulator slot, one scenario designed to cover both the certification items and the operator’s requirements. But the combination is physical, not legal. The session produces two distinct acts: the examiner’s signature renewing the type rating, with its report, and the line check entry in the operator’s training file. Each has its own record, deadlines, and chain of transmission—and if one is missing, the corresponding act does not exist, regardless of the session’s quality.

The combined session produces two separate actsA single box, the simulator session, sends two arrows to two boxes: at the top the revalidated rating and the endorsed licence, at the bottom the off-line check entered in the operator’s records.Singlesimulatorsessionone examiner,two hatsActe licence :rating revalidated,licence endorsedActe exploitant :off-line checkentered in the recordsEach act leaves its own record; if one is missing, the act does not exist
The combination is practical, never legal. A single session covers both programmes, but it produces two separate acts, each with its own record — endorsement on the licence on one side, operator’s records on the other.

The right reflex: after a combined session, verify before leaving the center that the license is signed and the operator’s file is updated, with both new deadlines recalculated. Thirty seconds of review against discovering an administrative gap six months later, the day it blocks a schedule.

Failure does not look the same

If the proficiency check is failed, the type rating is not renewed. The license remains, but the privileges of the rating expire at the deadline: retraining is required, tailored to the identified gaps, followed by a new check with an examiner. After the deadline, renewal is not an option—only a full renewal, calibrated in particular by the duration of the expiration.

If the line check is failed, the license is not affected. The operator acts: removal from the line, retraining according to its program, and a new check before resuming flights. The two paths do not communicate mechanically—one repairs a license, the other an employment right—but they observe each other: repeated operator failures eventually question the maintenance of the certification standard, and the operator’s tracking system is designed to flag such signals.

Two failures, two consequencesOn the left, proficiency check failure: retraining, then a new check with an examiner; the effect falls on the licence. On the right, off-line check failure: removal from line flying, retraining with the operator; the effect falls on the job.Proficiencycheck failedRating not revalidated,retrainingNew checkwith an examinerThe effect falls on the licenceOff-line checkfailedRemoved from line flyingby the operatorRetraining under theoperator's programmeThe effect falls on the job
Two failures, two remedies. One is remedied with an examiner, the other within the operator’s programme; neither settles the other.

What follows the pilot, what stays with the operator

The type rating travels with its holder. Resignation, contract termination, leave: none of this affects the certification as long as deadlines are met, and a pilot without an employer can renew their type rating by booking a session with an examiner. The line check, however, is not transferable. It belongs to the operator’s system that conducted it, and the file remains with the operator upon the pilot’s departure.

What follows the pilot, what stays with the operatorTwo horizontal bands over time. The licence band is continuous from end to end. The off-line check band stops at the change of operator, marked by a dashed vertical line, and only resumes after the new operator’s conversion course.Changement d’exploitantLicence and rating — follow the pilotOff-line check — tied to the operatorno line flyingThe check record stayswith the operator left behindParcours d’adaptation :training, off-linecheck, line flying under supervision
The licence travels, the record stays. When changing operator, the licence and its rating follow the pilot without interruption; the off-line check is interrupted and only resumes at the end of the new operator’s conversion course.

Hence a counterintuitive situation for recruiters: a candidate “perfectly up-to-date” in terms of certification has no right to fly the line on their first day. They need the operator’s adaptation process—ground and simulator training on in-house procedures, line check, supervised line flights, line training check—regardless of their experience on the type. And for pilots flying for multiple operators, secondment or seasonal contracts, the default rule remains one file per operator; recognition mechanisms between operators exist, but they are built and approved, never assumed.

What evidence-based training shifts

Programs based on evidence replace the annual repetition of the same items with the observation of competencies in scenarios representative of real operations. Training and evaluation are intertwined to the point that the boundary between a check session and a training session becomes less clear for the crew experiencing it.

The duality, however, remains intact. Even in the most integrated program, something must renew the type rating on the license, and something must attest to the operator’s standard—two legal effects that the pedagogical form does not merge. It is precisely in these programs that the traceability of the two acts deserves the most attention: the less the two checks are distinguishable in the session experience, the more they must be distinguishable in the records.

Three lines to check in your own tracking

First check: your deadlines, tracked separately. The operator’s tracking system manages them, but data entry errors exist, and the license holder remains responsible for the validity of what they exercise. A personal tracking system that distinguishes type rating, line check, and line training check—three lines, three dates—costs little and saves much.

Two pilots in a cockpit at dusk, one operating controls and the other holding a checklist.
Checklists ensure accuracy in critical operations.
  • Second check: consistency after each combined session—two records, two recalculated deadlines, as described above.
  • Third check: local terminology. From one operator to another, the same exercise is called line check, operator check, recurrent session, or bears a proprietary acronym; it is the training section of the operations manual that defines what each term covers, and which of your deadlines it feeds.

A gray area that everyone benefits from clarifying for their own case: bridges between operators—recognition of a check conducted elsewhere, shared files within a group, crews on secondment. These arrangements exist, but they are based on formalized agreements accepted by the authority, never on assumption. Those preparing an examiner authorization or taking up a designated manager position are well advised to know exactly what their operator’s documentation allows—and what it omits.

The preceding developments describe general mechanisms. The applicable regulations, their compliance means, and your operator’s approved documentation—operations manual first and foremost—prevail in all circumstances over this article: it is there, and nowhere else, that your programs, standards, and exact deadlines are found.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.