Three weeks of line checks for an operator registered in Ireland, rotations that never touched French soil, a contract amendment signed in Dubai, and an invoice issued by a sole trader based in the Paris region: should value added tax be charged on it? The question comes up on every assignment outside France, and the answer is found neither on the flight plan nor on the aircraft’s registration. It rests on a connecting rule that sovereignly ignores where the aircraft flew.
One assignment, three locations that do not coincide
Three questions, and each has its own rule. The first asks which State collects value added tax. The second asks which State may tax the profit earned on the assignment. The third asks which social security legislation applies while it is being carried out. The three answers rarely land in the same place, and the most widespread mistake is to settle the first and then assume the other two follow.
Take the opening case again. For VAT, the service is deemed to be located where the customer is established, therefore in Ireland, and nobody collects French VAT. For income tax, the profit remains taxable where the business is established, in France, as long as no fixed place of business has been created elsewhere. For social security affiliation, European coordination deems a crew member’s activity to be pursued in the State where their home base is, which may perfectly well be a third country. One invoice, three connecting factors, three different administrations facing you.
The place where a service is taxed, where profits are taxed, and where social security applies are three different things. They don’t always match, and you have to check each one separately.
A French instructor flies a line check for an Irish operator in Spain. The VAT is Irish (customer’s country), the profit is taxed in France (supplier’s country), and social security is paid in the UK (home base).
The general rule: the customer decides
For a supply of services to a taxable person, the place of taxation is where that customer has established the seat of their economic activity, or that of the fixed establishment to which the service is supplied. Supplied to a non-taxable person, the same service is located where the supplier is established. The whole reasoning turns on that switch, and it depends neither on the place of performance, nor on the nationality of the aircraft, nor on the operator’s flag.
Two clarifications settle half of all cases. The first: the customer is the party that contracts, not the party that benefits from the work. An instructor who flies for a Gulf operator but whose contract is signed with a placement agency established in the United Kingdom has the agency as customer, and the connecting factor follows the contractual chain, not the seat occupied on board. The second: taxable-person status must be demonstrated, it is not presumed. A customer who has never provided an identification number, or whose number returns no answer in the European database, is treated, in the absence of other supporting evidence, as a non-taxable person.
| Customer | Service deemed located | On the invoice | Reporting that follows |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taxable operator established in another Member State | At the customer’s place | No French VAT, both identification numbers, reverse charge wording | Services declaration for the month of invoicing |
| Taxable operator established outside the Union | At the customer’s place | No French VAT, evidence of taxable-person status kept on file | No services declaration, accounting records only |
| Taxable person established in France, assignment performed abroad | In France | French VAT at the rate applicable to the service | Usual VAT return |
| French fixed establishment of a foreign operator, actual beneficiary of the service | In France | French VAT, despite the foreign letterhead on the contract | Usual VAT return |
| Non-taxable customer established in the Union (private owner, unidentified structure) | At the supplier’s place | French VAT | Usual VAT return |
The notion of a customer’s fixed establishment deserves a word, because it reverses the reasoning. If the foreign operator has in France a permanent structure with human and technical resources, and it is that structure which receives the service, the VAT becomes French again. The case is met on operating bases opened in the regions: the contract is signed with the foreign head office, but the assignment order, the operational supervision and the logistics come from the French base. The connecting factor follows the actual beneficiary, not the letterhead on the paper.
The services where physical location takes back control
The general rule has exceptions, and the sector concentrates several of them. They have one point in common: they hand control back to geography, either because the service is consumed on the spot or because it is inseparable from a property or a journey.
| Service | What determines the place | What it requires of the supplier |
|---|---|---|
| Passenger transport | The distances covered, leg by leg | Break the price down by leg instead of applying a single regime to the whole rotation |
| Short-term hire of a means of transport | The place where the aircraft is actually put at the customer’s disposal, short-term being assessed against a threshold set by the legislation | Look at the place where the aircraft is handed over, never the destination of the flight nor the lessor’s seat |
| Right of admission to an educational or scientific event | The place where the event is held, whether the customer is a taxable person or not | Check whether the host country requires local registration before issuing the admissions |
| Service connected with immovable property (hangar, fixed installation) | The place where the property is located | Attach the service to the country of the hangar, whatever the seats of the two parties |
| Training supplied to a non-taxable customer | The place where the training is physically carried out | Handle the VAT in the country where the session is held, and not in that of one’s own seat |
The line that costs the most is the last one: the one separating a right of admission to an event from a bespoke training service. A simulator session sold to an identified operator, under contract, with a programme aligned on its procedures, remains a supply of services governed by the general rule — it is located at the customer’s place, whether the device stands in Madrid or in Miami. Individual enrolment in an open seminar, on the other hand, invoiced like an admission ticket, is located where the seminar is held. Same instructor, same simulator hall, two regimes: it is the nature of the contract that decides, never the address of the building.
Invoicing correctly: wording, numbers and reporting
An invoice that is correct in substance can be defective in form, and an audit starts with the form because it can be checked without argument. On a reverse-charged service to a taxable person in another Member State, the invoice carries both identification numbers, no VAT, and explicit wording stating that the tax is due by the customer. Towards a customer established outside the Union, there is no European number to display, but you must be able to produce evidence of their taxable-person status: certificate of liability to tax, extract from the local register, tax certificate.
Then comes the obligation that self-employed people discover at their first audit: the declaration of services supplied to taxable customers in other Member States, filed with the customs administration for the month in which the invoice is issued. It is not linked to the payment of the tax — nobody pays it in France — but to European cross-checking. A supplier who applies the reverse charge correctly and declares nothing remains in breach, and the discrepancy shows up immediately since the client, for their part, declares the tax they have reverse-charged.
The trap. Charging French VAT “to be on the safe side” to a foreign operator costs more than not charging it. Tax mentioned on an invoice is owed by whoever mentioned it, even if it was not chargeable: it goes to the Treasury. The client, for their part, cannot deduct it since it was not lawfully claimed from them, and will ask you for a credit note. Putting it right requires a corrective invoice and, in practice, the actual repayment of the amount to the client before any offset — that “caution” is paid for twice.
The right reflex. Check the customer’s identification number in the European database before the first invoice, keep the dated screenshot of the answer with the contract, and repeat the check at every renewal of the assignment. An identification valid at signature can be withdrawn during the year; what counts is validity on the date of the service, and it is up to you to be able to prove it.
The small-business VAT exemption relieves you of none of this, and that is the second blind spot. A micro-entrepreneur who charges no VAT on the domestic market must nevertheless obtain an identification number as soon as they supply a service to a taxable person in another Member State, include the reverse charge wording, file the services declaration, and — symmetrically — reverse-charge the tax themselves on the services they buy abroad: training, flight preparation subscription, data hosting. The exemption bears on taxable turnover, not on identification obligations.
Expenses, per diem and disbursements: what goes into the taxable amount
A distant assignment almost always mixes fees and expenses, and the principle is as simple as it is regularly ignored: whatever is re-invoiced to the client follows the regime of the main service. A hotel night re-invoiced is not a hotel night, it is a fraction of the price of the assignment; it takes on its place of taxation and its rate. If the assignment is reverse-charged, so are the expenses. If it is taxable in France, the expenses bear VAT at the rate of the service, and not at that of hotel accommodation or transport.
The disbursement is the exception, and a narrow one: the expense must have been incurred in the name and on behalf of the client, the supporting document must be made out in their name, reimbursement must be claimed to the exact euro and the amount must, in principle, be tracked in a suspense account. A ticket bought in your own name, even re-invoiced identically, is not a disbursement. As for the per diem paid to a self-employed person, it is not an allowance but an element of the price: it enters the taxable amount just as the flight hour does.
Income tax, withholding tax and the home base
Once VAT is settled, two questions remain open, and they are not handled with the same texts. The profit earned on an assignment abroad remains taxable where the business is established, unless the supplier sets up a fixed place of business there: premises, a habitual presence, an organisation of its own. Tax treaties set the criteria, often in terms of duration and regularity, and those criteria vary from one treaty to another. It is not a universal threshold that must be sought, but that of the treaty applicable between the two States concerned.
The subject that surprises most is withholding tax. Several States levy a withholding on sums paid to a non-resident supplier, whatever the place of performance, and the principal applies it mechanically because they are liable for it. The treaty generally allows it to be avoided or credited, but on one material condition: producing a certificate of tax residence before payment. Requested after the event, it opens a lengthy refund procedure, in a language that is not yours, for an amount already collected by a foreign treasury.
There remains the social security side, which obeys yet another logic. For a crew member, European coordination attaches the activity to the home base, a notion inherited from flight time regulations and not from tax law. The document certifying the applicable legislation is requested before departure, not on return: it is the only paper that stops a demand for contributions in the State of activity. For a self-employed person working in several States with no identifiable base, the determination falls to the institution of the place of residence, which rules on the basis of the activity as a whole and not assignment by assignment.
What to check in your own file
Three checks are worth making before the next invoice, and none of them requires outside advice.

- The contractual chain: reread the letterhead of the contract rather than the name painted on the tail. The customer is the legal entity that signs and pays, and it alone fixes the place of taxation.
- The trace of the check: a dated screenshot of the answer obtained on the identification number, filed with the contract. Without it, good faith can be pleaded but not proved.
- Consistency between the invoiced object and the reality of the assignment: “training service”, “supply of staff” and “line check” do not describe the same operation, and an accommodating wording becomes evidence against you the day the classification is disputed.
A grey area remains, and it is not a tax one. The supply of staff follows, for VAT purposes, the same general rule as a supply of services: same connecting factor, same reverse charge, no invoicing difficulty. But a correctly applied VAT regime in no way validates the arrangement on the ground of employment law. A self-employed person integrated into an operator’s roster, its operations manual and its chain of command shows the classic indicators of a relationship of subordination, and reclassification is then played out neither before the tax administration nor on the invoice. It is the most frequent blind spot among crew members who move into self-employment: they optimise the invoice and neglect the contract that underpins it. The discussions in the FL330 community provide several illustrations of this every season.
For anyone preparing the move into self-employment, the practical consequence is clear: the structure of the contract weighs as much as the hourly rate. Before signing with an intermediary, four questions are enough to frame the file — who is legally the customer, which identification number they provide, which withholding tax regime applies in the State of payment, and which home base will be declared. The four answers fit on one page and avoid most reassessments; they arise just as much ahead of a one-off assignment as ahead of a long-term engagement on an assignment platform.
This article sets out a mechanism, it replaces no text: the applicable regulation, the doctrine of the administration you come under, the tax treaty binding the two States and the clauses of the contract you sign prevail over what is written here, and are authoritative in the event of divergence.
Questions fréquentes
Must French VAT be charged to an operator established outside the European Union?
No, if that customer is a taxable person: the service is deemed located at their place and falls outside the scope of French VAT. You must, on the other hand, keep on file the evidence of their taxable-person status — certificate of liability to tax, register extract, tax certificate — because no European number will establish it. The European services declaration does not cover those transactions, but they must remain identifiable in the accounts.
Does the small-business VAT exemption remove the obligation to file the European services declaration?
Yes. As soon as a service is supplied to a taxable person established in another Member State, you must apply for an identification number, put the reverse charge wording on the invoice and file the declaration for the month of invoicing. The exemption relieves you of collecting VAT on the domestic market, never of registering or declaring. The symmetry also applies on the purchase side: services acquired abroad must be reverse-charged.
What happens when French VAT has been charged “to be on the safe side” to a customer in another Member State?
Tax mentioned on an invoice is owed by whoever mentioned it: it goes to the Treasury even though it was not chargeable. The client cannot deduct it in their country and will claim a credit note from you. Putting it right requires a corrective invoice and the actual repayment of the amount to the client, a condition without which the offset is refused.
Is a simulator session carried out abroad taxable in the country of the simulator?
Not if it is sold under contract to a taxable operator with a programme adapted to its procedures: it is then a supply of services governed by the general rule, located at the customer’s place. It switches to the place of the event if it is sold as a right of admission to an open session, on the model of an admission ticket. The distinction rests on the nature of the contract, not on the location of the device.
After how long does a repeated intervention in a country make the profit taxable there?
There is no universal duration: each tax treaty sets its own criteria for a fixed place of business, in terms of duration as much as of regularity of presence. What triggers the connection is the existence of a material base or a habitual presence, not the mere accumulation of days. The only reliable answer is read in the treaty binding your State of residence to the one where you operate.
Must the per diem paid by the operator appear on the invoice?
Yes, as an element of the price. A self-employed person does not receive an assignment allowance within the meaning of employment law: the sum is the consideration for their service and enters the taxable amount, at the regime and the rate of the assignment. Only an expense incurred in the client’s name, evidenced by a document made out in their name and reimbursed to the exact euro, can be treated as a disbursement.

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.