Alternate Aerodrome: A Numerical Rule Versus a Planning Logic

Composite radar météorologique sur un écran de préparation, vu de biais

The destination TAF forecasts 2,500 ft and 8 km, with a temporary group at 900 ft and 2,500 m that encroaches on the estimated time of arrival. Is an alternate required? The answer does not depend on the weather alone, but on the system under which the flight is prepared: on one side a numerical threshold, single and binary; on the other a cluster of cumulative conditions and a scale of minima degradation. Same protected landing, preparation effort placed elsewhere.

Two questions, never just one

Every alternate regulation answers two distinct questions, and most misunderstandings come from conflating them. The first is a question of applicability: must this flight carry a destination alternate? The second is a question of qualification: can this particular aerodrome be retained, given what is forecast to be found there at the time the flight would arrive? The first is a gate, whose result is read on a single document. The second is a filter: genuinely usable approach, runway, hours, forecast, compared against a scale.

The two systems answer both questions, but do not invest the same effort in each. The American system puts its simplicity into the first and pushes the second onto operations specifications, in the form of a flat increment added to published minima. The European system makes the first hard to clear and writes the second into the regulation itself, making it enforceable and auditable. This shift decides who does the work, at what point, and what is left in writing.

The exemption: a threshold on one side, a cluster on the other

On the American side, the so-called 1-2-3 rule fits in one sentence: no alternate is required if, from one hour before to one hour after the estimated time of arrival, the ceiling reaches 2,000 ft above the aerodrome and visibility reaches 3 statute miles. Nothing about the available approach, nothing about the number of runways, nothing about flight duration. The test is absolute: it refers to no published minimum. In other categories of operation, the construction becomes relative: the threshold is no longer read as an absolute value but as an increment above the lowest published minima at the aerodrome. The spirit does not change — a single test, settled on a single document.

A man in a suit stands before a large screen displaying financial charts, with an airport control tower and a plane on the runway visible in the background at dusk.
Planning logic ensures safety when numerical rules fail.

On the European side, the exemption is cumulative. The reference construction requires, over the same two-hour window, a ceiling of at least 2,000 ft or the circling height increased by 500 ft if that is more restrictive, ground visibility of at least 5 km, two separate runways available and usable, and a flight duration not exceeding six hours. Added to this is the case of the isolated aerodrome, for which no adequate alternate exists.

The two exemption thresholds in the visibility-ceiling planeVisibility is plotted on the horizontal axis, from zero to eight kilometres, and ceiling on the vertical axis, from zero to three thousand feet. The American visibility threshold, three statute miles or roughly four point eight kilometres, and the European threshold, five kilometres, fall almost at the same point; the reference ceiling, two thousand feet, is identical on both sides. The exemption region is therefore nearly the same. The example’s dominant forecast sits inside it, while the temporary group is far outside. The two conditions that truly separate the systems, number of runways and flight duration, are not shown in this plane.ceiling (ft)3,0002,0001,0002468visibility (km)3 SM ≈ 4.8 km5 kmexemption possibledominant forecastsame reference ceilingactual gap between the two thresholdstemporary groupoutside both regionsoutside this plane: two separate runways, flight duration
The two weather thresholds fall almost at the same point. Three statute miles equal roughly 4.8 km, and the reference ceiling is identical: on the weather alone, the gap in severity between the two systems amounts to a few hundred metres of visibility. What separates them — two separate runways, a capped flight duration — is not shown in this plane.

The key difference between American and European rules isn’t the weather thresholds, which are nearly identical. Instead, Europe requires two separate runways and limits flight duration to six hours. These extra conditions make the system more complex but also more resilient to unexpected problems.

An Airbus A320 flying from Paris to Rome (2h30 flight) with a planned arrival at 14:00 UTC. The Rome TAF shows 2,500 ft ceiling and 8 km visibility, but a TEMPO group predicts 900 ft and 2,500 m from 13:30 to 14:30. Under European rules, this temporary group falls within the two-hour window, so an alternate is required. Under American rules, the dominant forecast (2,500 ft/8 km) would exempt the flight, but the TEMPO group would require an alternate if it overlapped the window.

Placed side by side, the two weather bars nearly overlap: a few hundred metres of difference in visibility, and nothing at all on the ceiling. The difference is finer than the resolution of the message used to settle it, since a forecast announces neither visibility to the metre nor ceiling to the nearest ten feet. Believing that Europe is stricter on the weather is therefore a misreading: it is stricter on something else, and that is where the preparation effort is spent.

The most interesting point on this list is not meteorological. The two separate runways and the capped duration do not speak to the weather: they speak to the aerodrome’s resilience to a single blockage, and to the gap between the moment a decision is made and the moment it is suffered. Europe refuses to base an exemption on the forecast alone; the United States assumes it is sufficient and compensates through the culture of the flight dispatcher.

The two constructions of the destination alternate exemption
Element of the test Single threshold Cumulative conditions
Window one hour before to one hour after the estimated time of arrival identical
Ceiling 2,000 ft above the aerodrome 2,000 ft, or circling height increased by 500 ft if more restrictive
Visibility 3 statute miles 5 km on the ground
Infrastructure no requirement two separate runways available and usable
Flight duration no requirement capped at six hours
Special case referred to operations specifications isolated aerodrome with no adequate alternate

The two-hour window, and how to read it

The two systems share the same window, one hour before and one hour after the estimated time of arrival. The divergence is not about its boundaries, but about how a forecast message is read within it.

Europe publishes an applicability grid that states, group by group, what counts for planning and what may be disregarded: a deterioration announced in BECMG or in TEMPO must in principle be taken into account, whereas a deterioration carried by a probability group may, in the cases the grid provides for, be set aside. The result is reproducible — two preparers reading the same message with the same grid produce the same file. The American text has no equally formalised equivalent: reading caution is carried by the flight dispatcher, in-house training, and operations specifications. Practical convergence is real; traceability is less so.

Reading the forecast within the two-hour windowA time axis carries the window running from one hour before to one hour after the estimated time of arrival. A solid bar represents the dominant forecast, well above the thresholds. A shorter dashed bar represents a temporary deterioration group that overlaps part of the window. The exemption threshold is therefore no longer held throughout the period.examination windowdominant forecast: 2,500 ft, 8 kmtemporary group: 900 ft, 2,500 mtimeETA − 1 hETAETA + 1 hthe deterioration enters the window: the threshold is no longer held
The test is based on the worst applicable condition within the window, not on the dominant forecast. It only takes a change group to overlap part of the period for the exemption to fall away. And the window is anchored to the arrival time: it moves with any delay.

The trap: the window follows the arrival time, not the filing time. A forty-minute delay at departure shifts the period to be examined by the same amount, and can bring in the temporary deterioration that was left outside at the time of the calculation. A file that is compliant at six hours no longer is at seven, and no one automatically redoes the test. A second, more mundane trap: reading the dominant group and ignoring the change groups, when both systems reason on the worst applicable condition within the window.

Qualifying the alternate: the degradation scale

Once an alternate is required, one must be chosen. This is where Europe spends its ink, with a scale whose logic is very physical: an aerodrome is never planned on what it offers at its best, but one notch above on the minima scale.

The justification is solid. One arrives at the alternate without having planned to, often after the event that caused the diversion — a failure, a blocked runway, degraded landing capacity. Planning on the lowest minima amounts to betting on exactly what may have just been lost. A Category II or III approach is therefore never planned: it requires an aircraft, a crew, and an aerodrome all qualified at the moment of arrival, which no forecast can guarantee.

The degradation scale for planning minimaVertical scale of minima, from Category III at the bottom to increased non-precision approach at the top. Three columns: a solid dot at the level of the capability actually available at the alternate, an arrow rising one notch, and an open square marking the minima retained at filing.minima scaleCat IIICat IICat INPANPA+Cat IICat INPAcapability actually available at the alternate aerodrome
An alternate is never planned on what it offers at its best, but one notch above. Solid dot: capability available. Open square: minima retained at filing. The arrow pays in advance for the degradation that caused the diversion.
The European scale of planning minima applied to the alternate
Approach usable at the alternate Minima retained at filing What the margin pays for
Category II or III Category I minima the loss of an aircraft, crew, or aerodrome qualification
Category I non-precision approach minima failure of the precision guidance aid
Non-precision approach increased minima, on the order of 200 ft and 1,000 m forecast error and loss of vertical guidance
Mandatory circling circling minima nothing: the margin is already built into the procedure

The right instinct: read the alternate’s card before its weather. The scale starts from the approach that will actually be usable, not the one printed on the chart. A precision guidance aid declared unserviceable by NOTAM drops the aerodrome down one further notch, and a forecast ceiling that used to be sufficient no longer is. Checking availability before the forecast avoids redoing the calculation twice, and above all redoing it at the wrong moment.

Before the weather, the aerodrome: adequate, then usable

European terminology distinguishes two states that practice tends to blend together. An adequate aerodrome is conceivable in the abstract: runway dimensions and strength compatible with the aircraft, air traffic services, lighting, communication facilities, sufficient rescue category, published approach procedure. The assessment is made cold, outside of any flight, and takes the form of a list maintained by the operator. A usable aerodrome is an adequate aerodrome that is forecast, for the time in question, to be open and to have weather at the required level.

The distinction has concrete consequences. An aerodrome that ticks every box except its opening hours is not an alternate, even under a clear blue sky. The rescue and firefighting category may be accepted at a level below the alternate’s own, under conditions the operator has had approved — but one still needs to know by how many notches, and for how long. Curfew, de-icing, ground handling, and fuelling are not all regulatory matters, but anyone diverting to an aerodrome without handling quickly discovers that compliance is not the same as availability. On the American side, the same logic runs through the list of authorised aerodromes rather than through a pair of definitions.

What the alternate costs in fuel

Choosing an alternate means signing off on a line of fuel: a missed approach at destination, climb, cruise, and descent to the alternate, approach, and landing. Final reserve fuel — on the order of thirty minutes holding at 1,500 ft above the aerodrome in standard atmosphere for a turbine aeroplane — is calculated above the alternate, not the destination. A distant alternate therefore moves two items at once.

The case of the isolated aerodrome reverses the reasoning: for lack of an adequate alternate, no alternate fuel is carried, but a supplement sized in time, on the order of two hours of normal cruise for a turbine aeroplane. The calculation stops being geographic and becomes temporal. Europe names this case and quantifies it; the United States handles it through operations specifications, in-flight redispatch, and the rules specific to extended diversion time flights. Where one writes an exception, the other writes a procedure.

Near or distant alternate: what each choice actually buys
Criterion Near alternate Distant alternate
Fuel committed low high, taken from payload
Weather correlation with the destination strong: the same system covers both weak: that is where the real margin lies
In-flight decision time short, the decision is made late long, it is made early and is hard to undo
Acceptance if the destination closes saturated by other diversions generally available
What is bought flexibility weather independence

Neither system settles the trade-off that follows. The aerodrome that minimises fuel shares the same weather front as the destination; the one that guarantees a landing is the one that is paid for. The regulation checks compliance, not decorrelation.

Where the preparation burden lands

The single-threshold rule is built to be applied hundreds of times a day, by flight dispatchers who share operational control and bear responsibility jointly with the commander. It answers quickly and leaves little room for judgement. Its robustness comes from training and from operations specifications stricter than the text itself: the dispatcher has an interest in the margin, because it is their signature on it.

The cumulative-conditions rule shifts the burden upstream. The operator writes its method, the authority approves it, and what is checked afterwards is less each individual decision than its conformity with the method. The cost is paid once, at the time of writing, and again at each revision. The benefit is reproducibility, regardless of who prepares the flight or when.

In flight, the two converge. The filed alternate is a plan, not an obligation to go there: the commander may change it, and what constrains that choice is not the regulation but the fuel remaining. The regulation constrains the plan; the fuel constrains reality — a gap that practitioners moving from one system to the other discover at their first diversion, and one that comes up regularly in discussions on the FL330 professional forums.

What to check in your own documentation

The useful gap lies in the operations manual, and six points deserve to be checked by name. First, the definition of the ceiling and its altitude reference: measured above the aerodrome or above mean sea level, it does not give the same result at a high-elevation aerodrome. Then the version of the applicability grid and the treatment given to probability groups. Then the review date of the list of adequate aerodromes, often older than one thinks. Then the numerical floor of the rescue category reduction accepted at the alternate. Then how the exemption interacts with the fuel scheme, which may have absorbed the condition. Finally, the operator’s own house minima, stricter almost everywhere — and these are the ones that will be raised in an audit.

One grey area remains: mixed operations. A European operator landing at an American aerodrome applies its own planning rules, but operating minima built by its own method from the procedures published by the State of the aerodrome; the reverse is also true. Planning rules follow the certificate; aerodrome minima follow the published procedure. Confusing the two fails a conversion oral exam: using a planning minimum as a landing minimum cannot be recovered from. Anyone preparing a qualification would do well to work on this pair of concepts before anything else, as the FL330 training programmes.

None of the above replaces the text itself. In case of discrepancy, the regulation applicable to the operation, the operations specifications issued to the operator, and its approved operations manual prevail over this article, including where they are stricter than the regulation from which they derive.

Questions fréquentes

Does a TEMPO group in the TAF cancel the alternate exemption?

Yes, as soon as the forecast deterioration brings the ceiling or visibility below the exemption threshold for all or part of the window running from one hour before to one hour after the estimated time of arrival. Both systems reason on the worst applicable condition within that period, not on the dominant forecast. A group qualified by a probability is treated differently: the European applicability grid allows it to be disregarded in specific cases, which the operations manual must state explicitly.

Why can an alternate not be planned on Category II or III minima?

Because a low-visibility operation requires the conjunction of an aircraft, a crew, and an aerodrome all qualified at the moment of landing. Yet one arrives at the alternate after the event that caused the diversion — an event that may have removed exactly one of those three conditions. The planning scale therefore uses Category I minima, one notch above, so that the degradation is already accounted for at the time the flight plan is filed.

Do two parallel runways count as two separate runways?

The definition requires two distinct landing surfaces, arranged so that the blockage of one does not prevent the planned operation on the other, each served by an approach procedure based on a distinct aid. Two sufficiently separated parallel runways therefore count, and two intersecting runways may count as well: it is not the geometry that decides, but the blockage condition and the independence of the aids. The two directions of the same runway never count, since it is a single surface, and a runway whose only approach is unserviceable no longer counts, regardless of its length.

What does isolated-aerodrome status change about the fuel carried?

It removes the alternate fuel item and replaces it with a supplement sized in time above the destination, on the order of two hours of normal cruise for a turbine aeroplane. The calculation stops being geographic and becomes temporal: one no longer buys the ability to go elsewhere, but the ability to wait in place for the situation to improve. This status must be established and documented by the operator; it is not a decision made in the flight-planning room.

Are planning minima and operating minima the same figures?

No, and confusing the two is the costliest mistake on this topic. Planning minima serve only to decide, on the ground and before departure, whether an aerodrome may appear in the flight file as an alternate. Operating minima serve to decide, in flight, whether the approach may be continued below the decision height or minimum descent altitude. An aerodrome can be unacceptable for planning purposes and perfectly landable on arrival: this asymmetry is intentional.

Must the exemption calculation be redone in case of a delay at departure?

Yes, because the examination window is anchored to the estimated time of arrival and moves with it. A significant delay can bring into the period a deterioration that was excluded from the initial calculation, or take one out of it. Good practice is to set in the operations manual the delay threshold beyond which the weather file must be re-examined, rather than leaving that decision to the moment.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.