Takeoff Alternate: When It Becomes Mandatory, and What It’s Required to Provide

A commercial airliner takes off from a foggy runway at dusk, with the cockpit illuminated and the runway lights barely visible in the low visibility.

The flight departs with a very low runway visual range: the operator’s takeoff minima allow it, the low-visibility procedure is approved, the centreline lights are on, and the transmissometer readings give the required value. Thirty seconds later, with an engine failed after V1, the same aircraft is no longer allowed to land on the runway it just left — it would take several times more visibility. The takeoff alternate exists solely to bridge that gap, and everything asked of it follows from there.

An Aircraft That Can Depart From an Aerodrome It Cannot Return To

The two families of minima do not measure the same thing. A takeoff minimum answers a narrow question: does the crew see enough to keep the centreline, control symmetry and, if need be, reject the takeoff? It is expressed in runway visual range, is checked at the mandated measurement points, and assumes no vertical guidance at all. A landing minimum answers a far heavier question: at the end of an approach, at decision height, does the crew acquire the visual references needed to continue? It depends on ground infrastructure, onboard equipment, crew qualification and aircraft category.

This asymmetry creates an entire band of conditions where departure is legal and return is not. A Category I precision approach is typically flown at around 550 m visual range for a decision height of roughly 200 ft; a low-visibility takeoff, with the right procedures, infrastructure and guidance, goes down to a fraction of that value. Between the two, the aircraft has departed and no longer has a runway behind it. This is a perfectly regular state, not a tolerance: the regulation organises it rather than forbidding it, on condition that an exit has been identified before brake release.

The trigger, moreover, is not always meteorological. The European system explicitly adds the case where return would be impossible for other reasons: a scheduled closure of the single usable runway right after departure, an opening window closing, an unavailable approach aid that makes the aerodrome unusable under instrument conditions, or a surface condition that rules out a landing at high weight. The reasoning remains identical — at the moment the aircraft leaves the ground, a solution must exist elsewhere.

The takeoff alternate is needed because the visibility required to land is often much higher than what’s needed to take off. If an engine fails right after takeoff, the plane can’t safely return to the same runway. So, another airport must be ready as a backup.

An Airbus A320 departs from Paris Charles de Gaulle with 50m RVR (runway visual range) at takeoff, but the landing minima for the same runway are 200m RVR. If an engine fails after V1, the crew cannot land back on the same runway. The takeoff alternate (e.g., Brussels Airport) must be within a one-hour flight radius at one-engine-inoperative speed and have weather above its own landing minima at the time of use.

Visibility band where departure is permitted and return is notHorizontal axis graduated in runway visual range, from zero to eight hundred metres. A solid line marks, far to the left, the takeoff minimum. A dashed line marks, much further to the right, the Category I precision landing minimum. The band between the two is the range where the aircraft can depart without being able to return, and where a takeoff alternate is required.takeoff minimumlanding minimumalternate requiredcan depart, cannot return0400800runway visual range (m)
The takeoff alternate lives in the gap between two minima that do not measure the same thing. On the left, what it takes to depart; on the right, what it takes to land. The central band is the only zone where the question arises, and it is wide.

The Condition That Triggers the Requirement

It fits in one sentence on both sides of the Atlantic, but the sentence does not mean what is often assumed. The reference is not the published minimum of the aerodrome: it is the landing minimum that the operator holds for that aerodrome, with that aircraft, that crew qualification and those approvals. Two aircraft taxiing on the same taxiway, in the same visibility, are therefore not subject to the same requirement. The one approved for a Category III approach finds the aerodrome above its minima and departs without designating anything; the one that only holds Category I is below its own and must hold a takeoff alternate.

On the European side, the rule requires selecting this alternate and entering it in the operational flight plan, together with the criteria that justified the choice. On the American side, the wording runs through the operations specifications of the certificate: no flight may be dispatched from an aerodrome whose weather is below the landing minima listed in those specifications unless a takeoff alternate is specified there. The nuance is not cosmetic, and we return to it below.

The Takeoff Alternate in Both Systems: Same Principle, Two Formulations
Point European system American system, scheduled air carrier operations
Trigger Departure weather below the operator’s landing minima, or return impossible for another reason Departure weather below the landing minima listed in the operations specifications
Reference for the minima Minima established by the operator under its approvals Minima listed in the operations specifications of the certificate
Radius, twin-engine One hour at the one-engine-inoperative cruise regime, in still air — or the approved diversion time, capped at two hours One hour at normal cruise speed with one engine inoperative, in still air
Radius, three engines or more Two hours at the one-engine-inoperative cruise regime, in still air Two hours at normal cruise speed with one engine inoperative, in still air
Speed used for the radius One-engine-inoperative cruise speed, taken from the type’s performance data for the conditions of the day Normal cruise speed with one engine inoperative, with the distance measured from the departure aerodrome
Outside scheduled air transport Requirement carried by separate rules depending on the category of operation, each with its own selection criteria One-hour radius at normal cruise speed in still air, without the engine-failure assumption being framed in the same terms
Required weather at the chosen aerodrome Above the applicable minima at the planned time of use Observations and forecasts above the alternate minima at the planned time of arrival
Where the decision is recorded Operational flight plan Operations specifications, then the flight release/dispatch document

One Hour of Flight, Not a Distance in Miles

The second condition is a range constraint, and this is where most preparation errors lie. The radius is not expressed in nautical miles but in flight time, and that flight time is calculated using a deliberately unfavourable assumption: one engine inoperative, in still air, at the corresponding cruise regime — that is, at the speed the aircraft would actually hold in that state, at the weight it has at departure.

For a twin-engine aircraft, the figure retained is one hour; for a three- or four-engine aircraft, two hours. The European system additionally allows twin-engine operators to use the operator’s approved diversion time instead of the flat one-hour figure, up to a limit of two hours and subject to restrictions arising from the Minimum Equipment List. The American text applicable to scheduled air carrier operations, for its part, sticks to the number of engines.

What the word ‘hour’ conceals is the collapse of speed. A heavy long-haul twin that loses an engine does not stay at cruise level: it descends to the altitude it can hold and stabilises there at a true airspeed far below what it would have held on all engines, in denser air and with reduced available thrust. The one-hour circle calculated under these conditions is markedly smaller than the one a crew estimates in their head from their usual cruise. An aerodrome that ‘makes an hour’ on the chart can fall well outside the required radius, and it falls further outside the higher the takeoff weight — that is, precisely on the flights where the failure would be most constraining.

Still air, for its part, is a convention. The rule fixes the calculation conditions to make verification reproducible from one flight to another and from one operator to another, not to describe the day’s actual conditions. It does not claim that the aerodrome will be reached in one hour: it guarantees that it was chosen against a common yardstick.

One-hour radius on all engines and one-hour radius with one engine inoperativePlan view from the departure aerodrome, shown as a point on the left. Two concentric arcs represent the distance covered in one hour. The outer, dashed arc corresponds to the all-engine cruise regime. The inner, solid arc corresponds to the one-engine-inoperative regime at high weight, and it is much closer to the departure point. An aerodrome considered as an alternate sits between the two arcs, and therefore outside the regulatory radius.departurealternate1 h, engine inoperative1 h, all enginesat high weight, the failure radius shrinks
The required radius is calculated with one engine inoperative: it is much smaller than cruise intuition suggests. An aerodrome comfortably within the all-engine hour can end up outside the regulatory circle, and the gap widens with takeoff weight.

The trap. The radius is fixed in still air: it is a calculation convention, not a forecast. An aerodrome chosen right at the limit remains regulatorily acceptable even when the forecast wind on the route is a strong headwind; after a failure and a level reduction, the actual flight time can stretch considerably, and fuel burn along with it. Compliance is secured, the margin is not — and the day visibility is poor is rarely the day the wind is calm.

What Is Required of the Aerodrome Itself

Being within the radius is not enough. The aerodrome must be adequate in the sense understood for an en-route alternate: runway dimensions and strength compatible with the type, rescue and firefighting resources at the expected level, and actual availability at the time it would be used. An aerodrome open only during the day is not an alternate for a departure before dawn. An aerodrome with no customs service is not one for certain international flights. A NOTAM for works on the only usable runway disqualifies it even if the weather there is excellent.

Next comes the weather condition specific to the chosen aerodrome: its conditions must be forecast above the minima that would apply to it, at the time the aircraft would present itself there. This is not the weather at the time of flight preparation, nor is it an end-of-day forecast: it is a short window, typically within the hour following departure, and it is often the window least well served by the forecasts available, because it falls between two forecast periods.

The point most often underestimated remains landing performance. The landing would take place at a weight close to the takeoff weight, therefore above the maximum landing weight as soon as the flight carries any meaningful amount of trip fuel, with one engine inoperative, a thrust reverser unavailable on the affected side, possibly a contaminated runway, and high-lift devices constrained by the failure. Many modern aircraft have no fuel jettison capability. The runway length to be checked is therefore not that of the landing case planned in the flight plan, but that of this case — and the gap between the two can run to hundreds of metres.

Finally, the approach capability available at that aerodrome must be compatible with the equipment fitted that day and the crew’s qualification. Selecting an aerodrome whose only usable approach requires a capability the aircraft does not have, or that the Minimum Equipment List has just removed, amounts to selecting nothing at all.

Decision sequence leading to a takeoff alternateFirst box: is the departure weather below the landing minima? If yes, an alternate is required, within the radius calculated with one engine inoperative, with weather above its own minima at the time of use, the decision being recorded in the operational flight plan. If no, a branch specific to the European system asks whether return would be impossible for another reason; if yes it rejoins the box for a required alternate, if no nothing is required at departure.departure weather belowthe landing minima?alternate requiredand within one-engine-inoperative radiusaerodrome weather aboveits minima at time of usereturn impossible foranother reason? (EU)yesyesnonorecorded in the flight plannothing required at departure
Three conditions to clear, and one branch specific to the European system. Departure weather opens the question, the one-engine-inoperative radius filters the aerodromes, and the aerodrome weather at the time of use settles it. The left-hand branch captures the non-meteorological cases.

Two Systems, Two Ways of Writing the Same Constraint

The physical constraint is identical: after a failure at the worst possible moment, a reachable and usable aerodrome is needed. The way it is written into law differs, and that difference has practical effects.

The American system anchors everything to the operations specifications. The minima applicable to the departure aerodrome appear there, and the takeoff alternate must be specified there. The scope of choice is therefore pre-approved and finite: whatever has not been processed with the authority beforehand is not available on the morning of departure. In return, verification is immediate and done on paper, and the trigger remains purely meteorological.

The European system proceeds differently. It imposes an obligation of outcome — selecting an alternate that meets stated criteria — and leaves the operator to exercise it flight by flight, recording the decision in the operational flight plan. The choice is broader and more dynamic; the burden of demonstration shifts towards preparation and towards after-the-fact oversight. Two additions come with it: the clause covering an impossible return for other reasons, which captures non-meteorological cases that the American text leaves to the operator’s general judgement, and the option of the approved diversion time for twin-engine aircraft, which ties the takeoff alternate to the logic of extended diversion time operations rather than treating it as a separate rule.

A third difference is worth knowing for those moving between frameworks. Outside scheduled air transport, the American body of rules applicable to on-demand operations also retains a one-hour radius, but at normal cruise speed and in still air, without the engine-failure assumption being framed in the same terms. The number is the same, the content is not, and the resulting radius is substantially larger. An operator switching between the two regimes, or a crew moving to a new company, cannot carry the reflex over without re-reading the text that applies to them. It is a recurring source of misunderstanding in exchanges between crews coming from different operating backgrounds.

What the Rule Changes in Preparation and in Flight

The designation is settled before the aircraft moves. It jointly commits flight preparation and the commander, and it leaves a written record: the aerodrome appears in the dossier, along with the weather and the criteria that justified selecting it. It is this record, not the crew’s memory, that will be reviewed in the event of an occurrence.

In flight, however, it binds no one. The takeoff alternate is not a mandatory destination: it certifies that a solution existed at the moment the decision to depart was made. Once airborne, the commander selects the aerodrome best suited to the actual failure, the actual wind and the actual state of the aircraft, which may well be a different aerodrome — or even the departure aerodrome itself, if visibility there has recovered in the meantime. Confusing the two, believing one must absolutely go to the designated aerodrome, leads to poorer choices than the rule actually allows.

The briefing therefore benefits from focusing on three concrete elements rather than just the aerodrome’s name: the intended runway and the approach leading to it, the weight at which the landing would take place, and what that weight requires — the high-weight landing procedure, the energy to be dissipated, brake and tyre checks after landing, and the aircraft’s likely grounding. On many types, this last point turns a diversion of a few tens of minutes into a much longer grounding, with the operational consequences that follow.

The Minimum Equipment List inserts itself into the picture. An inoperative item that degrades approach capability, configuration performance or the diversion time approval reduces the set of eligible aerodromes at the very moment low visibility at departure makes one necessary. These are two independent constraints meeting each other, and their intersection must be checked explicitly, never assumed.

The right reflex. Assess the aerodrome using the landing case you would actually have to fly — weight close to takeoff weight, one engine inoperative, one reverser down, the day’s surface condition — rather than the performance table at the landing weight planned in the flight plan. Then check the weather and availability of that aerodrome at the time it would be used, that is, typically within the hour following departure, not at the time of preparation.

What to Check in Your Own Documentation

  • Operator’s landing minima: Where are they documented for frequent departure aerodromes, and who keeps them updated? It’s not just the aerodrome’s published minima but the operator’s specific minima for your aircraft and crew qualifications.
  • Diversion time approval: Does your operator have an approved diversion time that can be used for takeoff alternates? Check the Minimum Equipment List to see if any deferred defects affect this approval.
  • Flight-planning system criteria: How does your flight-planning system choose the takeoff alternate? Some use a fixed nautical mile radius, which may not match the one-engine-inoperative radius. Know whether this is conservative or permissive for your operations.
A commercial airplane on a wet runway in foggy conditions with ground crew nearby.
Ensure takeoff alternates are available in adverse weather conditions.

A grey area remains, and it is better to name it. The rule fixes calculation conditions and says nothing about actual reachability on the day: a compliant aerodrome can be practically out of reach, and a non-compliant one can be the best choice once airborne. Nothing prevents choosing better than the required minimum, and that is where the operator’s room for manoeuvre lies — provided it is documented somewhere, failing which it will vanish at the first change of dispatcher.

For anyone preparing a type rating or an operational check, the question almost always turns on the same two hinges: the reference to the operator’s minima rather than the aerodrome’s published ones, and the speed assumption with one engine inoperative. Candidates who get it wrong generally cite the correct number of hours with the wrong flight regime, which is the surest way to designate an unreachable aerodrome. The operational preparation modules cover this point together with the associated performance calculations.

The text applicable in your State and your operator’s approved documentation take precedence over this article: in the event of any discrepancy, they are authoritative, and it is your Operations Manual that describes how the requirement is applied at your organisation.

Questions fréquentes

Is a takeoff alternate required if the departure weather is good but the only runway closes right after departure?

In the European system, yes: the rule also covers the case where return would be impossible for a reason other than weather. A scheduled closure of the single runway, the unavailability of the only approach aid, or a closing opening window all fall under this case. The reasoning remains the same as in reduced visibility: at the moment of departure, a landing solution must exist within reach.

Is the one-hour radius calculated at the usual cruise regime?

No, and this is the most common mistake. It is calculated at the one-engine-inoperative cruise regime, in still air, from the actual takeoff weight. After a failure at high weight, the aircraft descends to the altitude it can hold and stabilises there at a true airspeed well below its normal cruise, so the regulatory circle is noticeably smaller than a rough mental estimate.

Is the crew required to divert to the designated takeoff alternate?

No. It is a preparation constraint, not an in-flight obligation: it guarantees that a solution existed at the moment the decision to depart was made. Once airborne, the commander selects the aerodrome best suited to the actual failure, the actual wind and the aircraft’s condition. That can be a different aerodrome, or even the departure aerodrome itself if conditions there have recovered.

Does extra fuel need to be carried for the takeoff alternate?

The standard fuel scheme does not add a reserve dedicated to this alternate, since the aircraft has just taken off with the whole of its trip fuel and the distance involved is small. The real issue is not quantity but weight: the landing would take place above, often well above, the maximum landing weight. It is therefore the landing performance and the high-weight landing procedure that need to be prepared, not the fuel uplift.

Can a twin-engine aircraft use its approved diversion time instead of the flat one-hour figure?

The European system allows it, up to a limit of two hours and subject to the applicable restrictions arising from the Minimum Equipment List. The operator’s approval still needs to cover the actual configuration of the day, which a deferred defect can call into question. The American text applicable to scheduled air carrier operations does not provide this flexibility and sticks to the number of engines.

What should be checked first on an aerodrome selected as a takeoff alternate?

Its availability and weather at the time it would be used, not at the time of preparation, then its runway length assessed against the actual landing case: weight close to takeoff weight, one engine inoperative, the day’s surface condition. Add the firefighting level, opening hours, NOTAMs, and the compatibility of the available approach with the day’s equipment and qualification.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.