Energy Management on Approach: What Automation Conceals

Gestion de l'énergie en approche : ce que l'automatisation masque

Three miles from the threshold, the flight director bars are centred, the glidepath is held to within half a dot, and yet the aircraft is arriving some twenty knots too fast, speedbrakes stowed. Nothing was flown badly: the guidance did exactly what it was asked to do, and it did it well. What it never displayed is the energy state — the one quantity that will decide the outcome of this approach.

A command instrument is not a state instrument

The flight director displays a command: the difference between the current pitch attitude and the one that would satisfy the target of the active mode. Centred bars mean “you are following the command”, never “the aircraft is where it should be”. The two statements coincide as long as the target is the right one and the aircraft has the means to hold it. As soon as either of those conditions fails, the guidance goes on displaying a perfectly followed command while the situation deteriorates, with nothing in its appearance changing.

The second point is more structural. On the vertical axis, the crew has two controls — pitch and thrust — for two variables: flight path and speed. No system holds both with a single control. Every vertical mode therefore makes an assignment: pitch takes one, thrust takes the other. That assignment is written somewhere, in three letters, on the least-watched line of the display.

That leaves energy itself, which is displayed nowhere. It is made up of a height term and a speed term, and it is spent only through drag. The flight deck supplies the pieces — height, distance to run, speed, trend, thrust lever position, configuration — but the assembly is crew work. It is exactly the work automation does not do, and the work a pilot rated on a modern aircraft has the fewest opportunities to practise.

The flight director tells you what to do, not where you are. Energy is the sum of your height and speed, and you can only lose it by slowing down or descending. Automation doesn’t track this for you, so you have to do it yourself.

An Airbus A320 on a 3-degree glidepath at 140 knots groundspeed should descend at 700 feet per minute. If it’s 300 feet high at 8 miles and 20 knots fast, it has an energy excess that must be dissipated before the stabilisation gate, or the approach will be unstable.

Three numbers and one reserve

The energy read-out fits into a short frame, independent of any mode. Three numbers: the distance to run, the height, the speed. One reserve: the drag not yet deployed.

Height is compared with a profile, not with an altitude. On a three-degree glidepath, the order of magnitude used everywhere is three hundred feet per nautical mile: eight miles from the threshold, an aircraft on profile is around two thousand four hundred feet above it. The rate of descent that maintains that gradient is roughly five times the groundspeed expressed in knots — one hundred and forty knots of groundspeed calls for close to seven hundred feet per minute. Neither rule needs a computer, and both remain true when the computer itself is flying a path poorly rebuilt after a shortcut from air traffic control.

Vertical approach profile and height deviation from the profileThe horizontal axis carries the distance to run to the threshold, from twelve miles on the left to the threshold on the right; the vertical axis carries the height. A straight line descends towards the threshold: the three-degree gradient, of the order of three hundred feet per mile. Two silhouettes are placed at the same distance, one on the line, the other clearly above it, joined by a dashed segment that represents the excess height.height (ft)3,0002,0001,0001284thresholddistance to run (NM)3° gradient — 300 ft/NMexcess height
The profile can be rebuilt in the head, without a computer. Three hundred feet per mile give the expected height at every distance; the vertical gap between the two silhouettes is what will have to be dissipated, and it depends on no mode.

The third number, speed, is not read in isolation: it is read as an equivalent height. Excess speed is a height that has not yet been paid for, and the exchange rate is not constant: it grows with true airspeed. Ten knots too fast are worth of the order of a hundred feet at approach speeds; the same ten knots are worth more than twice that in a fast descent at altitude, where true airspeed far exceeds indicated airspeed. In other words, the same speed error does not carry the same price depending on where it is made, and an excess accumulated high up costs more than the displayed figure suggests.

Equivalent height of kinetic energy as a function of speedA rising curve, concave upwards, relates true airspeed on the horizontal axis to the equivalent height of the speed energy on the vertical axis. Two tangent dashed segments, one at approach speeds, the other in a fast descent, show that the same ten-knot variation is worth a greater height the higher the speed.energy height (ft)1,0002,0003,000100140180220260true airspeed (kt)10 kt ≈ 120 ft10 kt ≈ 220 ft
The same speed deviation does not cost the same everywhere. The slope of the curve is the exchange rate between speed and height: it roughly doubles between final approach and a fast descent, which is why an excess taken on high is paid for over a long time.

The drag budget is spent only once

With the thrust levers at idle, a transport aeroplane has nothing left but its drag to shed excess energy. In the clean configuration that drag is low: it is precisely the quality that was paid for in cruise. The dissipation devices form a budget in which every item has its own conditions of use. The speedbrakes are the first resort, but on many types their use is restricted as soon as the flaps go beyond a certain setting: deploying them also means accepting their loss as the configuration is advanced. The flaps add drag and at the same time lower the target speed, so they shift the reference against which the comparison is made — they do not reduce a deviation, they redefine it. The landing gear is the most brutal increment, and the only one that does not change the target speed; that is why it is often moved earlier in the sequence when the excess has been identified early, instead of being kept as a last resort.

A pilot in a cockpit at dusk, with illuminated instruments, prepares for landing.
Automation cannot replace human judgment in critical landing phases.

Once everything is out, the rate of dissipation is set by the aircraft, not by the crew. Only one variable is left: the distance. That is the instant when the energy read-out stops being a correction and becomes a decision — and the distance needed to recover is then compared with the distance still available, which is displayed on no screen.

What remains dissipable as a function of the distance to runTwo straight lines start from the threshold, on the right, and rise towards the left. The steeper one, solid, gives the excess still dissipable with all the drag deployed; the shallower one, dashed, the same capability in the clean configuration. A dotted horizontal represents the excess actually carried: its intersection with the solid line marks the distance below which recovery is no longer possible, clearly before the vertical line of the stabilisation gate.energy excessmaximum drag deployedclean configurationexcess carriedstabilisation gaterecovery limitthresholddistance to run, decreasing
The useful window closes before the stabilisation gate. The intersection between the excess carried and the dissipation capability gives a limiting distance; beyond that point no configuration recovers the profile, and there are still several miles to go before any criterion is formally exceeded.

This budget does not look the same from one family of aircraft to another, and that is what makes the energy read-out transferable rather than learned by heart on one type. What transfers are the three numbers and the question “what have I left to deploy?”; what changes is the value of the budget items and the distance at which they cease to be enough. A very clean aircraft dissipates slowly: its recovery limit lies far further from the threshold than intuition acquired on a draggier type would suggest. On a machine whose main resource depends on engine speed, it closes as soon as that engine speed comes back down.

What becomes of the drag budget according to the family of aircraft
Family Dominant dissipation resource What limits it Effect on the limiting distance
Transport aeroplane fitted with speedbrakes The speedbrakes, supplemented by the landing gear; the flaps mainly serve to lower the target Speedbrake use is frequently restricted beyond a certain flap setting A comfortable budget, but one that closes as the configuration is advanced: the limit moves closer as the aircraft is configured
Slender-wing business twinjet The landing gear, often moved earlier in the sequence for want of equally effective speedbrakes High lift-to-drag ratio in the clean configuration, limiting extension speeds sometimes low in relation to descent speeds Slow dissipation: the recovery limit lies markedly further from the threshold
Turboprop Propeller drag, which increases when a high propeller speed is set at low power This drag depends on a parameter that is set and can be unset; reverse remains prohibited in flight An abundant but reversible resource: it disappears as soon as the propeller speed is reduced, including inadvertently

The trap. Recovering an excess of energy by increasing the rate of descent removes nothing: it converts height into speed. The aircraft comes back onto the profile and arrives at the gate with the same excess, now entirely in the form of speed — and speed is shed more slowly than height, since it has only drag available. A profile recaptured late with a high vertical speed is an unstabilised approach that does not yet look like one, and the guidance will fly it to the end without flinching.

Who holds the flight path, who holds the speed

Two assignments cover most of the descent and the approach. In the first, pitch holds the flight path and thrust regulates the speed: this is the regime of a profile to be respected, of a final gradient, of a level segment. In the second, thrust is against a stop — idle, in descent — and pitch holds the speed: the flight path is no longer a command, it is what is left.

The consequence is asymmetric, and that is the whole point of the distinction. Under the first assignment, an accumulated excess is consumed by nothing: pitch is assigned to the flight path, thrust to the speed, and neither has the task of dissipating energy. The excess therefore stays where it is until someone creates a genuine thrust deficit or deploys drag. Under the second, excess speed is precisely what makes the aircraft descend: the machine corrects itself, but it does so by spending height, and thus brings closer the moment when the drag budget will have to be opened.

Two assignments of the controls to the two variablesOn the left, pitch holds the flight path and thrust holds the speed: an excess of height is consumed by nothing. On the right, thrust is at the idle stop, pitch holds the speed and the flight path is what results. An arrow recalls that the switch happens on its own.pitch holds the profilethrust is at the stoppitchthrustflight pathspeedpitchthrust at stopspeedresulting flight pathmode reversionthe annunciation is three letters long
Two controls, two variables: the unassigned variable is the one that drifts. On the left, nothing consumes the excess height; on the right, the excess speed is what makes the aircraft descend. Switching from one assignment to the other is not a failure but normal operation — it changes what the aircraft spends, and it is announced only by a mode label.

The sensitive point, then, is not the assignment but the switch. When a loop can no longer satisfy its target — thrust already at the stop, speed coming up against a limit — the system reorganises itself rather than allow that limit to be crossed. The flight path then stops being held, or else the speed does. The aircraft does something perfectly logical and unrequested, and it announces it with a three-letter change, boxed for a few seconds. A crew following the bars sees nothing go by; a crew following the energy sees that the aircraft has just changed the way it is spending.

Reading the energy without the guidance

The independent read-out fits into one sentence, spoken in an invariable order: distance, height relative to the profile, speed relative to the target, drag remaining. “Eight miles, three hundred feet high, fifteen knots fast, clean” describes a state. “We are a bit high but it will come back” describes none. The difference is not one of style: the first formulation contains the four terms that make a decision possible, the second contains a hope.

That sentence attaches to a simple two-input geometry. The height deviation and the speed deviation draw four cases, of which only two are genuine energy deviations. High and slow, or low and fast, describe the same total energy badly distributed: pitch alone is enough to put it back in place, almost without delay and without consuming anything. High and fast is a real excess, which goes only through drag and through time. Low and slow is a real deficit, which is filled only by thrust, with the engine acceleration delay — the only one of the four cases in which what is wanted is not recovered when it is wanted.

The four energy deviations and their natureTwo axes cross: the speed deviation horizontally, from slower to faster, the height deviation vertically, from lower to higher. The four quadrants carry the combinations high and slow, high and fast, low and slow, low and fast, each matched with the resource that corrects it. A dashed segment joining two opposite quadrants recalls that they correspond to the same total energy distributed differently.fastslowhighlowhigh and slowhigh and fastlow and slowlow and fastheight → speeddrag, distancethrust, engine delayspeed → heightequal total energy
Two quadrants out of four are not energy deviations. High and slow, low and fast: same total, different distribution, pitch is enough. The other two call on an outside resource — drag on one side, thrust and its delay on the other.
The four energy deviations: what a correctly followed guidance shows, what corrects them
Deviation What a correctly followed guidance shows Resource for recovering Trap specific to the deviation
High and slow Bars centred, thrust low Pitch alone: the height gives the speed back Corrects itself so quickly that it yields no information about what follows
Low and fast Bars centred, low rate of descent Pitch alone: the speed gives the height back Recapturing the profile consumes the speed margin before the gate
High and fast Nothing in particular once the profile has been recaptured Drag, then distance, in that order Increasing the rate of descent moves the excess instead of reducing it
Low and slow High pitch, thrust increasing Thrust, with its acceleration delay The only case in which the resource is not immediately available

The right habit. Call the energy state aloud at fixed markers — glidepath interception, then every mile from six — in the same order every time: distance, height, speed, configuration. A sentence that does not end, or that contains an “it will come back”, amounts to a decision: deploy drag immediately, or ask for extra track miles while they are still cheap. Speaking the state engages the other pilot, which a silent glance never does.

What this read-out changes for a type rating

Three checks are worth making in one’s own documentation, before the check as before the line. First the operator’s stabilisation criteria: which parameters, at what height, with what action mandated in the event of a deviation. Those criteria are a check at a point of passage, not a flying technique — they observe, they do not anticipate. Then the limitations on the use of the drag devices: from which flap setting the speedbrakes are restricted, and what the manufacturer permits regarding the use of the landing gear as a dissipation device, which some manuals frame explicitly. Finally the policy on the use of automation on approach: what is prescribed, what is left to the captain’s judgement, what is prohibited.

There remains a grey area that nobody quite closes. Between the instant when the drag budget is exhausted and the stabilisation gate, a period elapses during which no criterion is yet breached although the outcome is already written. No automatic system flags that instant and no text names it: it is nonetheless the last moment at which a go-around costs little, in fuel as in explanation. On a check as on the line, a go-around announced at that instant and owned defends itself; what is hard to defend is having gone through that instant without seeing it. It is also the sequence that is worked in the simulator rather than in the classroom, with an instructor who replays it until the sentence comes of its own accord — the advanced training programmes make it one of their recurring exercises.

This article describes a mechanism, not a procedure. The limitations of the flight manual, the criteria and procedures of the operator’s approved documentation and the manufacturer’s instructions prevail in all circumstances over what is written here; in the event of a discrepancy between the two, the on-board documentation is authoritative.

Questions fréquentes

Bars centred and the profile held: can the aircraft still be in excess of energy?

Yes, and that is the most frequent case. The flight director displays the deviation from the target of the active mode, not the state of the aircraft: as long as the target is held, it says nothing about the excess speed or about the drag still to be deployed. Excess energy is displayed on no instrument and has to be assembled by the crew from the distance, the height, the speed and the configuration.

How can the deviation from the profile be estimated without a computer?

Two orders of magnitude are enough on a three-degree approach: about three hundred feet per nautical mile for the expected height, and a rate of descent close to five times the groundspeed expressed in knots. At eight miles, the profile therefore passes around two thousand four hundred feet, and one hundred and forty knots of groundspeed calls for close to seven hundred feet per minute. These rules remain valid when the computed path has been poorly rebuilt after a shortcut.

Why does increasing the rate of descent not eliminate the excess energy?

Because a steeper descent converts height into speed instead of dissipating energy. The aircraft comes back onto the profile, but it arrives with the same total excess, now carried entirely by the speed. And speed is shed only through drag, more slowly than excess height: the problem has changed form, not magnitude.

Can the landing gear be used as a dissipation device?

It is the largest and most immediately available drag increment, and using it early is a widespread energy management technique. It remains subject to the type’s limiting extension and operating speeds, and some operating manuals explicitly frame this use or advise against it other than when necessary. It is therefore essential to check what the documentation of the type operated says before making a habit of it.

At what moment is the go-around decision really made?

Before the stabilisation gate, at the instant when the drag budget is exhausted and the distance to run becomes shorter than the distance that would be needed to dissipate the excess. That moment is flagged by no automatic system and has a name in no text: it is deduced from the energy read-out. The gate merely observes at a fixed height an outcome already determined several miles earlier.

What should be looked at to know who holds the flight path and who holds the speed?

The active mode annunciation line, supplemented by the position of the thrust levers. Only two controls, pitch and thrust, share two variables: depending on the mode, pitch holds the profile and thrust regulates the speed, or the reverse with thrust against a stop. A change in that assignment, including one triggered by the system itself, alters what the aircraft is spending without any alert underlining it.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.