Maintaining Instrument Currency: Counted Approaches or a Revalidated Rating

A pilot in a flight simulator cockpit at dusk, performing an instrument approach with a safety pilot monitoring the session.

A captain passes his proficiency check in the simulator in spring and comes out with an instrument rating valid for one year. A few weeks later, also holding a US certificate, he is nonetheless not entitled to exercise that same privilege on the US-registered aircraft he ferries at weekends: the session only had him fly two or three approaches, his airline sectors are long and the landing is shared with the other seat, and his logbook has never logged the approaches one by one. Nothing has expired, no fault has been committed: the two systems do not check the same thing, and one counts events where the other judges a performance.

Two Ways of Answering the Same Question

Every instrument currency regime asks the same question: can this person still fly an IFR flight through to the end, including when the weather closes in and a piece of equipment fails? There are only two families of answer.

The first measures recent exposure. If the pilot has performed a given action a given number of times in recent months, it is presumed that he can still do it. It is objective, verifiable on paper, and involves no one but the person concerned and their logbook. The second has the execution judged: an examiner observes a complete profile, under prescribed conditions, and delivers a binary verdict. It is reliable at the moment it is taken, and entirely silent about what happens the rest of the year.

The American system built its currency regime on the first logic, with the second as a safety net once the count has lapsed. The European system did the opposite: the periodic check carries the validity, and training only comes in to make up for a rating that has lapsed. Both constructions are defensible; they are simply not interchangeable, and that is what every pilot who operates under both discovers.

The US system checks if you’ve done enough instrument flying recently, while the European system checks if you can still do it well when tested. Neither fully covers the other.

Sliding count window versus fixed annual deadlineTwo twelve-month timelines stacked one above the other. At the top, a band covering the last six months contains six dots representing the approaches to be found; this band slides with today’s date. At the bottom, a deadline is marked at the far right, preceded by a three-month band during which the check can be taken without moving the anniversary date.Counting: sliding windowsix approaches to be found hereChecking: fixed annual deadlinerevalidation windowdeadline12 months ago6 months agotoday
Counting has no anniversary date, checking has no memory. At the top, the window moves back one day every day: what was valid yesterday drops out of scope tomorrow. At the bottom, only one date matters, and the band preceding it allows you to get ahead without losing anything.

Counting: Proof of Exposure, Not of Level

Under the American regime, exercising instrument privileges requires having performed and logged, within the previous six calendar months, six instrument approaches, holding procedures, and intercepting and tracking courses using navigation aids. All of it in actual or simulated instrument conditions.

Three mechanical details matter more than the headline rule. First, the unit is the calendar month, not date-to-date: an approach flown on 2 January remains usable until the last day of the sixth month that follows, which gives nearly a month of margin to anyone who knows how to read it. Second, simulated conditions require a view-limiting device and a safety pilot qualified in the other seat, failing which the approach does not exist for counting purposes. Finally, the accepted reading holds that the portion flown solely by reference to instruments must be maintained down to minimums or to the missed approach point: an approach abandoned well above minimums because the airfield was in sight does not count.

Nothing is judged in this scheme: the pilot certifies, through their own record-keeping, that they meet the condition. When the window empties out, they have a grace period of equivalent length to rebuild their count, but only in simulated conditions with a safety pilot, with an instructor, or on an accepted training device. Once that period has passed, only an instrument proficiency check conducted by an authorised person reopens the privilege.

The grace period is not a licence to fly. Many read it as an extension: it is not. During this period, instrument privileges are suspended. You can fly under the hood with a safety pilot, or with an instructor, to rebuild your count; you cannot file an IFR flight plan and enter cloud. Confusing the two means finding yourself in actual conditions without a valid privilege.

A pilot flying a Cessna 172 in the US must log six approaches in the last six calendar months. On 1 June, they did three approaches at KJFK in actual IMC. On 15 July, they did two more in a simulator with a safety pilot. On 1 October, they did one more at KLAX in actual IMC. On 15 December, they did one more in a simulator. Their count is valid until 31 December (six months after the first approach on 1 June).

The Periodic Check: A Dated Judgement

On the European side, the instrument rating carries a validity of one year and is revalidated by a proficiency check with an examiner. The check can be taken within the three months preceding the deadline without the anniversary date moving: the new validity runs from the previous deadline, not from the day of the check. Getting ahead of schedule within this window therefore costs nothing; a check taken before that window opens, on the other hand, makes the validity restart from the day of the test, and the deadline then moves back by however many months’ head start was taken.

The content is of a different nature. The examiner runs through a complete profile: departure, cruise, precision and non-precision approaches, missed approach, handling a significant failure, and on multi-engine types asymmetric flight. It is not repetition that is assessed but the conduct of the flight: anticipation, respect of minimums, the decision to go around, task-sharing. A pilot who has flown thirty approaches over the year can fail; another who has flown none can pass after two preparation sessions.

Once the deadline has passed, the logic changes: it is no longer a matter of revalidating but of renewing, which requires refresher training within a training organisation, the volume of which is determined by the organisation itself in view of how long the lapse has been, followed by the check. Beyond a long period of interruption, credit for theoretical knowledge also lapses, and the road back becomes considerably heavier than a simple simulator session.

At an operator, this pattern is absorbed by the training and checking programme: operator proficiency checks typically come around twice a year, and one of them can be combined with the licence proficiency check that revalidates both the type rating and the instrument rating. The airline pilot is therefore judged far more often than the standalone holder — but it is the operator’s programme that produces this frequency, not the licensing rule.

Place the check inside the window, never before it. The rule that runs the new validity from the previous deadline only applies within the three months preceding it. A check placed four months ahead, for simulator scheduling reasons, no longer defers anything: validity restarts from the day of the test, the new deadline falls four months earlier than it otherwise would have, and the gap repeats year after year until someone catches it.

What Each Regime Certifies, and What It Ignores

Placed side by side, the two barely overlap anywhere: continuous record without evaluation on one side, one-off evaluation without a record of practice on the other.

What each of the two mechanisms certifies, and what it leaves in the dark
Point of comparison Counting regime Periodic check regime
Time unit Sliding six-calendar-month window Fixed annual deadline date
What is measured Number of events performed Quality of an observed flight
Who decides The pilot, on the strength of their record-keeping An authorised examiner
Record required Detailed logging, approach by approach A check form and an endorsement on the licence
Possible failure No: you are either current or you are not Yes, with immediate consequences for the privilege
On expiry Time allowed to rebuild the count in flight Training within an organisation, then the check
Main blind spot Six identical approaches, at the same airfield, autopilot engaged Eleven months without an approach between two checks
What it costs Regular flying time, little logistics An examiner’s and a simulator’s slot, once a year
What each regime certifiesA two-axis matrix. On the horizontal axis, the degree of third-party verification; on the vertical axis, the frequency of attested practice. Counting alone occupies the upper-left quadrant, the periodic check alone the lower-right quadrant, the combination of both the upper-right quadrant, and the lower-left quadrant corresponds to a pilot neither checked nor practising.counting alonebothcheck aloneneither one nor the otherattested recent practicethird-party verification
The two mechanisms are orthogonal: neither replaces the other. A pilot can be flawless on the horizontal axis and empty on the vertical axis, and vice versa. Only the upper-right quadrant describes a proficiency that is both practised and judged.

The Blind Spots, and How the Field Fills Them

The count is satisfied by six identical approaches, at the same airfield, in fine weather under the hood, autopilot engaged down to minimums. The condition is met, actual competence has not moved an inch. Nothing requires variety: neither the type of approach, nor the mode of guidance, nor the presence of a failure. It is the practitioner, not the text, who decides whether their six approaches served any purpose.

The periodic check suffers the symmetric flaw: it is prepared for. The likely scenario is known, revision happens the week before, the pilot shows up at their best, and the curve drops again the following day with nothing to sustain it. A holder who flies little can go eleven months without a single instrument approach while remaining perfectly compliant.

Effective proficiency between two deadlinesA twelve-month proficiency curve. The solid line, associated with regular practice, ripples around a high level all year. The dashed line, associated with a single annual check, declines slowly then rises sharply on the day of the check, marked by a vertical line near the right edge.checkeffective proficiencyregular practiceannual check alonetwelve months
The check raises the level on the day it is taken, not over the preceding eleven months. The dashed line shows the slope that nothing offsets between two deadlines; the solid line shows the effect of practice spread over time, which never reaches the peak of check day but never falls as low either.

Operators close the gap through operations themselves: real approaches on the line, imposed rotation of scenarios, line checks in the normal environment. The standalone holder does not have this crutch and must fabricate their own rule: vary the procedures, alternate manual and automatic guidance, impose personal minimums for as long as practice has not been regular.

The Pilot Operating Under Both Regimes

This is where the two clocks collide. Four situations recur, and none of them is theoretical.

  • Current in Europe, out of count in the United States. The annual check dates from January, and the pilot has been flying the line ever since. Their rating is valid, and yet they cannot exercise instrument privileges on a US-registered aircraft, unable to produce the required count of approaches.
  • Current in the United States, lapsed in Europe. The reverse is even more clear-cut: no accumulation of approaches extends a lapsed European deadline. The date falls, and the privilege with it.
  • A certificate resting on a foreign licence. A US certificate issued on the basis of a foreign licence remains tied to it: if the instrument rating that underpins the original licence ceases to be valid, the privilege falls on the American side too — and European validity never exempts anyone from the count.
  • Missing traceability. A logbook kept according to European habits does not itemise approaches. Twenty approaches in actual IMC over the half-year are worth nothing if they were not logged one by one. The count must be proven, not argued.

There is also the question of training devices: a simulator qualified for the European check is not automatically accepted under the American rule for rebuilding a count, and the terms of use vary with the device’s qualification level. Assuming a session counts on both sides because it was expensive is the costliest reflex of all.

Keep an IFR sheet alongside your logbook. One line per approach: date, airfield, type of procedure, actual or simulated conditions, manual or automatic guidance, safety pilot if there is one, holding and interception performed. Ten seconds per flight, three minutes of review six months later, and a documentary check stops being a discussion.

What to Go and Check in Your Own Documentation

Three points deserve to be read in plain terms. The first concerns the operations manual: does it state which simulator sessions credit what, and is the licence proficiency check combined with an operator proficiency check? Many crews do not know which of their two sessions carries the revalidation, and only find out when a rescheduling shifts the wrong one.

A pilot in a cockpit during twilight, operating controls and monitoring instruments, with a co-pilot visible in the background.
Instrument proficiency ensures safe operations in all conditions.

The second concerns the date of record. The entry on the licence, the training organisation’s record, and the operator’s tracking table diverge more often than one might imagine, because one logs the day the session took place and the other the renewed deadline. Knowing which of these sources the authority will look at, and which one triggers internal reminders, avoids discovering the gap on a layover, in front of someone asking to see the licence.

The third is a grey area that no one settles completely: in a two-person crew, who “performed” the approach? The pilot who was handling the controls, presumably. Did the one who was monitoring, working the radio and calling the minimums fly an approach for counting purposes? The prevailing practice logs only the pilot flying position, and that is the cautious answer; it implies that a crew that alternates strictly sees its count halved. The remedy takes two steps: allocate sectors with this arithmetic in mind rather than at random, and plan to make up the shortfall on an accepted device before the window closes, not the month it closes.

For anyone preparing a conversion or a first rating held under two flags, the arithmetic must be done in advance: no conversion resets a counter to zero, and the check-preparation courses do not exempt anyone from the traceability required by the other regime.

The applicable regulation, the operator’s approved documentation, and the instructions of the authority the licence falls under always prevail over this article, which is intended only as an explanation.

Questions fréquentes

Does passing a European proficiency check make me current under American rules?

No, not as such: the American rule requires a logged count of approaches, not the mention of a foreign revalidation. However, the approaches actually flown during that check can feed into this count if the device used is accepted and if they are logged individually. After the grace period has expired, only an instrument proficiency check conducted by a person authorised under the American regime reopens the privilege.

Do approaches flown on the line, in actual conditions, count?

Yes, an approach flown in actual instrument conditions by the pilot flying counts, without needing a hood or a safety pilot. The difficulty lies elsewhere: it must be logged approach by approach, which the usual way of keeping a European logbook does not provide for. A crew that alternates roles strictly must also remember that only the pilot flying position can prudently be counted.

What can I do during the grace period of the counting regime?

You can rebuild your count, but not exercise the privilege. Concretely: fly in simulated conditions under a view-limiting device with a qualified safety pilot, fly with an instructor, or use an accepted training device. Filing an IFR flight plan and entering cloud during this period is out of the question.

Can I take my European check early without losing my deadline date?

Yes, within the three months preceding the deadline: the new validity then runs from the previous deadline date and the anniversary does not move. Taken in a session before that window, the check remains valid but the validity is recalculated from the day of the test: the deadline moves back by however many months’ head start you took, and it does not catch up on its own the following cycle. This is a matter of simulator-scheduling planning more than of regulation.

My rating expired a long time ago: what do I need to redo?

Renewal goes through refresher training within an approved training organisation, the volume of which is set by that organisation after assessment, followed by a proficiency check with an examiner. Beyond a long interruption, credit for theoretical knowledge is no longer held and the corresponding exam must be retaken. Have your situation checked by the organisation before booking a check slot.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.