Fuel policy compared: prescribed reserves or approved policy

Raccord de tuyau d'avitaillement sous une aile, camion en arrière-plan

Two operators load the same type on the same route, in the same slot, with the same weather at the alternate. One files a departure fuel figure several hundred kilograms higher than the other, and both flight plans are compliant. The gap is not a rounding difference: the first applies a prescribed list of reserves, the second operates under an approved fuel policy built on its own consumption data.

Two ways of building a minimum

The real question is not « how much fuel », but « who carries the burden of proof ». Under a prescriptive approach, the authority writes the list and the method: fixed blocks are added together, each with its own formula, and the result is deemed safe because the formula is. The operator has nothing to prove, and nothing to negotiate either. Under an approved-policy approach, the authority sets the objective — landing with the final reserve intact in reasonably foreseeable scenarios — and lets the operator demonstrate that its method achieves it. The minimum stops being a table entry and becomes the output of a model.

The European system today contains both. Since the recast of the fuel and energy rules, an operator falls under a Basic Fuel Scheme — the classic list —, a Basic Fuel Scheme with variations, or an Individual Fuel Scheme built on its own data. The American system, for public transport, remains prescriptive: the margin is expressed as a percentage of flight time or as minutes of consumption, and flexibility comes through named procedures rather than a global policy subject to approval. On one side, flexibility is earned through a case file and continuous monitoring; on the other, by changing the geometry of the flight, since the formula itself is not up for discussion.

Some airlines use fixed fuel rules, others calculate their own based on real data. The first method is simple but rigid; the second is flexible but requires proof that it works.

An A320 flying from Paris to Madrid under a Basic Fuel Scheme might carry 1,200 kg of contingency fuel. The same flight under an approved policy, using statistical data, might carry only 900 kg—saving 300 kg of weight and fuel cost.

The European inventory, block by block

The flight plan reads from the bottom up, and each block answers a different question. Taxi fuel covers ground consumption, corrected for known delays and de-icing. Trip fuel covers take-off, climb, cruise, descent and approach through to touchdown at destination. Contingency fuel absorbs deviations of the actual flight from the planned flight: individual airframe consumption, an imposed level, ATC routing extension, wind different from forecast. It is this block, and this block alone, that any operator policy attacks first, because it is the only one with a statistical basis.

A man in a dark jacket points at a computer monitor displaying bar graphs in an office.
Data analysis informs fuel policy decisions for optimal reserves.

Alternate fuel covers the go-around at destination, the transit and the landing at the alternate aerodrome. The final reserve — thirty minutes holding at 1,500 ft above the aerodrome in standard conditions for a turbine-powered aircraft, forty-five minutes for a piston engine — is neither negotiable nor plannable: no flight plan may foresee dipping into it. Additional fuel addresses not contingencies but specific scenarios: an engine failure or depressurisation at the most critical point of the route, or serving an isolated aerodrome. What remains are extra fuel, decided and documented by the operator, and discretionary fuel, decided by the commander.

Two stacked fuel figures, prescribed list versus approved policyTwo stacked vertical bars. On the left, the figure derived from the prescribed list: trip, contingency, alternate, final reserve, extra. On the right, the figure derived from an approved policy: same trip fuel, reduced statistical contingency, no alternate block, identical final reserve. The right-hand stack is noticeably lower, the gap marked by a dashed line.TripContingencyAlternateFinal res.Extraalternate removedstatistical contingencyfinal reservegapPrescribed listApproved policy
The only block that never moves is the final reserve; everything else is a matter of method. On the left, each block comes out of an imposed formula. On the right, contingency fuel is calculated from consumption history and the alternate block disappears once the selection conditions are met: the height of the stack changes, the end-of-flight protection does not.
What is fixed and what can be negotiated in a European flight plan figure
Block What it covers Operator’s room for manoeuvre
Taxi Ground up to brake release Measured value, adjustable by aerodrome and by slot
Trip Climb, cruise, descent, approach None: it comes from the performance documentation
Contingency Deviation between the planned flight and the actual flight 5% of trip fuel, 3% with a usable en-route alternate, or an approved statistical value; floor of five minutes’ holding
Alternate Go-around, transit, landing at the alternate aerodrome May be removed under conditions of flight duration, available runways and weather
Final reserve Thirty minutes holding (turbine), forty-five (piston) None, whatever the scheme
Additional Engine failure or depressurisation at the critical point, isolated aerodrome Depends on the scenario, not a commercial choice
Extra and discretionary Known contingencies, commander’s judgement Free, but tracked and coded separately

The American reckoning: three regimes, three logics

Federal law does not write a single flight plan figure: it stacks regimes according to the nature of the operation. The general instrument flight rules require reaching the destination, then the alternate where one is required, then holding for forty-five minutes at normal cruising speed. The alternate is only required there under a simple weather threshold, and one noticeably more permissive than what the European system accustoms one to: within the one-hour window bracketing the estimated time of arrival, a ceiling of at least 2,000 ft and visibility of at least 3 miles exempt the crew from designating one.

Domestic public transport carries this architecture forward but retains the most distant alternate, then the same forty-five minutes, calculated not at holding consumption but at normal cruising consumption. The nuance is not cosmetic: forty-five minutes of cruise weighs considerably more than thirty minutes of low-altitude holding. Flag operations add a margin of 10% of the total flight time counted from departure, then the alternate, then thirty minutes holding at 1,500 ft above it.

Margin basis and nature of the terminal reserve by regime
Regime Margin basis Terminal reserve
European Basic Fuel Scheme Percentage of trip fuel, floor in minutes of holding Thirty minutes holding at 1,500 ft (turbine)
European Individual Fuel Scheme Value derived from consumption monitoring, by aerodrome pair Identical, not modifiable
Instrument flight, general rules No distinct margin Forty-five minutes at normal cruising speed
Domestic public transport No distinct margin Forty-five minutes at normal cruising consumption
Flag operations 10% of flight time counted from departure Thirty minutes holding at 1,500 ft above the alternate

On a ten-hour sector, this 10% basis amounts to an hour of cruise. That is not a computational nuance, it is a payload penalty. In-flight redispatch is therefore not a refinement for optimisation there: it is the mechanism without which a share of the long routes would not close.

What an approved fuel policy actually buys

The first gain is the statistical margin. Instead of a universal percentage, the operator measures, flight after flight, the gap between planned fuel and fuel burned on a given aerodrome pair, then retains a percentile of this distribution, negotiated with the authority and backed by a fuel consumption monitoring programme. On a stable route flown by a homogeneous fleet, the resulting value often falls well below the flat-rate figure. On a windy or congested route, it can exceed it — and that is precisely what makes the method acceptable.

The second gain is geometric: the decision point. A flight plan is filed to an intermediate destination, with a full flight plan figure over that shorter leg; past the decision point, if the fuel remaining meets the criterion, the crew is redispatched to the final destination and the margin then applies only to the remaining portion of the trip. The mechanism does not, in fact, belong to either world alone: it goes by different names on each side — reduced contingency fuel procedure here, redispatch there — for the same idea, moving the point at which the margin is calculated rather than arguing over its rate. The third gain concerns the selection of aerodromes: under conditions of flight duration, two separated usable runways and weather observed around the estimated time of arrival, the alternate block disappears from the flight plan figure.

Decision point and contingency margin basisA horizontal route from departure to the final destination, with a decision point and then the initially filed destination. Below, two bars: the first covers the whole trip, the second only begins at the decision point, illustrating the reduced basis of the contingency margin.departuredecision pointfiled dest.final dest.margin over the whole tripmargin over the remainderbasis removed
Moving the point where the margin is calculated weighs more heavily than arguing over its percentage. With a nearer filed destination and a redispatch at the decision point, the margin applies only to the remainder of the trip. On a long sector, the difference exceeds what a rate adjustment could ever deliver.

The price is paid elsewhere: dedicated consumption data, a justification by route rather than by network, an operations manual that describes the method and the cases for reverting to the general rule, specific training for flight dispatchers and crews, and acceptance that a variation can be withdrawn as quickly as it was granted if monitoring shows a drift. It is not an acquired right, it is a credit secured on the quality of the data.

The end of the flight is not said in the same terms

This is where the two systems diverge most visibly for a crew. On the European side, aligned with international practice, two calls are codified and do not carry the same weight. The MINIMUM FUEL call signals that the crew is committed to a given aerodrome and that any change of clearance would result in landing with less than the final reserve: it is information intended for air traffic control, not a request for priority. The distress call with the word FUEL appended is made as soon as the calculation shows a landing below the final reserve at the nearest usable aerodrome.

End-of-flight bands and call thresholdsDecreasing curve of usable fuel against flight time. Two dashed horizontal lines mark a commitment band, between final reserve plus alternate and final reserve, then a distress band below the final reserve. The curve successively crosses the two thresholds.usable fuelflight timeactual consumptionfinal reserve + alternatefinal reservecommitment: MINIMUM FUELdistress: emergency call
The trigger is a forward-looking calculation, not a gauge reading. As long as the projected landing leaves the final reserve intact, nothing is owed. The middle band corresponds to commitment to a given aerodrome; the lower band is a distress, whatever figure is still shown on the totaliser.

On the American side, the underlying logic is the same but the wording differs: the MINIMUM FUEL call exists there too as advisory information, while crossing the critical threshold goes through an ordinary emergency declaration, remaining fuel being announced in minutes rather than through the standardised international phrase. A crew alternating between the two spaces therefore keeps two ways of naming the same shift — and above all, that the trigger is a calculation about the future, never an instantaneous gauge reading.

On the flight deck and at dispatch: what the gap changes

A dispatcher moving from one operator to another finds the same flight prepared with a different question. Under a prescribed list: which alternate makes the figure the lightest. Under an approved policy: do the assumptions that justify the reduction still hold this morning. The work shifts from optimising the choice to verifying the conditions of use.

The trap. The assumptions that justified a reduction are not frozen at filing. The en-route alternate that authorised the reduced rate can become unusable after departure — deteriorating weather, a closed runway, an expired slot — without the flight plan figure being recalculated. The same mechanism applies on the ground: a long taxi delay consumes the taxi block and then eats into the contingency margin, so the aircraft takes off with a margin already dented while the formula intended it for the flight. In both cases the protection has disappeared, and the figure on the flight plan itself has not moved.

The right reflex. At every reporting point, compare the fuel remaining not to the flight-plan figure, but to the sum of final reserve plus alternate from your current position. And name, at the approach briefing, the aerodrome to which you are committing and the value below which that commitment becomes final: it is that value, not the flight-plan one, that will trigger a call.

The same discipline applies to coding. Fuel added by the commander and logged as operator extra fuel, or the reverse, distorts the base on which the statistical margin rests. The error is invisible on one flight and corrosive over a thousand: it ends up pushing the percentile up, or losing the variation altogether. Field cases are discussed on forums.fl330.com.

What to check in your own documentation

Three points deserve a read before your next leg. Under which scheme your operator actually operates, and on which routes: many hold a Basic Fuel Scheme with targeted variations, so that two flights by the same crew on the same day do not follow the same margin rules. How en-route alternates are checked: the question is not their existence at the planning stage, but whether there is a procedure for reviewing them in flight. And who has the authority to discuss a commander’s addition, under what written record.

There remains a grey area that the texts regulate poorly: the boundary between commercial fuel tankering and fuel policy. Loading more where it costs less is an economic decision, but that weight changes consumption, and therefore the statistics that feed the margin, and therefore the justification for the reduction. Few manuals describe this loop, and it is often there that oversight finds fault.

For anyone preparing a type rating or a licence conversion, the point of vigilance lies elsewhere still: the exam answer remains the prescribed list, while the line answer will be your operator’s scheme. Knowing how to hold both, and which one applies at the moment you sign a flight plan figure, is checked in the line-oriented evaluation. The associated courses are detailed on formations.fl330.com.

This article describes mechanisms, not enforceable obligations: the regulation applicable in the operator’s state, the operations specifications issued by the authority and the approved documentation prevail over the above, and the operations manual is authoritative in the event of a discrepancy.

Questions fréquentes

Can contingency fuel be used up during taxi?

Nothing physically prevents it, since the fuel is on board, but contingency fuel is sized to cover deviations of the flight, not those of the ground phase. A prolonged taxi delay should lead to reviewing the flight plan figure before brake release, not to taking off with protection already consumed. Most operations manuals impose a review threshold and an explicit decision by the commander.

What is the difference between extra fuel and discretionary fuel?

Extra fuel is a documented decision by the operator, based on an identified contingency such as known congestion or a runway constraint. Discretionary fuel is a matter for the commander’s judgement alone and does not need to be justified by a rule. The distinction is not formal: both must be coded separately, otherwise the consumption statistics underpinning an approved margin become unusable.

Does an individual scheme allow the final reserve to be reduced?

No. The final reserve is the one block that neither a variation nor an individual scheme touches: thirty minutes holding for a turbine-powered aircraft, forty-five for a piston engine. All the flexibility of an approved policy bears on contingency fuel, on aerodrome selection and on the geometry of the flight, never on end-of-flight protection.

When should MINIMUM FUEL be called rather than a distress?

The MINIMUM FUEL call indicates that the crew is committed to a given aerodrome and that any change of clearance would result in landing below the final reserve: it is information, with no associated priority. The distress call is made as soon as the calculation shows a landing below the final reserve at the nearest usable aerodrome. The trigger is a projected calculation, not a gauge reading, and the shift from one to the other is not negotiable.

Why does the same flight require more fuel under American flag-operation rules?

Because the margin there is calculated as a percentage of total flight time counted from departure, not of the remaining leg. On a long sector, this basis represents an hour of cruise or more, regardless of how reliable the forecast is. That is what makes in-flight redispatch a structural mechanism rather than a comfort optimisation.

What does an authority check before approving a statistical margin?

It first checks the quality and traceability of the consumption data, including how added fuel is coded. It then checks that the justification is established by aerodrome pair and by homogeneous fleet, and not extrapolated from an entire network. Finally, it imposes continuous monitoring and reserves the right to withdraw the variation if the observed distribution drifts.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.