Type Rating and First Officer: What Differs Between the Two Systems

Sièges et commandes d'un poste de pilotage vus depuis la porte

A first officer’s file arrives with an endorsement facing the type that limits the rating to first officer duties. On the licence of the next candidate, trained in Europe, that endorsement exists nowhere: the rating is written once, with no indication of seat. Yet both sit in the same seat. The gap changes what has to be retaken, before whom, and what remains to be done on the day of the move to the left seat.

What triggers the requirement is not defined the same way

The American system uses an arithmetic threshold written into the pilot certification rule: above a maximum take-off mass of 12,500 pounds, or about 5,700 kilograms, and for any turbojet-powered aircraft regardless of its mass. The criterion is purely physical, independent of the number of pilots required by the flight manual. No list to consult: the criterion is read off the airworthiness certificate.

The European system works by list. The authority publishes and maintains a list of type and class ratings. It includes every aircraft certified for a minimum crew of two pilots, and those that, although single-pilot, are judged too complex or too high-performing to fall under a class rating.

The consequence is still surprising. A pressurised single-turboprop below the American mass threshold most often appears on the European list, and therefore under a type rating, even though it triggers no rating at all in the United States, where it is handled through logbook endorsements. The pilot arriving with this background has nothing to have recognised: the experience on the model is real, but it left no trace of a rating.

The rating required to occupy the right seat in the two systemsOn the left, a single type rating valid for both seats, command coming afterwards from the licence and the operator’s command course. On the right, two distinct ratings, the first officer’s imposing one more examination to command.European systemAmerican systemone type ratingvalid for both seatsto command, afterwards:the required licence, then theoperator’s command courseratingcaptainratingfirst officerendorsement on the rating:first officer privileges,one exam to command
The right seat is rated once in Europe, twice in the United States. Same aircraft, same seat: on the left the distinction is pushed outside the rating, on the right it is engraved into it and lifted only by an examination.

In Europe, a type rating allows you to fly any seat, but you need extra qualifications to be a captain. In the US, the rating itself is different for first officers and captains, and you need an extra exam to move from one to the other.

A pilot trained on the Airbus A320 in Europe has one rating covering both seats. In the US, they’d have two ratings: one for first officer and another for captain, with an exam required to switch between them.

The first officer’s own rating answers an international requirement

The annex to the Chicago Convention on personnel licensing requires that every pilot assigned to a commercial international flight be rated on the type operated. In Europe, the requirement is met automatically. In the United States it was not: the second pilot could serve without a type rating as long as the operator had trained and checked him under its own programme. Hence a distinct rating, reserved for first officer duties.

This rating has two particular features. The first concerns how it is obtained: the training covers a list of operating tasks, but does not necessarily end with a practical test before a designated examiner — a certificate issued by an authorised person is enough to establish that the programme was completed. The second concerns its scope: the endorsement limits the privileges to the right seat, does not fade with experience, and is lifted only by a full practical test.

There is an additional requirement with no direct equivalent: the first officer of an American scheduled carrier must hold the Airline Transport Pilot certificate, or its restricted version accessible earlier through university or military credit. The type rating therefore exempts nothing; it is added to a licence condition that, in Europe, falls only on the captain.

In Europe, the rating ignores the seat — everything else takes care of it

A European type rating carries no seat endorsement: from the licence’s point of view, its holder may occupy either seat. The differentiation exists nonetheless, carried by three other instruments.

The licence first: commanding an aircraft operated in commercial air transport with two pilots requires the Airline Transport Pilot Licence, while the first officer operates with a commercial licence and the instrument rating. The operator’s command course next, required before any first assignment to the left seat, which adds nothing to the rating and does not appear on the licence. Finally the qualification to operate from either seat, required of a first officer liable to occupy the left seat, which covers the seat-related tasks: handling, visibility, distribution of controls, emergency station.

Two special cases are often misread. The Multi-crew Pilot Licence opens privileges limited to first officer duties in multi-pilot operation: the restriction does indeed exist in Europe, but it falls on the licence, not on the type rating. And the cruise relief co-pilot qualification allows occupying a seat during cruise only, with no training in take-off or landing: the pilot holds the type, but not everything the type authorises.

What the type rating covers in the two systems, for the same aircraft and the same seat
Question European system American system
Trigger for the requirement Entry on the list maintained by the authority Maximum take-off mass threshold, or turbojet propulsion
Distinct rating for the first officer None: a single rating, with no seat endorsement Yes: a rating carrying an endorsement limiting privileges to the right seat
How the first officer’s rating is obtained Approved course and skill test before an examiner Ground and flight training on the operating tasks, certified without a mandatory practical test
Move to command Airline Transport Pilot Licence and command course, rating unchanged Practical test to lift the endorsement, in addition to licence conditions and the operator’s course
Left-seat proficiency Distinct qualification to operate from either seat, maintained at checks Handled within the operator’s approved programme, with no trace on the certificate
Maintaining the rating One-year validity, check before an examiner, often combined with the operator’s own check Periodic check required by the certification rule or by the approved programme, depending on the operating framework
Command time before the function Supervised flight, logged as pilot-in-command-under-supervision time Counted on actual handling of the controls, with no equivalent notion

The content of the course is written neither by the regulation nor by the operator

This is the point the two systems treat in the same way, and it explains most of the differences in duration between two courses bearing the same name. The minimum programme for a type rating is set by the type certificate holder, evaluated by the authority, and published in a dossier specific to the model.

In Europe, this dossier is called Operational Suitability Data; its part covering crew training is binding, and an organisation may not go below it. In the United States, the Flight Standardization Board report plays the same role. Both contain the tool most useful to the practitioner: the differences table between variants of the same family, which classifies each difference according to the means required to address it, in training as in checking.

This classification is tiered and marked with increasing letters. The lowest level is satisfied by self-study; the next requires guided instruction; then come the systems trainer, the flight trainer, and finally the full simulator combined with a check. Moving up one step does not cost a few more hours: it changes the nature of the means.

Scale of difference levels and required training meansStaircase rising from left to right. On the x-axis, the difference levels marked with increasing letters; on the y-axis, the means required. The first level is satisfied by self-instruction, then come assisted instruction, the systems trainer, the flight trainer, and finally the full simulator combined with a check. Each step changes the nature of the means, and therefore the order of magnitude of the cost.self-instructionassisted instructionsystems trainerflight trainerfull simulator and checkABCDElevel of difference between modelsmeans required
The cost of a difference follows the step where the report placed it, not the size of the technical gap. Two very similar models can end up one step apart as soon as a single system touches on failure handling.

Two consequences. The question ‘is the type held?’ is poorly framed: the right one is ‘which variant, and what level of difference from the one the employer operates?’ And the table is not symmetrical: moving from an older model to a newer one is not at the same level as the reverse journey.

Maintaining the rating: two clocks that do not count the same way

A European type rating is valid for one year. Its revalidation rests on a proficiency check taken before an authorised examiner, supplemented by recent experience on the type expressed in sectors flown during the period, with relief where certain sectors are flown under supervision. The point that costs the most, however, lies elsewhere: the date from which the new period starts running.

A pilot in uniform reviews technical documents in a cockpit.
Type ratings require rigorous study of aircraft-specific data.
Effect of the check date on the validity of the ratingTwo timelines superimposed on a time axis graduated from zero to twenty-four months. On the first, the check is taken within the window preceding the expiry: the new period runs from the original expiry date and the validity is kept in full. On the second, the check is taken well earlier: the new period runs from the day of the check, and the months separating it from the maximum deferral are lost.original expirymaximum deferralcheck within the windowvalidity kept in fullearly checkmonths lost012 months24 months
A check taken too early does not extend the rating, it shifts it. Within the window it anchors on the expiry date; outside it, on the day of the check, and the gap repeats every cycle.

In Europe, if you take your type rating check too early, you lose some of your validity period. It’s better to schedule it close to the expiry date to keep your full year.

A pilot’s European type rating expires on December 31st. If they take their check on October 1st (within the 3-month window), their new rating is valid until December 31st of the next year. But if they take it on July 1st, their new rating only lasts until December 31st of the current year, losing 5 months of validity.

A check taken within the three-month window preceding the expiry anchors the new period on the expiry date itself; taken earlier, it anchors it on the day of the check. An operator who schedules its sessions according to simulator slots thus loses several weeks of validity every cycle, without anyone seeing a fault in it: the check is passed, the rating is valid, it simply expires earlier.

The trap. A check that is passed is not always a check that revalidates. Three faults recur: the session taken outside the window, and validity moves back; the examiner authorised for the operator’s check but not for the one that revalidates the rating, so only the operator part is credited; recent experience on the type not met, in which case passing the session is no longer enough.

The right instinct. Set the session date working back from the expiry date printed on the licence, never from the last check or the centre’s calendar. Before confirming, check that the examiner holds the privileges for both the licence part and the operator part, and that the sector count will be met by the planned date.

On the American side, the clock depends on the operating framework rather than on the licence: periodic check attached to the type outside public transport, the operator’s approved programme otherwise. The rating, once entered on the certificate, does not expire: it is the right to exercise it that dies out. One therefore sometimes reads a type valid for life on a certificate whose operational currency has been dead for years.

Moving to the left seat: what the rating does not give

In both systems, the type rating does not make a captain: it establishes mastery of the model. Command is built elsewhere, and that is where the two cultures diverge the most.

Europe has formalised an intermediate step: the pilot-in-command-under-supervision flight, where the first officer occupies the left seat and exercises the captain’s functions, a qualified captain supervising without intervening as long as safety is not at stake. The time thus flown counts as pilot-in-command time and feeds into the conditions for access to the Airline Transport Pilot Licence. The American system has no equivalent: counting there rests on actual handling of the controls or on formal designation as responsible for the flight.

This detail becomes central at the moment of conversion. No type rating carries over as such from one system to the other, and recognition of a foreign licence opens recreational privileges, not professional practice. What converts poorly is not the experience, it is its legal qualification.

What to check in your own file

Three checks settle most of the surprises, and none requires reading the regulation.

  • The first concerns the exact variant flown, not the family. Note the designation carried on the aircraft’s flight manual and compare it with the differences table for the model operated: it is this pairing that determines whether entry into service requires a reading or a full simulator session.
  • The second concerns the endorsements. On an American certificate, the right-seat limitation is written facing the type. On a European licence, look for the multi-pilot character of the rating, which prohibits reduced-crew operation even on a model that allows it, and the restriction attached to a Multi-crew Pilot Licence.
  • The third concerns the dates, and it is the one that gets neglected. Note the expiry of the rating, that of the operator’s check, that of the medical fitness, and the date of the last landing on the type: these four clocks are not synchronised, and the nearest one governs. These desynchronisations come up regularly in exchanges between pilots trained in the two systems, on the professional forum.

One grey area remains, and it is accepted as such: seat-related proficiency. In Europe it is named and maintained; in the United States it falls under the operator’s programme and leaves no trace on the certificate. A pilot who switches systems carries a real competence that nothing in the file can prove.

The applicable text, the list of ratings maintained by the authority, the data published for the type, and the operator’s approved documentation take precedence over this article, which describes mechanisms and replaces no training decision.

Questions fréquentes

Does a European first officer need a specific rating to occupy the right seat?

No. The European type rating is unique and carries no seat mention: from the licence’s point of view, it covers both seats. The differentiation comes from the licence held, from the operator’s command course, and, for the first officer liable to occupy the left seat, from a distinct qualification to operate from either seat.

What does an endorsement limiting a type to first officer duties mean on an American certificate?

It indicates that the rating was issued on the basis of first officer training and does not authorise exercising command on that type. It does not disappear with accumulated experience: a full practical test, to the standards of the licence level sought, must be passed to obtain the unrestricted rating.

Is a type rating obtained in one system recognised in the other?

Not directly. Each authority issues its own ratings at the end of a course taken with an organisation it approves, and recognition of a foreign licence does not open professional privileges. Experience gained is taken into account for access to the course and sometimes for its volume, but it exempts neither the training nor the skill test.

Why can two courses bearing the same type name last very different lengths of time?

Because the minimum programme is set by the dossier published for the model — Operational Suitability Data in Europe, and the Flight Standardization Board report in the United States. These dossiers classify the differences between variants according to the means required, from self-study to the full simulator with a check. Two close variants can therefore fall on either side of a step, with training costs on a very different scale.

When must the check that revalidates a European type rating be taken?

Within the three-month window preceding the rating’s expiry. Taken within that window, the check starts the new period from the original expiry, with no loss. Taken earlier, it starts the new period from the day of the check: validity moves back accordingly, and the gap repeats every cycle if scheduling does not correct it.

Does pilot-in-command-under-supervision time count for an American employer?

It has no regulatory equivalent in the American system, where command time is counted on actual handling of the controls or on designation as responsible for the flight. A European file showing pilot-in-command-under-supervision time must therefore be documented carefully, since its requalification in the other system is anything but automatic.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.