Mandated Blending and Transferable Certificates: How the Litre Is Really Counted

Camion avitailleur à un poste d'avion de nuit, tuyau enroulé et câble de continuité raccordé

The delivery note reads “Jet A-1.” So does the batch certificate of analysis. And yet, a few months later, the operator’s annual report announces several thousand tonnes of sustainable aviation fuel, on routes where the fueller never pumped anything but the airport’s common kerosene. All three documents are true. Between the litre that goes into the tanks and the tonne of declared avoided carbon dioxide, there is a chain of custody, auditors, a registry, and transfer rules that few practitioners have had the chance to look at closely.

The mandate does not fall on who you’d expect

The first surprise for anyone discovering the European framework: the blending obligation is not addressed to operators. It is addressed to aviation fuel suppliers who deliver at Union airports. It is the supplier who must demonstrate, over a reporting period, that a minimum share of what it made available fell under eligible fuels, with a sub-obligation specific to synthetic fuels of non-biological origin. The operator is not in breach for failing to uplift sustainable fuel: it does not choose the molecule that comes out of the hydrant.

What the regulation asks of the operator is of a different nature: actually uplifting on site nearly all of its annual requirement, airport by airport, to prevent the constraint from being circumvented through a practice of excess tankering from an airport not subject to the obligation. It is an anti-fuel-tankering rule, not a purchasing rule, and non-compliance is demonstrated by comparing declared uplifted fuel against the calculated annual requirement.

During the initial period, a flexibility mechanism is added that allows the supplier to spread its mandatory share across its network rather than meeting it at every airport served. A direct and rarely stated consequence: no airport guarantees that a given flight received a single drop of sustainable fuel, and this is not a failure of the system, it is its normal operation.

The fuel supplier, not the airline, must ensure a minimum share of sustainable fuel is available. Airlines must uplift most of their fuel at each airport, but they can’t guarantee their flights used any sustainable fuel—it’s all mixed in the system.

An airline operating from Paris (Charles de Gaulle) and Amsterdam (Schiphol) must uplift nearly all its fuel at both airports. However, the fuel supplier may meet the EU blending mandate by averaging sustainable fuel across its entire network, meaning a flight from Paris might not have used any sustainable fuel, even if the supplier’s overall mix complies.

Why the litre and the attribute separate

The cause is physical before it is legal. A fuel from synthetic pathways is not delivered pure: the specification requires it to be blended with fossil-origin kerosene, in a proportion capped pathway by pathway, with the order of magnitude allowed for the most common processes being at most half the volume, and markedly less for certain annexes. The blending happens upstream, at the depot, then the product joins a pipeline, a shared storage facility, a hydrant network shared among all users of a platform. From that point on, no analysis can tell which fraction of the litre drawn off comes from which feedstock: synthetic paraffinic hydrocarbons are, by design, indistinguishable from their fossil counterparts.

The industry has therefore adopted what the food and forestry industries have long practiced: mass balance. Physical blending is accepted, and each site keeps an account of inflows and outflows over a defined period, forbidding itself from releasing more sustainable attributes than it has taken in. The molecule flows through the pipes, the attribute through the ledger, and the two no longer meet.

Synthetic fuel is mixed with regular jet fuel, so you can’t tell which part is sustainable. Instead, the system tracks how much sustainable fuel was added to the system and assigns “credits” for it, which can be sold or transferred separately from the actual fuel.

A fuel depot blends 10,000 litres of synthetic fuel (50% sustainable) with 10,000 litres of conventional jet fuel. The resulting 20,000 litres are indistinguishable, but the system records 5,000 litres of sustainable fuel “credits” that can be assigned to flights, even though no single flight gets pure sustainable fuel.

Separation of the physical flow and the attribute flow at the blending pointA solid line connects the feedstock, production, blending, hydrant, then the aircraft. At the blending point, a dashed line descends toward a certified batch, then toward a registry and a retirement. The attribute joins a buyer who is not necessarily the operator of the flight.Physical flowfeedstockproductionblendinghydrantaircraftcertified batchregistryretirementAttribute flow
The litre and the avoided tonne do not travel together. At the blending point, the fuel becomes indistinguishable; only the accounting entry keeps track of its origin, and it is that entry which is sold, transferred, and retired.

Four ways to hold the chain of custody

Mass balance is not the only possible model, it is the compromise that was adopted. The four families are distinguished by a single question: what must be preserved of the link between the material and its sustainable quality? The stricter the required link, the more rigid the logistics become; the more it is relaxed, the tighter the documentary control must be for the claim to retain meaning.

Logistical flexibility of the four chains of custodyFour bars of increasing height from left to right: identity preservation the lowest, then segregation, then mass balance, then book and claim the highest. A vertical dashed line separates the first three, accepted for mandate compliance, from the last, reserved for voluntary claims.flexibilitylogisticsaccepted for the mandateoutside the mandateidentity preservedsegregationmass balancebook and claimFrom left to right, the physical link between the litre and the attribute weakens.
The stricter the physical traceability, the less flexible the logistics. Mandatory regimes stop at mass balance; book and claim, even more convenient, serves only voluntary claims.
The four chains of custody and what they allow you to state
Model What the delivered batch contains Where the attribute can be claimed Use in aviation
Identity preserved Material of a single origin, traced back to the plot or collection site On the batch itself, and nowhere else Trials, demonstrations, niche pathways
Segregation Only certified material, but of origins mixed together On the batch, without distinction of origin Dedicated deliveries, truck fuelling
Mass balance A mix of certified and non-certified material, in unknown proportion at output On an equivalent quantity, within the limits of the scope and accounting period Default regime for the mandate and offsetting schemes
Book and claim No link required: the fuel is delivered wherever logistics are best By the certificate holder, wherever located Voluntary claims by corporate customers, outside regulatory compliance

What a certified batch really contains

On the ground, sustainable fuel does not announce itself. The specification for aviation fuels containing synthesized hydrocarbons describes each production pathway in a separate annex — hydroprocessing of esters and fatty acids, Fischer-Tropsch synthesis, alcohol-to-jet conversion, among others — each with a blending cap and its own requirements. Once blending is complete and rechecked, the product is redesignated as ordinary aviation kerosene under the usual specification. It is no longer a sustainable fuel in the documentary sense: it is Jet A-1, with the same limits on freezing point, conductivity, and sulphur content.

The physical differences exist but stay within tight bounds. Synthetic components are practically free of sulphur and aromatics, which slightly lowers density and slightly raises specific energy. This is precisely why the specification imposes a floor on aromatics in the blend: the elastomer seals, in circuits designed decades ago, need this swelling to remain leak-tight. None of this changes a flight preparation: the density used is that of the batch, as always.

Four documents, four objects — and what none of them proves
Document What it establishes What it does not establish
Batch certificate of analysis The delivered product’s conformity with the specification’s characteristics The share of sustainable fuel it contains, nor its origin
Sustainability declaration of the chain of custody The origin of the feedstock, the sustainability criteria met, the emissions value used That the described material is present in the batch delivered to a given airport
Supplier’s annual declaration Compliance with the mandatory share across the declared scope That a particular airport or flight was served eligible fuel
Attribute certificate transferred to a third party That a quantity of avoided emissions has been attributed to a named buyer That this buyer travelled, or even flew, on the fuel concerned

What counts as a reduction

The claimed reduction is not a tailpipe reduction. Carbon leaves the engine exactly as before: for equal energy, combustion produces essentially the same amount of carbon dioxide. What changes happens upstream, and is measured by an LCA that traces back to feedstock collection, its conversion and its transport, then compares the total to a fossil baseline. Carbon emitted in flight is deemed offset by that fixed by the biomass, or by that captured to manufacture the synthetic fuel.

Two refinements deserve the practitioner’s attention. First, the international offsetting scheme distinguishes a core component, specific to the process, from a component tied to the land-use change induced by feedstock demand: it is the sum of the two that is used in the calculation. Second, the operator can choose between a default value, published by pathway and deliberately conservative, and an actual value calculated on its own supply chain, more favourable but which must be documented and verified. Two batches identical at the engine can thus carry different declared reductions, without either being false.

Double counting, and what holds it back

As soon as the attribute separates from the material, it becomes possible to count it twice: once by the airline that bought the fuel, once by the shipper or corporate customer to whom it transferred the certificate; or once under the European mandate, once under the international offsetting scheme. The anti-double-counting mechanism rests on four pieces: a unique batch identifier carried by the sustainability declaration, a database or registry where the quantity is recorded, a retirement that renders the attribute unusable once claimed, and a written no-double-claiming declaration signed by each link.

This is where the control changes in nature. A physical characteristic is measured; a documentary chain of custody can only be verified by cross-checking — consistency of inflows and outflows over the period, agreement between the registries of two sites, uniqueness of identifiers, traceability of cancellations. The pathway auditor does not take a sample: they compare records and look for the quantity that appears twice.

The trap. Selling the environmental attribute to a corporate customer for its travel footprint, then also counting it in one’s own inventory or in one’s mandate compliance. The transfer is clean, the internal declaration is too, and yet the same tonne has been claimed twice. The mirror image exists on the buyer’s side: paying for a certificate already retired by a third party, for lack of having demanded proof of retirement in the registry.

What does not transfer

Carbon dioxide has a property that makes the certificate legitimate: its climate effect depends on neither the place nor the time of emission. A tonne avoided at one end of the network is worth a tonne avoided at the other end, and it is rational to burn the blend where logistics are least costly. This fungibility stops dead as soon as one leaves carbon dioxide alone.

Bench and flight tests show that blends with a high paraffinic content markedly reduce non-volatile particles at engine exit, with an expected effect on the formation and persistence of condensation trails, since these particles serve as ice nuclei. These benefits are attached to the flight that actually burned the blend, to its route, its altitude, the atmosphere crossed that day. No certificate moves them, and air quality around a platform obeys the same rule.

Extent of effects and reach of a transferable certificateTwo horizontal bands. The first, spanning the full width, represents the life-cycle climate effect of carbon dioxide, independent of place, therefore transferable. The second, narrow and centred, represents non-volatile particles and condensation trails, attached to the route flown, therefore non-transferable.carbon dioxide, life cycletransferableparticles and trailsnon-transferableroute flownextent of the effect, in space and in timeA certificate acts on the top band, never on the bottom one.
A certificate moves carbon, not particles. The effect of carbon dioxide ignores the place of emission, which permits transfer; local effects remain on the route actually flown, whatever the records say.

The right instinct. Separate, in all internal and external communication, what belongs to a transferable attribute from what belongs to a local physical effect. Writing “we funded the blending of so many tonnes” is not the same as “this flight emitted fewer particles”: the first claim is proven by a retirement in the registry, the second requires that the blend was actually burned on that particular flight, which presupposes a segregated delivery and a fuelling record.

What to go check in your own documentation

Three places deserve a careful read before the next reporting deadline. In supply contracts, the clause that says who retires the attribute: the supplier, the operator, or an intermediary. An ambiguous wording is enough to create a double claim in good faith, and it is the auditor who will find it. In reporting procedures, the scope and period of the mass balance used by the supplier: a broad scope and a long period make the statement “this network is supplied with sustainable fuel” true over the reporting period, and false on any given flight. In agreements with corporate customers, the explicit mention that the transferred attribute leaves the operator’s balance.

A worker in a high-visibility vest checks a clipboard next to a computer monitor displaying a graph of production data in an industrial setting with large tanks.
Production data tracking ensures accurate fuel blending compliance.

Grey areas remain and it is better to name them than to discover them. Cross-recognition between certification schemes is not total: a batch certified for one regime is not automatically certified for the other. Allocation of the attribute among the flights of a single reporting period remains an internal convention, not a measured fact, which makes any ticket-level declaration delicate. The treatment of chartered flights, where the holder of the operator certificate is not the one selling the trip, requires a written agreement: failing that, the same quantity appears in two inventories. For anyone preparing to take up a role in fuel procurement or environmental compliance, it is this mechanics — not the chemistry of the pathways — that forms the heart of the matter, and exchanges between practitioners show that the most persistent confusion remains that between the litre delivered and the tonne declared.

The applicable text, the decisions of the competent authority and the operator’s approved documentation prevail in all circumstances over this article, whose sole purpose is to set out the mechanism; in case of discrepancy, it is the operator’s procedures and the certification standards that govern.

Questions fréquentes

Has the sustainable fuel my airline bought actually gone into my tanks?

Almost never, and the system does not provide for it. Once the blend is made and injected into a shared storage facility or hydrant network, the synthetic molecules are indistinguishable from fossil kerosene, and the fuel drawn off belongs to all users of the platform. What the operator buys is the environmental attribute of an equivalent quantity, tracked by mass balance. Only a segregated delivery by dedicated truck allows one to state that a given flight actually burned the blend.

Does the certificate of analysis of the delivered batch mention the sustainable share?

No. After blending and rechecking, the product is redesignated as ordinary aviation kerosene and its certificate of analysis carries only the specification’s characteristics: freezing point, density, conductivity, sulphur content, aromatics. The sustainable share and its origin appear on a separate document, the sustainability declaration issued under the chain of custody. The two documents do not replace each other and do not cross-reference each other.

Can an airline sell the attribute to a corporate customer and also count it in its own inventory?

No, this is precisely the double counting that registries and no-double-claiming declarations seek to prevent. As soon as the attribute is transferred and retired in the buyer’s name, it leaves the seller’s inventory, who can no longer invoke it either in its communication or in regulatory compliance. The transfer must be in writing and the outflow must be traceable in the registry, otherwise the pathway auditor will flag the quantity appearing twice.

Does mass balance allow claiming sustainable fuel at an airport that never receives any?

Yes, within the limits of the scope and accounting period used. Mass balance does not require the certified material to be physically present in the delivered batch: it requires that attribute outflows not exceed inflows within the declared scope. The flexibility mechanism provided for the initial period of the European mandate indeed extends this logic to the scale of a supplier’s network. This is why a statement true over a reporting period can be false at the level of a single flight.

Does flight preparation need to be adjusted when the batch contains a share of synthetic fuel?

No, since the blend is redesignated as ordinary aviation kerosene and complies with all the specification’s limits. Density is slightly lower and specific energy slightly higher, but the value used is the one measured on the batch and enters the calculation as usual. The aromatics floor imposed on the blend protects the swelling of seals in older circuits. No specific operating procedure follows from it.

Why doesn't the blending mandate apply directly to operators?

Because an operator does not choose the molecule that comes out of the hydrant: the obligation was placed where it is enforceable, that is, with the aviation fuel supplier that supplies the airport. The operator carries a separate obligation, that of actually uplifting on site nearly all of its annual requirement, intended to prevent circumvention through excess tankering from an airport not subject to the obligation. Both obligations are checked through annual declarations and cross-checking, not at the gate.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.