Two noise-optimized departure profiles: where each shifts the noise, and its fuel cost

Champ en lisière de zone habitée au crépuscule, avion en montée au-dessus des toits sur ciel froid

Two aircraft of the same type depart from the same threshold, at the same weight, three minutes apart. The first passes over the housing estate while climbing steeply, with landing gear extended, at low speed. The second passes lower at the same point but is already clean and will be significantly higher fifteen kilometers further on. Neither has been quieter than the other—they’ve just displaced the noise elsewhere. The question remains: where, who is protected, who isn’t, and who pays in fuel.

What is displaced, and what is not removed

The noise level received by a resident depends on three factors, and a departure procedure only controls two of them. The first is the acoustic power emitted. On a jet engine, the noise from the jet mixing varies as a very high power of the ejection velocity—the so-called eighth-power law—so a modest reduction in thrust disproportionately reduces the noise source. On high-bypass engines, the fan contributes more, but the principle holds: the engine speed controls the noise level much faster than proportionally.

The second factor is the oblique distance between the source and the ear. A point source in free field loses about six decibels for each doubling of distance, plus atmospheric absorption (which affects high frequencies most) and lateral attenuation (which depends on the angle at which the aircraft is viewed and what lies between it and the ground). The third factor is directivity: a jet engine does not radiate equally forward and aft, which is why a resident hears the aircraft longer after passing than before.

Of these three factors, the procedure affects engine speed and geometry. This is where the difference between the two profile families lies, and it’s also where the most common reasoning trap occurs: gaining altitude only pays off if the aircraft is near the vertical of the listener. From a distance, at a shallow angle, an extra hundred meters changes the oblique distance hardly at all.

The noise you hear from an aircraft depends on how loud it is, how far away it is, and the direction it’s pointing. The departure procedure can only change the first two: by reducing engine noise or by making the aircraft climb higher (and thus farther away). But extra height only helps if you’re directly below the plane—farther away, the difference is tiny.

An Airbus A320 departing from Paris Charles de Gaulle on a 3,000-meter runway at 15°C. At 800 feet (thrust reduction altitude), the “close” profile accelerates immediately, reaching 250 knots by 1,500 feet. The “distant” profile stays at 180 knots until 3,000 feet, gaining 100 meters of altitude over the first 2 km—but at 5 km, the “close” profile is 200 meters higher and quieter.

Height only pays off close to the overhead pointA resident on the ground and four aircraft positions: two close to overhead, one low and one high, two much further away at the same heights. Near overhead, climbing clearly lengthens the slant distance. Far ahead, the two slant distances are almost identical: the extra height brings only a marginal gain.riverainclose to overheadloin devantgain netgain faiblehautbas
Height only buys slant distance near the overhead point. The two solid lines show the distance difference gained near the listening point; the two dashed lines, almost superimposed, show that far away the same extra height hardly lengthens the sound path at all.

A word on airframe noise, often incorrectly cited here. Flaps and slats generate it, but at takeoff power, it’s masked by the engines, and the landing gear is already retracted. Keeping the takeoff configuration longer costs fuel, not decibels. All the acoustic advantage of the profile that retains its flaps comes from the altitude gained, never from its drag.

Two configuration schedules, one physics

The two NADP standardized profiles are based on the same framework: a thrust reduction altitude, an acceleration altitude, and a procedure end altitude. The international framework sets a minimum for thrust reduction—around eight hundred feet above the aerodrome elevation—and ends the procedure at about three thousand feet, beyond which the climb becomes a normal climb. Many operators raise this minimum for margin or standardization reasons: their documentation is the law, not the generic value.

What distinguishes the two profiles is a single decision: where to place the acceleration altitude. Setting it at the thrust reduction minimum gives the so-called distant profile; delaying it to the end of the procedure gives the so-called close profile. Everything else—climb speed, gradient, flap retraction timing, time spent at climb power—follows mechanically.

Configuration timeline of the two profilesTwo horizontal bands aligned on a height scale. Profile one keeps the take-off configuration from the ground to the end of the procedure, then cleans up. Profile two keeps the take-off configuration only up to the thrust reduction height, then accelerates, cleans up and continues in clean configuration.height thresholds above the aerodromethrust reductionend of procedureNADP 1NADP 2take-off configuration heldlissagetake-offacceleration, clean-up, clean climbsolaround 800 ftaround 3,000 ft
Only one parameter separates the two procedures: the acceleration height. The two bands share the same thrust reduction height and the same end of procedure; what changes is the length of the segment flown in take-off configuration.

NADP 1: Altitude first

At the thrust reduction altitude, the crew transitions to climb power but does not change the configuration or speed: flaps remain in the takeoff position, and speed is maintained at the takeoff safety speed plus ten to twenty knots. All excess thrust then goes into the climb rate, as nothing is diverted to accelerate. This is the maximum gradient the aircraft can sustain with all engines, and it holds until the end of the procedure, where acceleration and flap retraction finally occur.

The result is clear at short distances: the aircraft is higher over the first few kilometers, thus farther in oblique distance, and quieter where altitude differences still matter. In return, it remains slow, in an extended configuration, with poor glide ratio.

Vertical profiles of the two noise abatement departures comparedTwo flight paths from the same point. The first climbs steeply to the end of the procedure before accelerating; the second flattens from the reduction height to accelerate and clean up, then resumes a more efficient climb and catches up with the first at a distance from the aerodrome.hauteurdistance from brake releaseend of procedurethrust reductionNADP 1NADP 2croisement
The profile that protects close-in residents is the one that loses further out. The solid line gains height straight away; the dashed line sacrifices it to accelerate, then climbs better once clean and passes back above beyond the crossover point.

NADP 2: Speed and glide ratio first

Same thrust reduction altitude, but acceleration begins immediately: excess thrust first goes into kinetic energy, flaps retract as per the schedule, and the aircraft completes the procedure clean, at climb speed. The path during acceleration is almost flat, and this is precisely what is visible from the ground at short distances.

What follows is less visible but equally real. A clean aircraft has a much better glide ratio; at the same climb power, it climbs faster and, above all, climbs faster with less thrust. The distant resident therefore receives an aircraft that is both higher and quieter at the source. The energy did not disappear during acceleration: it changed form, then was converted into altitude when the aircraft became efficient. The choice between the two profiles is not a choice between more or less noise; it’s a choice about when the energy is absorbed.

Where the crossover point lies

The two noise level curves cross somewhere. Exactly where, no one can say without calculation: it depends on the type, weight, thrust setting, temperature, terrain, and ground composition between the aircraft and the listener. The certification noise measurement points give the scale of the problem: the lateral point is a few hundred meters from the runway centerline, and the flyover point is a few kilometers from brake release. The crossover typically falls beyond the first and in the region of the second, where the suburbs begin rather than the immediate vicinity.

Noise level received on the ground versus distanceTwo decreasing curves of noise level received on the ground. Profile one’s starts lower and decreases slowly; profile two’s starts higher and decreases faster. They cross halfway: before this point, profile one is the quieter; after it, profile two.level receivedground distanceNADP 1NADP 2bascule
The crossover is not a constant; it is the result of a calculation. Its position depends on the type, the mass and the thrust setting: it moves with every departure, which rules out choosing a profile out of habit rather than from the aerodrome’s noise map.
What each profile does, protects and costs
Item NADP 1 (close-in noise) NADP 2 (distant noise)
Acceleration height end of procedure thrust reduction height
Initial climb configuration take-off flaps held retracted on schedule
Vitesse tenue safety speed plus a small increment clean climb speed
Gradient over the first few kilometres maximal reduced during acceleration
Residents who benefit immediate vicinity of the runway built-up areas beyond the crossover
Lift-to-drag ratio during the procedure degraded over the whole length degraded over a short segment
Fuel burn on departure the higher of the two the lower of the two
Sensitivity to an imposed level-off high: the aircraft stays slow and configured low: it is already clean

What the close profile costs

The energy cost of the close profile is not found in a table: it is the product of excess drag and the distance covered in the extended configuration. Every meter flown with flaps extended is paid for at the rate of degraded glide ratio, and the close profile multiplies these meters, as it retains the configuration until the end of the procedure instead of abandoning it at the thrust reduction altitude. It’s the area between two drag curves.

The extra fuel cost is the area between two drag curvesDrag versus time since brake release. Both profiles start from the same high level, corresponding to the take-off configuration. Profile two drops early to the clean level, profile one much later. The area between the two transitions represents the extra fuel burned.dragtime since brake releasetake-off configurationlisseextra costNADP 2NADP 1
The extra fuel is read as an area, not as a flat rate. It grows with the time spent in take-off configuration: the higher the acceleration height, the larger the departure’s energy bill.

At the scale of a flight, the difference is not measured in tons or minutes: it is counted with each departure, across an entire fleet, every day. This cumulative impact is what matters to an operator, and that’s why the decision is not made in the cockpit. Add to this a rarely mentioned effect: the additional fuel is burned low, in the atmospheric boundary layer, where nitrogen oxides affect local air quality. Protecting the immediate resident’s ears therefore costs some of their air, making the choice between the two profiles an environmental trade-off, not just an acoustic option.

When the noise reduction profile takes a back seat

A noise reduction procedure is never prioritized over safety, and the list of situations that suspend it is longer than one might think. It starts before takeoff: in wet snow conditions, deicing imposes an effectiveness window, engine anti-icing consumes power, and the available performance becomes the constraint that dictates the profile.

An engine failure changes everything: the noise reduction profile is abandoned, the clean trajectory and the go-around path take precedence, and the acceleration altitude to be maintained is no longer that of the noise procedure but the one that ensures obstacle clearance. Wind shear, turbulence, icing in climb, level-off, or speed reductions imposed by ATC produce the same effect.

What takes precedence over the noise abatement profile, and by what mechanism
Situation What then governs Effect on the profile
Contaminated runway take-off performance and flight path control profile subordinate to the performance calculation
Engine failure after the decision net flight path and obstacle clearance noise procedure abandoned
Nearby terrain or obstacle acceleration height determined by obstacles acceleration height raised, profile imposed
Level-off imposed by ATC compliance with the clearance early clean-up, procedure interrupted
Wind shear or turbulence configuration and manoeuvring speed profile abandoned at the crew’s discretion

The trap. The numbering is not universal. An operator may name its profiles differently than the international framework, and an aerodrome publication may prescribe one by description rather than by number. An crew may then conscientiously apply the distant profile while believing they are applying the close profile. The second trap is more insidious: the acceleration altitude entered into the flight management system does not distinguish on its own between the all-engine acceleration altitude and the obstacle protection altitude in case of engine failure. Entering one for the other goes unnoticed until something happens.

What to verify in your own documentation

Three questions suffice, and none are resolved in flight. Which profile does the operations manual prescribe by default, and in what terms—mandatory, recommended, or left to the captain’s discretion? Are the two altitudes expressed as height above the aerodrome or as altitude, and what exactly does the flight management system do with the entered value? Finally, what abandonment criteria are written in black and white, and are they stated in the departure briefing rather than assumed to be known?

Two pilots in a cockpit examine a display showing noise and fuel cost profiles.
Balancing noise reduction and fuel efficiency in flight operations requires careful planning.

The right reflex. State the two altitudes aloud during the briefing, with their reference—thrust reduction altitude, acceleration altitude, and the value retained in case of engine failure if it differs—then compare them with what is actually displayed in the computer. This is the only check that catches both input errors, confusion between the two profiles, and the substitution of an obstacle altitude for a noise altitude.

There remains a gray area that the cockpit cannot fill: the crossover point is published nowhere. A crew applying the local instruction does not know if it effectively protects the targeted population—that demonstration is the responsibility of the aerodrome manager and the balanced approach that frames noise-related restrictions, where noise reduction procedures come only after source reduction and urban planning control. For those preparing a type rating or line training, the question asked in the simulator is almost never “which profile”: it’s “what do you abandon first, and to what signal”. Discussions on these local instructions continue on the FL330 forum.

Finally, this text describes a mechanism, not an applicable instruction: the applicable regulatory text, the aerodrome’s aeronautical information publication, and the operator’s approved documentation take precedence in all cases over what is written here.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.