Single-Engine Taxi: Fuel Savings Versus Wear, and the Conditions That Prohibit It

Tracteur sans barre attelé à un train avant sur une aire mouillée à l'aube, gyrophare ambré allumé

Four minutes of taxi from the stand to the runway: should the second engine keep running? The question seems arithmetic – two engines at idle burn twice as much as one – but it is not. The saving window is much shorter than the taxi time, and a large part of what is saved on the engine is given back elsewhere: to the APU, the brakes, the tires. The balance depends on the conditions, and some factors can make the question irrelevant before it is even asked.

The savings window is shorter than the taxi time

The mental calculation is always the same: the fuel consumption of a large turbofan at ground idle – in the order of hundreds of kilograms per hour – multiplied by the duration of the taxi. The result is flattering and wrong, because it attributes all the savings of the time between position and threshold.

Two limits shrink it. Upstream, pushback, the first engine start and the initial movement take time, whatever procedure is chosen. Downstream, the second engine must be started, its parameters checked, and then it must stabilize at idle for the time prescribed by the manufacturer – typically a few minutes, the exact value being type-specific – before takeoff thrust can be applied. Add the flight control check, configuration, and the time lost to a late runway change, and what remains is the stretch actually taxied on one engine.

One point deserves correcting, because the misconception is widespread: the procedure does not add an engine cycle. On departure, the second engine is started once, just later; on arrival, it is shut down once, just earlier. The engine cycle counter does not move, and the argument of accelerated hot-section ageing does not apply here. The costs, if any, lie elsewhere.

Where fuel is actually saved during taxi to takeoffTwo horizontal bars show the same taxi. The upper bar, taxi with two engines, is uniformly equal over its entire length. The lower bar is divided into three sections: a first section for resetting and starting the first engine, a middle section with the second engine shut down, then a final section for the second start and stabilization before takeoff. A bracket under the lower bar shows that the savings window only covers the middle section.Taxi with two enginestwo engines at idleTaxi with one engineEngine 2 shut downSavings windowResetting2nd start
The saving occurs only in the middle section of the taxi. The two limits – the movement on one side, the second start and stabilization on the other – do not depend on the chosen procedure. For a short taxi, they consume almost all the available time.

The savings from running one engine instead of two are much smaller than you might think. You lose time starting and stopping the second engine, and the actual fuel saved is only during the middle part of the taxi. The rest of the time, you’re either preparing to shut down or restarting the engine.

On an Airbus A320, the savings window for single-engine taxi is typically 8-10 minutes. If your taxi is only 5 minutes, you might not save any fuel at all because the startup and shutdown times eat up most of the potential savings.

The APU is the forgotten accountant of the operation

The second start needs air. Only two sources: the APU or cross-bleed from the running engine. This choice decides almost everything in the balance and is rarely considered as such.

If the APU is running during taxi to remain available, its consumption is directly deducted from the announced savings. It is not negligible compared to an engine at idle: For a short taxi, it can completely cancel them out. Cross-bleed avoids these costs, but requires that the running engine has sufficient compressor speed to operate the starter. The thrust then increases on one side while the aircraft is taxiing. For this exact reason, most procedures require that maneuvers be straight, at low speed or stopped, never in a turn or near another aircraft.

An additional systems constraint is sometimes discovered during taxi. With one engine, one generator and one hydraulic system are supplied from a backup source: electric pump, PTU or APU. However, nose wheel steering and normal braking are not powered by every system, and those are the ones you need. The question is not « Can we shut down an engine? », but « Which one, and what remains powered? ».

Three ways to start the second engine, and what each one costs
Configuration Air source for the start Costs deducted Effect during maneuvers
Two engines from the stand not applicable none, but double consumption during the entire taxi symmetric thrust, standard control, uniform airflow
One engine, APU remains in operation APU APU consumption during the entire taxi duration, ground emissions Start without disturbances, no thrust change
One engine, start by cross-bleed running engine brief power increase on the running engine, APU shut down the rest of the time speed and thrust increase on one side, hold straight
One engine, second start at the holding point APU or cross-bleed Stabilization time comes out of the waiting time, risk of delay when lining up maximum savings window, no buffer time

What the procedure shifts in emissions

Idle is the operating state in which combustion is the least efficient in the entire landing-takeoff cycle: unburned hydrocarbon and carbon monoxide emissions are highest there, while nitrogen oxides are lowest. Shutting down an engine at idle removes a larger share of local pollutants than of fuel; the air quality argument is stronger than the fuel argument, and it is the one airport operators put forward.

The trade-off reads the same way. Running the remaining engine above idle improves combustion efficiency but increases nitrogen oxides. And an APU that keeps running emits on the ground, in a confined area where nothing disperses, what an engine would have emitted while taxiing. Noise follows the same logic: a ground observer perceives the loudest source, not the sum, and one engine at breakaway thrust can be more disturbing at the adjacent stand than two engines at idle.

Net fuel savings depending on taxi durationTwo ascending lines start at a negative value below a horizontal axis with the value zero. The solid line without APU crosses zero early and rises sharply. The dashed line, APU remains in operation during the entire taxi, starts deeper, rises more slowly, and crosses zero much later. Two points mark these two profitability thresholds on the duration axis.0Net savingTaxi durationwithout APUAPU in operationThresholdThreshold
The profitability threshold shifts with the APU, not with the goodwill of the crew. The two lines start below zero because the procedure initially costs before it yields gains. An APU that continues to run shortens the slope and shifts the threshold to the right.

The remaining engine does not run at idle

Moving a loaded aircraft requires breakaway thrust, which is normally shared between two engines. With one engine, the same total thrust must be produced at a single point of application, several meters off the longitudinal axis. The resulting yawing moment is the product of this thrust and this lever arm: it increases with mass, slope and anything that demands more thrust.

At first, it is countered by nose wheel steering. However, the side force a nose wheel can develop is limited by its load and the available friction. On a wet, slippery or contaminated surface, this ceiling drops; steering saturates, and only differential braking remains to hold the track. The difficult case is a turn towards the running engine: the thrust works against the turn instead of helping it, and demands more steering, more braking and often a burst of thrust so as not to stall halfway through the turn – which worsens the yawing moment one was trying to limit.

Jet blast follows thrust. The area in which blast velocity remains dangerous extends much further than at idle. On a crowded apron with personnel, ground equipment and vehicles, this parameter governs the operation before any fuel consideration.

Asymmetric thrust and forces absorbed by the landing gearTop view of a twin-engine aircraft. The left engine is operating and generates a forward thrust offset from the aircraft axis by a lever arm represented by a dashed line. This creates a right yaw moment represented by a curved arrow near the nose. Two arrows show the means of compensation: turning the nose wheel and braking the left main wheel. The right engine is shut down.ThrustLever armRight yaw momentTurningLeft brakeRunning engineShut-down engine
The yaw moment follows the requested thrust, not the taxi speed. As long as the nose wheel keeps its lateral grip, steering is enough to counter it; once it saturates, the rest goes to the brake on the running engine’s side.

The trap of the cross-bleed start in a turn. The power increase required for cross-bleed produces extra thrust from the running engine, precisely when control is already at the limit. The reflex is then to brake to hold the track, putting energy into one brake while the other stays cold – and the temperature difference shows up later at the holding point. The cross-bleed start is set up in a straight line, before or after the turn.

What the brakes and tires return to the calculation

With two engines at idle, taxiing proceeds in stages: residual thrust accelerates the aircraft, then rolling resistance and short, light brake applications slow it down. With one engine, idle thrust rarely sustains movement at high mass: thrust has to be added, and the excess then has to be dissipated. The technique changes – it becomes a sequence of thrust and brake applications, more frequent than before.

The total energy put into the brakes is not necessarily higher; operational experience differs on this point, and the type of airport matters more than the procedure. However, the asymmetry is undeniable. The differential braking used to counter the yawing moment always loads the same side, and wear is uneven between the main landing gears. The same goes for the tires: harder, sustained steering increases wear on the nose tires, which wear by scrubbing, not by rolling.

Brake temperature is the other cost, and the most operational one. It determines the energy absorption margin available in the event of a rejected takeoff and, above a threshold defined in the documentation, requires waiting before lining up. At the holding point with hot brakes, this means paying twice: the fuel burned while waiting and the savings that preceded it.

Increase in brake temperature during taxiTwo sawtooth curves rise during taxi: each tooth corresponds to a braking, followed by partial cooling. The solid curve, taxi with two engines, rises slowly and remains low. The dashed curve, taxi with one engine, has higher teeth, rises faster, and approaches at the end of the path a horizontal dashed limit, above which one must wait before aligning.Limit before alignmentone enginetwo enginesBrake temperatureTaxi duration
It is not the average that counts, but the peak value on reaching the runway. Each spike is a brake application. Single-engine taxi increases their number and loads one side more; the remaining margin is read at the holding point, not at the stand.

The trap of hot brakes at the holding point. The temperature indication takes time to rise, and the peak is often reached after stopping, when airflow no longer cools the wheels. A value that is acceptable on the taxiway says nothing about the value two minutes later. The decisive value is the one at the actual takeoff, not at the last turn.

The conditions that make the question irrelevant

Part of the subject is not a trade-off: there are cases where the procedure is not open to discussion. What they have in common is that the available friction, the thrust margin, or both are degraded.

An airplane lands on a snowy runway, with snow being kicked up by the wheels.
Single-engine taxi requires careful consideration of surface conditions.

A taxiway covered with slush combines both effects. Lateral friction decreases while rolling resistance requires higher breakaway thrust; and the running engine, alone, throws up and ingests more contaminants. The second engine, for its part, is started with an inlet that has received what the first one kicked up.

The conditions that influence the decision, the mechanism that limits it, and the signal that should warn
Condition Affected mechanism Warning signal
Contaminated surfaces: slush, snow, standing water reduced lateral grip on the nose landing gear, higher breakaway thrust, contaminants thrown into the inlet the aircraft starts to yaw despite heavy steering, or refuses to move at idle
Ground icing conditions no anti-icing on a shut-down engine and no airflow to clear what has built up on the spinner and the fan blades visible icing on a leading edge or an inlet, temperature near the dew point
Slope, soft ground, damaged surface increased rolling resistance and breakaway thrust, longer jet blast area more than one thrust application needed to move off after each stop
Crowded area, personnel, and ground material the blast area of one engine at high thrust exceeds that of two engines at idle Cones, ground vehicles or personnel behind the aircraft, in the blast axis
High mass and tight turns maximum yawing moment and minimum available side force on the nose landing gear at the same time turn that must be performed in the direction of the running engine
Short taxi or dense takeoff sequence the stabilization time before takeoff thrust does not fit in the remaining time announced queue, probable runway change, or takeoff

Ground icing conditions pose another, more insidious problem: a shut-down engine has no anti-icing. Ice builds up on its inlet, its spinner and its fan blades, whereas on the running engine it is normally shed from the leading edges by rotation, periodic run-ups and hot anti-icing air. Whatever has accumulated during taxi will be ingested at takeoff, when the aircraft is already close to the runway. This is why most operating procedures simply exclude single-engine taxi when ground icing conditions are forecast or observed.

Decision sequence before initiating the procedureThree questions are aligned in a left column from top to bottom: taxi duration above the threshold, dry and ice-free runways, free area with moderate slope and turns. Each positive answer leads to the next question, the last one leads to the block “Taxi with one engine” at the bottom of the column. From each question, a dashed arrow leads to the right to a negative answer, and the three converge in a common block: two engines, normal procedure.Taxi durationabove the threshold?dry runways, noice announced?free area, moderate slope, andturns?Taxi with one engineyesyesyestwo engines:normal procedurenonono
The duration comes first because it alone decides whether there is anything to gain. The two following questions are non-negotiable: a single negative answer leads to the normal procedure, without economic consideration.

The right reflex: decide at the stand, not during taxi. Make the decision before moving, while the taxi route, the runway conditions, the departure sequence and the mass can all still be weighed. Announce it, with the engine concerned and the point where the second engine will be started: the crew then knows what to expect, and reverting to the normal procedure will be an explicit choice, not an improvisation during taxi.

The procedure is different upon return

Taxi with one engine upon arrival is subject to a constraint that does not exist on departure: the cool-down period. After a high-power phase and the use of thrust reversers, the engine must run at idle for the time prescribed by the manufacturer before shutdown, otherwise the residual heat in the hot section is not carried away by airflow and lubricant. The risk is not immediate: it takes the form of oil coking in the bearing compartments and thermal rotor bow. For a short arrival taxi, this time alone consumes most of the time available, saving nothing.

The choice of engine is not neutral. It depends on the hydraulic system that powers nose wheel steering and normal braking, the APU status, the side from which the stand is entered and the direction of the last turn – preferably keep the engine that helps the turn rather than the one that resists it. It also depends on the ground crew: the hazard area of a running engine when entering the stand differs from side to side, and the ground crew lead must know which one is still running.

The right reflex on arrival: announce the side before entering the stand. Tell the ground crew which engine is still running, and shut it down only once stopped with chocks in place, if the stand configuration requires it. The minute saved by an early shutdown is worth nothing compared with a ground agent who walks round the wrong side of the aircraft because he thought both engines were shut down.

What else must be checked in your own documentation

Four points deserve to be looked up in the operations manual, rather than assumed. The exact duration of stabilization before applying takeoff thrust and the cooling duration before shutdown, specific to the aircraft type and sometimes to the engine standard. The rule for cross-bleed: allowed during taxi or only at the position. The brake temperature limit applied before alignment and how it is read. Finally, who makes the decision: the company policy with a list of conditions, a simple recommendation, or the full authority of the captain – all three formulations exist and do not mean the same thing.

There remains a gray area that the documentation will not fill. The saved fuel is measured, summed, and presented; the wear of the brakes and tires attributable to the procedure is rarely measured at the fleet level, as it mixes with the geometry of the airport, the mass, and the driving style. The accounting is asymmetrical by nature, and a positive result is not necessarily complete. If you are preparing a type rating, this is the argument an examiner is looking for: not the recitation of conditions, but the ability to explain why each one is there. Operators continue the discussion in the FL330 forum.

In case of discrepancy, the applicable text, the aircraft flight manual and the operator’s approved documentation take precedence over everything above: this article explains mechanisms but does not replace any procedure.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.