Accredited representative and advisors: who sits on an international investigation, and in what capacity

Fragments d'épave disposés sur une trame de ruban au sol d'un hangar, lampes d'inspection ambrées

An aircraft registered in one State, operated by a company from a second, designed in a third, assembled in a fourth, runs off the runway in a fifth, with nationals from a dozen countries on board. Within hours, several administrations and as many industrial players want to know. A single authority will lead the investigation; all others will only have the rights granted by the text, and not one more. Knowing which role you hold—accredited representative, advisor, designated expert, or mere recipient of the report—determines what you will see, what you will have to provide without being asked, and above all, what you will not be allowed to repeat upon returning to headquarters.

One investigation, one project manager

The principle has no useful exception: the State on whose territory the event occurred opens the investigation, conducts it, and bears responsibility. It appoints an investigator in charge of the investigation, who exercises unshared control over the conduct of the work—the scope, the sequence of examinations, the composition of working groups, the schedule. If it lacks the technical means for the case, it may delegate all or part of the investigation to another State or a regional investigation body: this delegation is concluded by agreement and documented; it is never presumed simply because a State is better equipped. When the event occurs outside a State’s territory, the responsibility falls to the State of registration, without the rest of the structure changing.

This uniqueness governs everything else. The rights described later are not rights of co-direction: they grant access, they grant a voice, but they never grant the pen. An accredited representative who fails to convince on an analysis cannot modify the report; they can have their disagreement, motivated and supported, appended. It is less spectacular but more effective than it seems, because an appended divergence is public and lasting.

The sole purpose of the investigation is prevention, not the establishment of faults or responsibilities. This is not a preamble formula: it is what underpins the protection of sources, the separation from judicial proceedings, and the prohibition on participants circulating what they learn along the way.

The State where the accident happens leads the investigation. Other countries or companies can join but don’t control the process. Their role is to help, not to rewrite the final report. The goal is to prevent future accidents, not to blame anyone.

Typical sequence of an international investigationHorizontal timeline with six milestones: the occurrence, notification of the States concerned, appointment of the accredited representatives, the field phase and recorder readout, circulation of the draft report for comments, then publication of the final report. A band shows that the representatives’ access window opens at their appointment and closes at publication.access — and confidentiality — windowoccurrencenotificationappointmentterrain, lecturesdraft reportrapport finalstatus decides access, timing decides how long it lasts
Status opens a window, but not indefinitely. Before appointment, a manufacturer has no right of access, even if it is the first to know what to look for. After publication, the duty of silence ends with the report, not before.

The States that have a right, those that have a door

Notification is the first act, and it is addressed to: the State of registration, the State of the operator, the State of design, the State of construction, plus the international organization when the maximum takeoff weight exceeds the threshold set by the annex, a threshold low enough to include all public transport and part of business aviation. These four qualities each open a distinct right to appoint an accredited representative, and the State conducting the investigation must admit them: it has no say over the appropriateness of their presence, only over the modalities.

A group of formally dressed individuals in a meeting, discussing documents and laptops.
Accredited representatives collaborate in formal investigations.

A fifth circle exists, derived: the State that, at the request of the State of occurrence, provides information, facilities, or experts. Its presence depends on the expressed need and ends with it. This is how many third-party States with a recorder laboratory or rare expertise in metallurgy gain access.

A sixth is often misunderstood, and it is the most costly in misunderstandings: the State whose nationals have been killed or seriously injured does not have the right to an accredited representative, but to an expert. Their prerogatives are strictly enumerated: to go to the scene, to access the factual elements made public by the State conducting the investigation, to participate in the identification of victims, to attend the questioning of survivors from their country, to receive a copy of the final report. This is not a seat at the analysis table, and announcing it to the families as such prepares a crisis of confidence.

A borderline case deserves to be known before it arises: the aircraft registered in one State and operated durably by a company from another, under an agreement transferring functions between the two administrations. This agreement shifts surveillance functions—airworthiness, licenses, operating rules—but it does not shift the titles opened by the notification. The State of registration remains the State of registration, the State of the operator remains the State of the operator, and each retains its own right to appoint an accredited representative. The difficulty on the ground is therefore not knowing who has the right to be there, but avoiding two delegations asking the same questions to the investigator, each believing themselves uniquely competent on the subject. The same caution applies to short-term leasing with or without crew: it is the contractual operating arrangement, not the flag painted on the tail, that designates the State of the operator—and the answer must be known before the event, not sought out the same evening at the bottom of a lease contract.

Who can appoint whom, and on what basis
Status invoked Person appointed Fondement Usual scope
State of Registry, of the Operator, of Design, of Manufacture Accredited representative, assisted by advisers Own right, opened by the notification Full participation in the technical investigation
State providing information, facilities or experts Accredited representative Request from the State of Occurrence Participation linked to the purpose of the request
State whose citizens suffered fatalities or serious injuries Expert Enumerated right, distinct from the previous one Site, released facts, identification, survivors, final report
Regional organisation or EU technical agency Adviser to the investigator-in-charge Invitation or regional provision Certification and airworthiness support
Operator, manufacturer, engine manufacturer alone No standalone status None Presence only as a State’s adviser

In 2022, an Airbus A320 operated by a European airline crashed in Africa. The State of occurrence (Africa) led the investigation. The State of registration (Europe) and the State of the operator (same European country) each sent an accredited representative. The State of design (France) and the State of construction (Germany) also sent representatives. The State of victims (another European country) sent an expert, not a full representative, with limited access.

What surrounds the State of OccurrenceSchéma en étoile. Au centre, l’État d’occurrence conduit l’enquête. Quatre traits pleins le relient aux États d’immatriculation, de l’exploitant, de conception et de construction, qui nomment un représentant accrédité de plein droit. Deux traits tiretés le relient à l’État sollicité pour des moyens ou des experts et à l’État dont des ressortissants ont été tués ou blessés, dont la présence est conditionnelle et de portée limitée.State of Occurrenceconducts the investigationÉtat d’immatriculationState of the operatorState of DesignState of ManufactureState of victims: one expertState requested: resources, expertssolid line: representative by right — dash: on request
Two circles, two regimes. The four solid branches are binding on the State conducting the investigation; the two dashed branches depend on a request or an enumerated right. The geometry explains why an engine manufacturer without a sponsoring State does not get in.

Representative and advisors: a state function, multiple hands

The accredited representative is appointed by a State, and they represent that State: in practice, a senior official from the safety investigation authority, sometimes an agent from the civil aviation authority when the country does not have a permanent body. They may be assisted by advisors, whom they propose and whose reception the investigator in charge of the investigation organizes. These advisors come from the operator, the design organization, the manufacturer, the engine manufacturer, the airworthiness authority, sometimes from air traffic control or an aerodrome operator.

The practical consequence is rarely stated so bluntly: the advisor holds no independent right. They are there because a State supports them, and their employer, no matter how powerful, has no autonomous title to participate. The representative is accountable for the conduct of their advisors to the investigator in charge of the investigation; if they withdraw one, or if the investigator requests their withdrawal, the individual leaves the case immediately, and the State’s participation continues without them.

This structure is not a bureaucratic burden; it is a filter: a single voice speaks for each State, and industrial expertise—indispensable, no one claims otherwise—comes under public authority control rather than directly. The specialist who knows the production line, the series modification, the fleet return history, provides what the investigator cannot reconstruct alone; they provide it through a representative who is accountable for them.

In Europe, the agency responsible for air safety at the Union level is associated with investigations, generally as an advisor to the investigator in charge of the investigation, which places certification competence at the table without confusing it with the State of design’s own position. It is a nuance of title, but it changes who has control over conclusions related to design.

The direction of information flowThree aligned blocks: the advisers from the operator and the manufacturer, the accredited representative, the investigator appointed by the State of Occurrence. A solid arrow running above shows that any useful element flows up to the investigator without delay. A dashed arrow running below shows that the return path to the company exists only if the investigator expressly authorises it.conseillersexploitant, constructeuraccreditedrepresentative of its StateinvestigatorÉtat d’occurrenceany useful element, without waiting to be askednothing flows back without the investigator’s consentthe adviser holds no right of its own: everything comes through the representative
The channel is not symmetrical. Flowing up is an immediate, unfiltered obligation; flowing back down is an authorisation, revocable and limited. Confusing the two directions is the most common mistake made by first-time participants.

Real access, point by point

The catalog of rights for the accredited representative is concrete, and it is worth reading line by line before leaving: to go to the scene and examine the wreckage; to obtain information from witnesses and suggest areas of questioning, without conducting the interviews themselves; to have full access to all relevant evidence as soon as possible; to receive copies of all useful documents; to participate in the reading of recorded media; to participate in investigation activities conducted off-site—component examinations, tests, simulations, technical meetings; to participate in progress meetings, including deliberations on analysis, findings, causes, contributing factors, and safety recommendations; and to present observations on various elements of the investigation.

The key word is participate. Participating in a recorder reading is not receiving a file: it is being in the room during extraction and synchronization, seeing raw parameters before smoothing, and being able to say on the spot that such a sensor is known to drift on this standard. Participating in analysis deliberations is not reviewing the report: it is discussing the reasoning as it is being constructed, when it is still modifiable without cost.

Conversely, none of these rights entails ownership of the data. The accredited representative does not leave with a copy of the recordings to have them analyzed at home, except by explicit agreement; the working copy remains under the control of the State conducting the investigation. Industrial players who discover this limitation on the third day lose a week contesting it instead of organizing it.

Extent of access according to status held
Poste Accredited representative Conseiller Expert from a State of victims
Site and wreckage examination Full access Through the representative who sponsors them Site visit
Witnesses Information, suggested areas of questioning Same, under supervision Assistance with interviewing survivors from its country
Recorder readout Participation Participation if admitted Aucune
Analysis and causes meetings Participation in deliberations Participation if admitted Aucune
Draft final report Substantiated comments within the deadline Through its representative only Aucun
Rapport final Destinataire According to its State’s channel Destinataire
Extent of access by status and timingTwo stepped curves plotted on axes: time on the horizontal axis, extent of access on the vertical axis. The solid curve of the accredited representative rises as soon as they are appointed, stays high throughout the investigation and rises further at publication. The dashed curve of the expert from a State with victims rises later, levels off much lower, and only reaches the level of the public at the final report.extent of accessaccredited representativeexpert from a State of victimsappointmentrapport finaltemps
Two steps, not the same height. The solid line rises early and high; the dashed line rises late and levels off. The gap between the two, throughout the analysis phase, is exactly what makes the promise to inform families “in real time” untenable.

The duty to speak and the duty to remain silent

The counterpart to access is an active obligation: the accredited representative and their advisors must provide the investigator in charge of the investigation with all relevant information they possess. “That they possess” is broadly interpreted. A service bulletin in preparation, a comparable event that occurred on another continent three months earlier, a known drift of a sensor, an internal maintenance directive not yet disseminated: all of this is reported, spontaneously, without waiting for a question that has no reason to be asked since the investigator is unaware of the subject’s existence.

And the counterpart to this obligation is silence. The representative and their advisors do not disclose any information about the progress and findings of the investigation without the explicit consent of the State conducting it. This specifically targets the company that employs the advisor: the flight safety director does not need to know the content of the recorder reading because their engineer was present.

The trap: the advisor who reports to their crisis cell. The good-faith internal note of the evening, written to “prepare for the regulator’s questions,” is a disclosure. It circulates, is included in a presentation, and ends up cited externally—and the State conducting the investigation withdraws the advisor, sometimes the entire delegation. You then lose access at the precise moment it became crucial, and you do not regain it.

The right reflex: write the circuit before the event. A single person named as the investigation’s point of contact, a single channel to the accredited representative of their State, and a stated rule: what comes from the investigation only goes back down after written agreement, and in the form of a measure to be taken, never in the form of a finding. If an immediate safety action is required, it is requested from the investigator—who has every interest in authorizing it—rather than carried out clandestinely.

This regime is linked to the protection of sensitive recordings: transcriptions of cockpit conversations, statements collected, medical elements, air traffic control communications, opinions expressed in the analysis. They only leave the file if the competent authority deems that their disclosure outweighs the harm it will cause to future investigations. The participant who circulates them bypasses this weighing without having the power to do so.

The draft report: comment, not correct

Before publication, the State conducting the investigation sends the draft final report to the participating States, inviting them to present significant and supported observations within the deadline set by the annex for this phase, around two months. These two adjectives do all the work: a significant observation concerns a fact, a method, or an inference; a supported observation is based on a verifiable element. A request for reformulation aimed solely at softening an awkward phrase meets neither condition and will be dismissed.

Two outcomes, and only two: the State conducting the investigation amends the draft to take the observations into account, or it appends them to the report if the author requests it. There is no third path where one would negotiate a conclusion—the only serious chance to influence the reasoning occurs much earlier, in the analysis meetings, when the text is not yet written.

The advisor, for their part, has no direct access to the draft: they see it through the representative of the State that supports them, under the conditions that this State sets. Many companies discover too late that this right to review exists only by delegation, and that it therefore had to be organized with the national authority long before the accident.

Once the report is published, the safety recommendations bind their addressees: the authority concerned makes known the measures taken or considered, and if applicable, the reasons why none will be taken, within a deadline also set by the annex, around three months. This is where the investigation produces its real effect, and this is where the memory of the file is lost, because the teams that participated have already moved on to other things.

When safety meets the judge

The safety investigation is not the only one to open. In most States, a judicial authority is interested in the same event, with an opposite purpose: to establish responsibilities. The two procedures physically compete for the same objects—the wreckage, the recorders, the witnesses—and the question is never “who is right” but “who accesses first, and under what conditions.” The texts require that these arrangements be concluded in advance between the safety investigation authority and the judicial authority, not improvised on the ground. Where they are lacking, recorders are sealed for weeks, a site is frozen, and accredited representatives are present but useless: their right of access still exists, it simply has no object.

Two investigations, a single set of evidenceTwo parallel tracks pointing right: at the top the safety investigation, which seeks causes and recommendations; at the bottom the judicial investigation, which seeks liability. Between the two, three shared elements — the wreckage, the recorders, the witnesses — linked to each track by dashed lines, showing that priority of access must be settled by a prior arrangement.safety investigation — causes, recommendationswreckageenregistreurswitnessesjudicial investigation — liabilitycustody of evidence is settled before the occurrence, not beside the wreckage
The conflict is not legal, it is practical. One wreckage, one recorder, witnesses whose memory will only be fresh once. The prior arrangement does not arbitrate between principles: it sets an access schedule.

What must be written before the event

On the day, nothing is improvised, and the list of points to check in your own documentation is short. Who, by name, is the permanently reachable point of contact, and who replaces them? Which individuals, in writing, have delegation to act as advisors to their State’s accredited representative—and is this list known to the national authority, or only to the service? Which data are ready to be handed over within a few hours: flight file, maintenance and modification history, recent training and activity of crews, reports of comparable events on the fleet?

Then, the clauses. The contract of detached experts, including those of a subcontractor, includes the confidentiality obligation that stems from the advisor status, or only the usual commercial clause? Does the crisis procedure separate the communication cell—who must receive nothing from the investigation—from the technical participation? A manual that does not draw this boundary will cross it.

Gray areas remain. The place of the engine manufacturer or equipment supplier depends entirely on the State that agrees to support them, and two neighboring States do not have the same policy. Data produced by an onboard system outside of regulated recorders are of uncertain status: their handover is negotiated more than imposed. Insurers have no title, regardless of financial exposure. For those preparing to take on a role in flight safety or airworthiness, these three subjects are the ones to know how to handle, far more than the catalog of rights.

This article describes a mechanism; it does not replace any text. The international convention and its annex on investigations, the applicable regional regulation, the national law of the State concerned, and the approved documentation of the operator prevail over what precedes, and it is to them that one must refer before any decision.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.