Radiation fog: anticipate the dissipation time rather than endure it

Brouillard bas nappant une piste à l'aube, sommets des mâts de balisage émergeant de la couche

The TAF forecasts an improvement between 08 h and 10 h, the 06 h message gives 300 m and a RVR of 400 m on the runway in service, and a decision must be made now whether to carry enough to wait or to plan a diversion immediately. The radiation fog is, however, the easiest to reason through, provided you look at the night’s energy balance rather than the current observation line.

Morning fog is decided at the start of the night

The mechanism is a radiative imbalance, not a visibility phenomenon. Under clear skies, the surface radiates in the infrared toward a dry atmosphere that returns almost nothing to it: the balance becomes negative by the end of the afternoon, and the ground cools faster than the air above it. The air in contact loses its heat by conduction, weak turbulence distributes this cooling over a few dozen meters, and a surface inversion sets in. In this layer, the temperature drops toward the dew point while the water vapor content, for its part, hardly moves. When the two meet, condensation begins on the available nuclei.

Three conditions make the night productive, and they can all be read on the ground before sunset. A clear sky first: even a thin high cover returns some of the infrared radiation to the ground and is enough to break the cooling. A humid ground next, after a previous day’s rain or on a poorly drained plain: it supplies vapor as condensation removes it, and it keeps the dew point high. A weak pressure gradient finally, typically a soft anticyclone with its subsidence, which guarantees calm and caps the boundary layer with an additional inversion.

Convergence of temperature and dew point during the nightTwo curves plotted against time. Air temperature, solid line, falls quickly after sunset then flattens out. The dew point, dashed line, decreases very slowly. The two meet in the middle of the night: this is the time of saturation, and therefore of fog formation. After that, they descend together, the temperature staying close to the dew point.temperatureairdew pointsaturationformationcoucherleverheure locale
Fog forms when the temperature curve catches up with the dew point curve. The slope of the first depends on the radiation balance; the second barely moves, so it is the spread at sunset that gives the likely time of formation.

The gap between temperature and dew point at sunset is therefore the first piece of data to note, and the only one that is free. A small gap on a waterlogged terrain announces early formation, hence a full night to thicken the layer: this is the unfavorable case. A large gap protects nothing, it only delays the deadline, and a fog formed just before dawn remains thin. Between two nights where fog eventually forms, what distinguishes a clearing in the early morning from a clearing that only arrives in the early afternoon is not the presence of the phenomenon but the time it started.

Le brouillard de rayonnement se forme quand la température de l’air chute jusqu’au point de rosée. Plus l’écart entre les deux est petit au coucher du soleil, plus le brouillard apparaît tôt et est épais. Un brouillard qui se forme tard la nuit reste souvent mince.

À Paris-Orly, un écart de 3°C entre température et point de rosée à 18h00 en hiver annonce un brouillard dense avant minuit. Si l’écart est de 6°C, le brouillard ne se forme qu’à 5h00 et reste léger, avec une RVR de 1 000 m au lever du soleil.

The wind chooses the thickness, hence the clearing time

The surface wind is the second parameter, and its effect is not monotonic. In dead calm, only the thin layer of air right at ground level reaches saturation: you get dew, white frost, at best a creeping fog of a few meters that lets the tower see the aircraft and the crew see nothing from the cockpit. With a few knots, mechanical turbulence mixes the cooling over a deeper layer: saturation gains in height and the fog thickens. Beyond about ten knots, the mixing becomes too vigorous, the cold air dilutes in a layer too thick to saturate, and the fog does not form or lifts into low stratus.

Effect of surface wind on layer thicknessTwo curves plotted against surface wind. Solid line: fog thickness forms a bell, zero in calm wind, greatest at a few knots, gone beyond about ten knots. Dashed line: the tendency to lift into low stratus increases steadily with wind.thicknessbrouillard densestratus basdew only05101520surface wind (kt)
You need just enough wind to mix the cooling, not enough to dilute it. In a flat calm only the thin film at ground level saturates, giving dew or shallow fog; above about ten knots, the layer lifts into stratus instead of disappearing.

This non-linearity explains an observation everyone has made: the most threatening night is not the calmest one. A plain under an anticyclone, with a weak but steady wind of a few knots, produces the deepest and most difficult layer to break. It also explains why the forecast of nighttime wind matters more than the forecast of visibility: the first is a reasonably reliable model parameter, the second is a derived diagnosis that inherits all the uncertainties.

The trap. An announced improvement is not always an exploitable improvement. If the wind strengthens before the sun starts working, the layer does not disappear: it lifts. Horizontal visibility and RVR return to normal, the ceiling sets below the decision height, and the approach is lost for a parameter that had been stopped monitoring. A message that changes from fog to low broken stratus is not good news until the base has been measured.

Why a thick layer resists the sun

Dissipation requires energy, and this energy must first pass through the fog. However, a dense layer behaves like a reflector: it sends back a large part of the incident radiation and protects the ground that should destroy it. The flux that actually reaches the surface warms it, creates a sensible heat flux upward, and erodes the layer from its base. In parallel, the dry air above the inversion is drawn in by the top and nibbles at the layer from above. Both processes are slow as long as the opacity remains strong, and they accelerate abruptly when it weakens: this is why a terrain often goes from minimum RVR to clear sky in a quarter of an hour.

The two ways a fog layer dissipatesSide view. A fog layer rests on the ground, capped by an inversion drawn as a dashed line. Solar radiation arrives obliquely; only part of it passes through the layer and reaches the ground, which warms and sends mixing flows upwards that erode the fog from below. At top left, a downward arrow represents the entrainment of dry air eating into the layer from its top.entrained dry airinversionflux solairefog layerwarming ground
A thick layer reflects most of the radiation and shields the ground that should destroy it. Dissipation comes from below, through surface warming, and from above, through dry-air entrainment: both are slow as long as the layer remains opaque.

Two quantities determine the delay: the total liquid water to evaporate, which increases with thickness, and the available solar flux, which depends on the sun’s height. In mid-season, under a sun that rises quickly and strikes the layer less obliquely, an ordinary layer does not last long after sunrise. In December at our latitudes, the maximum elevation remains low, the path through the layer is lengthened, and the budget of the entire day may not be enough. This is the case of episodes that repeat several days in a row: each night rebuilds what the day did not manage to destroy.

Estimating a probable time rather than waiting for the next message

The reasoning chain consists of four steps and is done the evening before, not at the time of departure. The night’s productivity is assessed, the temperature and dew point gap at sunset is noted, an hour of formation is deduced, and then the remaining night duration and wind are combined to estimate the thickness reached at sunrise. The clearing delay is then read in the combination of this thickness and the sun’s height for the season.

Clearance delay by layer thickness and sun elevationTwo rising curves. Horizontal axis: layer thickness; vertical axis: delay between sunrise and clearance. The solid curve, for a high mid-season sun, rises gently. The dashed curve, for a low winter sun, rises much faster and crosses the solar noon line for the thickest layers.clearance delaymidi solairewinter, low sunmid-season, high sunmincethicklayer thickness
The delay does not grow in proportion to thickness: it runs away. Under a winter sun, a thick layer can cross the solar noon line, meaning it may not clear at all before the following night.
Combining estimated thickness and sun elevation to place the likely clearance time
Layer thickness High sun (mid-season, spring) Low sun (midwinter)
Late fog, formed towards the end of the night Clears shortly after daybreak Clears during the morning
Layer established by the middle of the night Clears mid-morning Clears around solar noon
Deep layer, steady wind, saturated ground Clears late morning Dissipation uncertain during the day
Layer capped by a strong subsidence inversion Partial improvement, persistent low ceiling Episode repeated from one night to the next

None of this is a forecast in the meteorological sense: it is an order of magnitude, and it is mainly valuable for its lifespan. A probable hour set the day before lasts all night and allows a fuel quantity to be decided. An observation message, on the other hand, says nothing about the following hour and pushes for a reflex decision.

Reading the TAF without making it say more than it does

The evolution groups carry different types of information, and the confusion is costly at the time of planning. A gradual change group describes a lasting evolution that will be achieved at the latest by the end of the announced window: the window is not an hour, it is a range, and reasonable planning retains the unfavorable edge. A temporary group describes, by construction, short-duration fluctuations: each lasts less than an hour and their sum does not cover half of the period: applied to fog, it describes a visibility that comes and goes, hence an approach that is playable but not guaranteed. A probability group only assigns a chance to a scenario; many operator doctrines nevertheless give it the same weight as the prevailing value when it degrades below the minima.

Three fogs that do not dissipate in the same way
Criterion Rayonnement Advection Lowering stratus
Origine Nocturnal surface cooling Mild, moist air over a cold surface Base of a cloud layer lowering
Vent favorable Light but not zero Moderate to strong Variable, often linked to advection
Cycle journalier Marked: night and early morning Weak: can persist all day Weak
Dissipation By the sun and dry-air entrainment By a change of air mass By drying or subsidence
What to watch T–Td spread, wind, high cloud Air mass trajectory, sea temperature Measured base rather than visibility

A useful reading also consists of not locking onto the destination airfield. Messages from neighboring airfields, a few dozen miles away, provide the spatial dimension that the TAF does not carry: a fog that covers an entire valley and a local bank do not call for the same clearing decision, even if the point observation is identical.

Translating the probable time into an operational decision

Radiation fog has a property that can be exploited: it almost always goes away, and it goes away quickly. This makes waiting rational when the probable time falls within a reachable window and fuel allows it. Still, the wait must be paid for in the right place. A wait in flight is paid in fuel and available crew; a wait on the ground, at the departure airfield or at a diversion, only costs time. On a destination airfield where the probable time is around mid-morning, delaying departure by half an hour is often better than carrying thirty additional minutes of waiting.

Chain of reasoning, from the night to the fuel decisionFour boxes linked by arrows. First box: clear night, light wind, wet ground. Second: spread between temperature and dew point at sunset. Third: time of formation and thickness reached. Fourth: sun elevation and thickness give a likely clearance time. An arrow leads down to a banner: holding fuel, alternate or slot delay.nuit clairevent faiblesol humideT–Td spreadat sunsettime offormationsun elevationand thicknesslikely timeholding fuel, alternateor slot delay
Four pieces of information available the evening before are enough to set a likely time. None of them is a forecast: they are observations you link together, and that is precisely what the TAF does not do for you.

The reasoning must also go upstream of the flight. A departure airfield in fog may allow takeoff with very low minima while being unusable for an immediate return: the question of clearing at takeoff then arises, and it arises on an airfield that, itself, is subject to the same clear night and the same anticyclone. A radiation fog episode is by nature regional; choosing a diversion a few dozen miles away in the same plain often amounts to having none.

The right reflex. Build your own climatology of the airfields you frequent in winter: the observed dissipation time, the temperature and dew point gap from the mid-night message, the wind strength. A few seasons are enough to build a local rule more useful than any general interpolation, because it integrates the terrain, soil moisture, and airfield exposure, which the model smooths out.

There remains the case of freezing fog, frequent as soon as the layer forms below zero. It adds a constraint that visibility alone does not show: ice buildup on exposed surfaces during ground waiting, contamination conditions to verify before power-up, and treatment slots that overlap with the exact time when the airfield becomes operational again. The probable clearing time must then include the treatment duration, otherwise you get an open airfield and an unavailable aircraft.

What remains to be checked in your own documentation

Three points deserve to be reread before the season rather than when the question arises. First, the actual capacity of the crew and aircraft on the target airfield: a higher category qualification is only valid if the runway, ground equipment, and low-visibility procedures of the airfield are actually in service at the time in question, and these procedures have their own triggering thresholds, often declared by the airfield operator before visibility drops. Then the planning rules retained by your operator to handle a degrading temporary group: they vary from manual to manual, and it is this choice, not the meteorology, that determines whether a second diversion becomes mandatory. Finally, the way RVR is produced on the airfield: number of measurement points, availability of the touchdown zone value, and reporting policy when a single sensor fails.

Two pilots in a cockpit observe a foggy runway at sunrise, with ground crew in high-visibility vests visible through the windshield.
Anticipate fog dissipation to optimize flight schedules.

The gray area that remains is that of reformation. An airfield cleared at noon may become unusable again as soon as solar radiation weakens, often faster than in the morning because the ground has remained wet and the air has not changed much. For an afternoon flight to an airfield that took all morning to clear, the critical time is not that of the observed dissipation but that of the next radiative imbalance. The practical rule is to repeat for the end of the day the reasoning held for the morning, starting from the gap between temperature and dew point recorded at the time of clearing: if it is already small at noon, the following night will start with a head start and reformation will be earlier than the previous day. The exchanges of the FL330 community gather local feedback on airfields that « bite, » and they usefully complement a personal climatology that is still short.

In case of divergence, the applicable text, the approved documentation of the operator, and the published procedures of the airfield prevail over this article, which is only explanatory in nature.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.