Trend Groups in Aerodrome Forecasts: Which Ones Count for Minima

Two pilots in a briefing room analyze a weather chart with trend groups, debating airfield minima under dusk lighting.

The TAF for your diversion destination, during your full arrival window, includes a PROB40 TEMPO with visibility below planning minima. In the briefing room, two interpretations clash: “forty percent, temporary, the airfield remains usable” versus “the application table disqualifies it.” Only one holds. The trend groups in an aerodrome forecast are not editorial nuances: they are operators, each with an application rule, and it is this grammar—not the general impression left by the message—that decides which airfields can legally support your flight plan.

Four groups, four statements about the weather

A trend group always answers three questions: when, for how long, and with what certainty. FM states a rapid, complete, and lasting change at a specific hour, which the forecaster commits to: after that hour, the previous state no longer exists. BECMG states that the final state will be reached at some unspecified time within the window and then maintained: the commitment is on the outcome, not the moment. TEMPO states the opposite of a settled condition: fluctuations, each lasting less than an hour, with the total duration less than half the period covered, and a return to the base state between episodes. Finally, PROB does not modify the phenomenon but the confidence: the forecaster assigns a 30 or 40 percent probability of occurrence—below that, nothing is coded; above that, the commitment is unconditional.

These four statements do not hold the same weight for planning. A certain and dated degradation is treated arithmetically. A certain but undated degradation, a brief degradation, or an uncertain degradation each require a distinct approach—and that is precisely what your manual’s application table encodes. Each cell is a decision rule, with an airfield either accepted or rejected as a result.

Each weather trend group (FM, BECMG, TEMPO, PROB) has specific rules for how it affects flight planning. FM means the change happens exactly at the given time. BECMG means the change happens at some point in the window. TEMPO means temporary changes that don’t last long. PROB means there’s a chance (30-40%) the weather will happen. These rules decide if an airport can be used for landing or diversion.

Four change groups and their time signatureFour stacked timelines. FM shows a sharp, lasting step; BECMG a gradual decrease within a window bounded by two dashed lines; TEMPO brief dips with a return to the prevailing conditions; PROB an excursion drawn in dashed line representing an uncertain occurrence.tempsFMsharp, timed, lastingBECMGreached within the windowTEMPObrief, return to prevailing conditionsPROB40occurrence incertaine
Each group makes a different statement about time. FM times a lasting change, BECMG promises an outcome without timing the moment, TEMPO guarantees a return to the prevailing conditions, PROB removes certainty about the occurrence itself. Solid lines represent a forecast change; dashed, an uncertain occurrence.

The foundational asymmetry: the worst first, the better later

The entire mechanism rests on a simple rule: a degradation announced in a change window is considered from the start of that window; an improvement is only counted once the change is complete. The forecaster says, “at some point between these two hours”; the planner responds, “then I assume the worst moment.” The uncertainty about the timing of the change is entirely borne by the plan, never by the crew on approach.

In practice, the assessment is made over a window bracketing the planned arrival time—typically one hour on either side. A BECMG degradation whose window overlaps this period, even at its edge, degrades the entire period. Conversely, fog given as dissipating by BECMG only clears the airfield at the end of the change window: as long as it persists, the plan must operate with the fog. And when multiple groups overlap in the arrival window, the most unfavorable combination is retained. This asymmetry may seem pessimistic; in reality, it is the price paid on the ground for an uncertainty that is refused in the air.

An A320 is planning to divert to Paris Orly (LFPO) with a TAF showing BECMG 1800/2000 FG VV0100. The planned arrival is 1930. The BECMG window (1800-2000) overlaps the arrival window (1900-2000), so the fog is applied from 1900. Even though the fog might clear by 2000, the plan must account for it being present during the entire arrival window.

Asymmetric application between deterioration and improvementTwo timelines. At the top, a deterioration forecast within a change window: the planning line, solid, drops from the start of the window while the forecast, dashed, drops only later. At the bottom, an improvement: the planning line rises only at the end of the window, while the forecast rises earlier.forecastinterpretation usedDeteriorationapplied from the startstartfinImprovementcredited at the end only
A deterioration is applied from the start of the window, an improvement only at the end. The dashed line shows what the forecaster announces, the solid line what planning applies: the gap between them is the uncertainty about when the change occurs, always borne by the plan.

TEMPO: the nature of the phenomenon decides, not the word

The treatment of a TEMPO is not read in the group itself but in what it carries. Convective phenomena—showers, thunderstorms, squalls—are transient by nature: the cell moves, dissipates, and the base state returns. A degradation of this type is compatible with the classic response: a short hold followed by a second approach. In contrast, fog, mist, continuous precipitation, snow clearing, or sand clearing are settled phenomena: when they occur, ten minutes of waiting does not change anything, and by the end of the night, the thermal trend works against you.

Hence the distinction made by the application tables: a TEMPO carrying a persistent phenomenon is treated as a condition established over the entire period—the word “temporary” does not subtract anything; a TEMPO of self-limiting phenomena may, depending on the operator’s table and the use in question, be disregarded. The operational question is always the same: if the episode occurs during my approach, is a reasonable wait sufficient to see it pass? For a shower, yes. For morning fog with calm winds, no.

The right reflex: read the phenomenon before the group. First, determine whether what is coded is self-limiting—shower, thunderstorm—or settled—fog, mist, continuous precipitation; only then consider what the group allows. A TEMPO of fog is treated as a durably degraded visibility, not as a passing squall.

Transient TEMPO versus persistent TEMPOTwo graphs of visibility against time. Left, showers: two brief dips go below the minima line, then visibility returns to the prevailing conditions. Right, fog: the curve drops below the minima line and stays there until the end of the period.aversesminimamay be disregardedbrouillardminimato be applied continuously
Two TEMPOs, two treatments. Left, showers: brief excursions below minima, with a return to the prevailing conditions — holding covers them. Right, fog: the curve settles below the threshold and does not come back within the window — the TEMPO is then read as a continuous condition.

PROB is not a footnote

The most common misreading is to treat the probability group as a writer’s caution—a neutral warning that is noted without consequence. This is a misunderstanding. PROB40 means that the forecaster, unable to commit, nevertheless assigns a 40 percent chance of the phenomenon occurring in the period. Accepting as a diversion an airfield with a 40 percent chance of being below minima at the moment it is needed is to nullify the purpose of the diversion: this airfield exists precisely for the scenario where everything else has already gone wrong.

Two men in uniform discuss a weather map labeled 'FOKJ3 TV PROB40 TEMPO' in a control room.
Weather forecasts must be interpreted carefully to determine operational minima.

That is why the treatment of probability groups is differentiated according to the role of the airfield. The exact structure varies from manual to manual, but the logic is constant: the further the airfield is at the end of the chain, the less uncertainty is tolerated. An uncertain occurrence may remain acceptable at the destination—a diversion waits behind—when it disqualifies the diversion itself, behind which there is nothing. As for the PROB TEMPO, it combines two operators: the uncertain occurrence of a brief fluctuation. It is therefore filtered twice, first by the nature of the phenomenon, then by the role of the airfield, and the most unfavorable reading of the two applies.

The trap: reading PROB40 as a simple warning and keeping the airfield as a diversion. On a persistent phenomenon, in the middle of the arrival window, this is the case that the application tables treat most severely on the diversion side: for an alternate, near-certainty is required. Treating the probability group as editorial style is to plan without a real diversion.

Decision tree for reading a deterioration coded in a forecastDecision diagram. FM and BECMG lead directly to applying the deterioration. TEMPO goes through the question of whether the phenomenon is persistent: if so, apply; if not, it may be disregarded. PROB refers to the operator’s table, which differs according to the role of the aerodrome being assessed.FM · BECMGTEMPOPROB30/40persistant ?on appliquemay be disregardedrole of the aerodromeouinonaccording to the manual
The decision tree for a coded deterioration. Certain changes are applied; a TEMPO is filtered by the persistence of the phenomenon; a probability group refers to the operator’s table, which distinguishes the role of the aerodrome assessed — destination or alternate.

Why the diversion is judged more severely than the destination

Planning minima are not landing minima. For the destination, the conditions forecast in the arrival window are checked to ensure the planned approach is possible; if not, the plan does not collapse—it strengthens, by demanding more from the subsequent stages, starting with the choice of diversions. For a diversion, however, the assessment is tightened twice. First, by downgrading: the most favorable approach to the airfield is not necessarily counted—diversions are not planned on the best possible performance, but on a plausible degraded capability. Second, by adding increments: typically a few hundred feet to cloud base minima and a kilometer to visibility, depending on the approach category.

The reason is operational, not bureaucratic: at the diversion, you arrive later than planned, with less fuel, on an older forecast, and with no other solution behind. The same trend group, in the same TAF, therefore weighs differently depending on the role of the airfield: a line acceptable for a destination may be disqualifying for a diversion. It is this cross-reference—group by group, role by role—that your application table materializes.

Alternate planning minima versus landing minimaBar chart. The destination bar stops at the landing minima of the planned approach. The alternate bar starts at the same level but receives a planning increment on top, shown as a separate filled area: the total requirement is higher for the alternate.exigenceminima d’atterrissageplanning incrementdestinationalternate
The alternate is planned above its own landing minima. For the same landing requirement, planning adds an increment for the alternate — and may refuse to count the aerodrome’s most favourable approach. The same forecast is therefore compared against two different thresholds depending on the role of the aerodrome.

The matrix to reconstruct before applying it

Put together, the mechanism fits into a two-entry matrix: the group encountered and the direction of the change.

Planning interpretation of change groups — standard structure of the application table; the exact wording is in the operations manual.
Groupe Deterioration Improvement
FM — timed change applied from the stated time credited from the stated time
BECMG — change window applied from the start of the window credited at the end of the window only
TEMPO — persistent phenomenon (fog, continuous precipitation) treated as an established condition disregarded
TEMPO — transient phenomenon (shower, thunderstorm) may be disregarded, according to the operator’s table and practice disregarded
PROB30 / PROB40 depends on the role of the aerodrome — destination or alternate disregarded

This table provides the structure, not the cells: what “must” be applied, what “may” be disregarded, and for which use are determined by your operator’s manual, which in turn derives from the means of compliance with the air operations regulations. The useful exercise is to reconstruct this matrix from memory, then compare it to the manual: the discrepancies you find are exactly the cases where your intuition would have planned incorrectly.

What your documentation must resolve—and what it leaves open

Four checks are worth making in cold conditions, outside of real flight preparation. Where is the application table in your manual, and does it explicitly cover the PROB TEMPO case? Is the treatment of transient phenomena distinct depending on whether the airfield is a destination or a diversion? What does the documentation provide when a forecast amendment is issued after the plan is established but before departure—mandatory replanning, or the captain’s discretion? And is the fuel articulation written? A diversion disqualified late changes the fuel load, not just a line in the flight plan.

Remain the gray areas that neither the regulation nor most manuals close: the forecast that does not cover the entire arrival window, the divergence between the TAF and the landing trend of the METAR when approaching the airfield, the overlapping probability segments. They are treated by the worst-case reading and documented in the flight log. For those preparing for a qualification or an off-line check, this cross-reference of the group and the role of the airfield is a classic oral subject: the FL330 preparation modules devote a special place to it.

This article describes a general mechanism for reading; it does not replace the regulation or your instructions. In case of discrepancy between the above and your references, the applicable regulatory text and the approved operator’s documentation prevail: it is your application table, and only it, that is authoritative in flight preparation.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.