Order book announced at the show: distinguishing firm commitment from memorandum of understanding

Maquette d'avion long-courrier sur socle sombre dans un hall d'exposition, lumière bleutée et visiteurs flous

Last day of a major airshow: the closing statement aggregates « orders and commitments » representing years of production. Three months later, the manufacturer’s published backlog retains only a fraction. Neither figure is false: they measure different things. Here’s how an airshow total is constructed — firm orders, conversions, options, memorandums of understanding — and what in this pile actually impacts delivery slots for a fleet.

What the announced total truly aggregates

An airshow figure is not a financial line item: it’s a communication aggregate, built for the day’s press. It adds up very different legal objects — new firm orders, conversions of options or previously announced memorandums, newly added options, purchase rights, and memorandums of understanding where part will never reach the contract stage. The statement presents them under a single term, « orders and commitments, » without systematic breakdown, and it’s precisely this ambiguity that creates the announcement effect.

Two mechanisms structurally inflate the total. The first is inter-airshow double counting: a memorandum announced one year reappears the next, converted into a firm order, and the press’s cumulative additions count it twice. The second is the absence of netting: announcements are always gross, never reduced by cancellations and deferrals that occurred in the meantime. A net orders table subtracts these exits — and it often tells a less flattering story than the press release.

The category of undisclosed customers adds to this: real, often strategic, but unverifiable at the time of the announcement. It prevents any cross-checking with known fleet plans, and it sometimes smooths the communication of a customer who hasn’t yet obtained internal approvals — board of directors, reference shareholder, supervisory authority.

An airshow order total is like a shopping list where some items are just ideas, others are promises, and a few are paid-for purchases. The real deliveries depend only on the paid-for ones.

At the 2023 Paris Air Show, Airbus announced 1,000 orders, but only 300 were firm contracts. The rest were memorandums or options. By December, 150 of those had vanished due to financing issues, leaving 850 in the backlog.

Breakdown of an order total announced at an air showOne bar represents the announced total, divided into four segments: new firm orders, conversions already announced, options and memoranda of understanding. A second, shorter bar represents only the actual entries into the firm backlog.Total announced at the showfermes nouvellesconversionsoptionsMoUActual entries into the firm backlogcontrat + acomptethe rest is waiting, or will never come
The “firm” scope is only a fraction of the show-stage total. Illustrative proportions: the split varies from one show to another, but the gap between the announced figure and the actual backlog entry is structural, not accidental.

From the press release to the purchase contract: the engagement scale

The memorandum of understanding — the MoU in press releases — is a framework document. It sets an intention, a volume, sometimes a family of aircraft, rarely an engine choice when it remains open. Its only truly binding clauses generally relate to confidentiality and good-faith negotiation conduct. A customer can withdraw without significant penalties, and this happens quietly: dead memorandums are never the subject of any announcement.

The letter of intent tightens the game: it immediately precedes the contract and is sometimes accompanied by a deposit, refundable or not depending on the negotiation. The purchase contract, on the other hand, changes in nature. It’s a thick document that freezes the detailed specification of the aircraft, the pre-delivery payment schedule, the price indexation clauses — the catalog price serves only as a calculation base, with actual discounts remaining confidential — the delivery windows with their tolerances, and the rights of each party in case of prolonged delay, in either direction.

The airshow staging deliberately blurs this scale. A signature under the spotlight can celebrate a contract negotiated for months — the announcement is then the end of the process, not its beginning — just as it can dress up a still-fragile memorandum that the staging gives apparent solidity. The signed document counts; the ceremony does not.

The commitment staircase, from announcement to firm slotStepped profile rising from left to right: announcement, memorandum of understanding, letter of intent, signed contract, deposit paid, slot reserved. The higher you go, the less reversible the commitment.AnnonceMoULoIContratAcompteSlotrevocable without penaltycostly exit
Each step reduces reversibility. A show total adds up lines located at every height of this staircase; only the last steps — signed contract, deposits paid — actually reserve an assembly slot.

Entry into the backlog: stricter criteria than the press release

The order backlog published by a manufacturer follows rules that the press release ignores. A line generally only enters when three conditions are met: a signed purchase contract, suspensive conditions lifted — board approval, financing closed, regulatory authorizations if applicable — and a deposit received. As long as one is missing, the matter remains a commercial commitment, not an order.

The backlog is also continuously reviewed. Manufacturers remove or reclassify lines when the customer’s ability to take delivery becomes doubtful — financial difficulties, restructuring, market withdrawal. Under the international accounting standard, the « firm » backlog only retains contracts deemed sufficiently certain; this probability filter explains part of the gap between the commercially claimed total and the backlog in the financial statements.

It’s also important to remember what the backlog is not: revenue. The international standard on revenue from contracts with customers only recognizes the bulk of an aircraft’s revenue at the transfer of control, i.e., at delivery. A record backlog and strained cash flow can therefore coexist without contradiction — pre-delivery deposits cushion the gap, they don’t eliminate it.

Memorandum of understanding and firm order: two legal instruments under the same show-stage label
Criterion Memorandum of understanding (MoU) Commande ferme
Valeur juridique Negotiating framework; limited binding clauses (confidentiality, good faith) Enforceable purchase agreement: specification, escalated price and schedule fixed
Acomptes None, or a token deposit, often refundable Schedule of pre-delivery payments until handover of the aircraft
Entry into the published backlog No — outside the firm backlog Yes, once conditions precedent are lifted and the deposit received
Reversibility Quiet withdrawal, without significant penalty Costly exit, governed by the termination clauses
Effect on the slot queue No slot reserved Position in the skyline, contractual delivery window
Use in communication Inflates the show total The only line that commits the assembly line

The real bottleneck: the delivery slot queue

What constrains a fleet isn’t the backlog total: it’s the position of each line in the delivery slot queue — the skyline, in program jargon. Each firm order is assigned a delivery window; the queue fills in the order of signatures and deposits, and a customer who signs late on a high-demand program discovers slots several years out, regardless of their commercial weight.

The slope of the delivery curve, on the other hand, isn’t negotiated at an airshow. It depends on the ramp-up of assembly and its limiting factors — engines, aerostructures, seats, and cabin fittings are regularly the posts that slow it down. When cumulative promises rise faster than the sustainable pace, the difference has a name: the slip, cascading throughout the queue.

Promised deliveries versus sustainable rateTwo curves start from the same point: the dashed curve of deliveries promised at the show rises much faster than the solid curve of the sustainable assembly rate. The gap between them, marked by a double arrow, represents slot slippage.livraisons / anhorizon (years)promised at the showcadence tenableglissements
When the promise rises faster than the rate, the difference is called slippage. The slope of promised deliveries is decided at the show; that of the rate depends on engines, aerostructures and cabin interiors — and it ripples through the whole queue.

Contracts anticipate this: windows with tolerances, delay penalties, right to terminate beyond prolonged delay — reciprocal mechanisms, because the customer who refuses to take delivery is symmetrically exposed. A discreet market organizes itself around the queue: slot exchanges between customers, transfers to lessors, takebacks by the manufacturer. An aircraft whose buyer disappeared late — the white tail — is repositioned, but rarely at the original conditions.

The practitioner’s reading grid

Five questions are enough to position a line on the engagement scale when faced with an announcement.

Two men in suits shake hands over a table with a model airplane, while another man observes, with a screen displaying an aircraft order announcement in the background.
Firm commitments seal major aircraft deals at industry events.
  • What is the exact nature of the commitment — firm order, option, purchase right, memorandum of understanding? The vocabulary of the press release is weighted, never innocent.
  • Is the customer named, and the engine choice made? A memorandum without engine choice is far from a slot: the negotiation with the engine manufacturer is a separate process.
  • Is a delivery schedule mentioned? An announcement without a horizon has not yet taken anything in the queue.
  • Are these new lines or conversions already announced elsewhere?
  • Is the figure gross, or net of cancellations from the same period?

The right reflex: never use an airshow figure without waiting for its accounting trace. The manufacturer’s monthly tables of orders and deliveries, then the backlog published with the financial statements, show what has actually been signed, received, and recorded. The gap between the announcement and the recording, a few months later, is the best measure of an airshow’s solidity.

The trap: building an operational reasoning on the press release total — sizing a recruitment plan, choosing a type rating, assessing the health of a program or a customer. The total aggregates revocable and irrevocable without distinguishing them, counts memorandums converted twice, and ignores cancellations. Any decision that commits for years is based on the firm backlog and the skyline, never on the press release.

Commitment strength and slot proximity matrixTwo-axis chart: legal strength of the commitment on the horizontal axis, proximity of the delivery slot on the vertical axis. A memorandum of understanding sits bottom left, an option in the centre, a firm order with a distant slot bottom right, a firm order with deposits and a near slot top right — only the latter actually constrains assembly.strength of commitmentslot proximityprotocoleoptionfirm, distant slotfirm, deposit paideffet d’annonceweighs on assembly
Two dimensions decide the real weight of a line: its legal strength and the proximity of its slot. A distant memorandum is a commercial signal; a firm order with deposits and a near slot is an industrial constraint.

What this changes for fleets and careers

For those planning a fleet or staffing, the consequence is direct: crew, maintenance, and training needs align with probable deliveries, not announcements. A fleet growth plan based on contractual windows and their tolerances — and the realistic assumption of a slip — ages better than a plan based on a press release.

For a pilot choosing between two type ratings, the reasoning is the same. The right indicator isn’t a program’s total backlog, but its effective delivery rate and the depth of its firm backlog in the near term: that’s where positions are created. A program with a spectacular backlog but sluggish deliveries opens fewer seats than a discreet program that delivers at a sustained pace.

The possible outcomes of a backlog lineFlow diagram: a memorandum of understanding either becomes a firm order or comes to nothing. The firm order ends in a delivery on slot, a slot postponement or a cancellation that leaves a white-tail aircraft.Protocole (MoU)Commande fermeSans suiteDelivered on slotSlot postponedCancelled
A backlog line has several possible outcomes, not just one. Serious tracking of a programme is read in conversions, postponements and cancellations as much as in the initial announcements.

On the safety and compliance side, a successful ramp-up has its downside: it compresses training deadlines, multiplies recent crews on type, and puts standardization under pressure. The safety manager who sees their operator’s firm backlog turn into close deliveries is wise to treat the fleet growth as an organizational change in its own right, with its impact analysis.

Before relying on an announcement: what remains to verify

Three concrete verifications are better than one conviction. In the manufacturer’s documentation: the exact definition that the published backlog retains — it appears in the financial reports and varies from issuer to issuer. In the monthly tables: the share of conversions and the net of cancellations over the period. In your own organization: which internal decisions — staffing, training, investments — cite an order figure, and which one.

A gray area remains, and it must be named: the commitments of lessors, announced en masse then placed later with operators, and the orders of launch customers with confidential concessions make the backlog reading more complex than the simple firm/memorandum dichotomy. These edge cases also fuel good discussions among practitioners, particularly on the FL330 forum.

The hierarchy of sources, however, is not up for debate: between a press release, an article — including this one — and a contract, only the signed purchase contract and the published financial documentation are authoritative, and applicable texts such as the operator’s approved documentation prevail over any pedagogical reading of the subject.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.