Loss-of-licence insurance for the self-employed: read the exclusions before signing

Bureau d’acier avec stéthoscope enroulé près d’un livret de contrat vierge dans une lumière froide

A renewal examination that drags on, a cardiology work-up that turns up an abnormality with no symptom whatsoever, and the Class 1 is not renewed. The salaried crew member falls back on the company scheme and on that of the profession. The one who invoices their days – instructor, captain on a contractor agreement, certifying staff, senior cabin crew member on assignment – has nothing but the policy signed three years earlier through a broker. Everything then turns on a single sentence, the one that defines the insured event, and on three or four exclusions that go unread at signature because they describe what only ever happens to other people.

What the policy calls “loss of licence”

The profession and the insurer use the phrase “loss of licence” very differently. For the insurer, it’s just a label for three possible covered events.

In the profession, losing your licence means no longer being able to fly. For the insurer, the phrase has no value of its own: all that counts is the definition of the covered event, and there are only three families of it.

The first covers unfitness to exercise the function of professional aircrew, evidenced by the refusal, the suspension or the non-renewal of the medical certificate. This is the wording that matches the real risk: the event is administrative, it is dated, it is in writing, and it asks no one to assess a capacity for work in general.

The second refers to a functional disability scale and makes payment conditional on a percentage. A controlled arrhythmia, a chronic vestibular disorder, a treatment that imposes close monitoring can close a flying career – or restrict it to the point where it can no longer be sold – while rating very low on a scale built for the general population. The gap between “unfit to fly” and “a few percentage points of disability” is exactly where claims are lost.

The third makes the benefit conditional on total and permanent incapacity to carry on any occupation whatsoever. It is consistent in a general protection policy and meaningless for aircrew: someone able to hold a ground post will never trigger it, even having lost the whole of their income.

The insurer doesn’t just pay when you lose your medical certificate. They only pay if your specific situation matches one of their three definitions. Many pilots think they’re covered when they’re not, because they don’t realize how narrow these definitions can be.

A 50-year-old captain with a stable heart condition might lose his Class 1 medical but still be able to work as a simulator instructor. His policy might not pay anything because he’s not completely unable to work (total incapacity) or because his condition only rates 10% on the disability scale, which is below the policy’s threshold.

Two nested definitions of the insured eventA large dashed frame represents unfitness for the flying function; a smaller solid frame, contained within it, represents total incapacity for any occupation. The common case, loss of the Class 1 with a ground post still possible, lies inside the large frame and outside the small one.Unfitness for the flying functionTotal incapacityfor any occupationLoss of Class 1,ground job possibleThe policy pays on its own scope, not on the examiner’s decision.
The small frame is the one most general policies cover. Loss of the Class 1 with a possible move to a ground role falls inside the large frame and outside the small one: the claim is refused without anything medical being disputed.

Two populations must go further still. Cabin crew do not hold a Class 1 certificate: the wording must target the fitness attestation and the function, failing which the insured event has no administrative support. Certifying staff, for their part, hold no aeronautical medical certificate whose loss would be recorded by an authority; their risk is being unable to work in the workshop or on the ramp – vision, spine, upper limb – fitness then being a matter for their organisation and for occupational health. A policy modelled on the Class 1 therefore covers them strictly nothing, and the brochure will not say so.

That leaves the intermediate case, the one that generates the most argument: the limitation. An OML entered on the certificate does not withdraw the licence, it prohibits single-pilot operation. For a business aviation pilot or an instructor working with reduced crew, it amounts to the end of the activity; yet it ticks no box in the policy if the limitation is not named there as a covered event.

The same event, read through three wordings of the insured event
Situation Unfitness for the flying function Functional disability scale Incapacity for any occupation
Class 1 not renewed, fit for a ground post Covered Depending on the percentage, often below the entry threshold No payment
Temporary unfitness, return after treatment Temporary benefit, then stopped on return Nothing until the condition has stabilised No payment
Limitation imposed, end of single-pilot activity Only if the limitation is named Nil or marginal percentage No payment
Licence withdrawn after a failed check Not covered, non-medical cause Not covered Not covered

Waiting period, deferred period, stabilisation: three clocks, and a fourth aimed at you

A loss-of-licence policy is not read as a single cover but as a succession of periods that do not measure the same thing and do not penalise the same person. The waiting period runs from the inception date: it protects the insurer against anyone taking out cover while already aware of their condition. The deferred period runs from the finding of unfitness: it sets the length of time during which unfitness is recognised but not paid. Stabilisation, finally, is not a contractual period but a medical fact: it is the moment when the condition stops changing and its permanent character can be established. Until it is reached, the claim stays on the temporary regime – whose maximum duration does appear in the policy.

Timeline of a loss-of-licence claimHorizontal timeline: waiting period after inception, then the finding of unfitness, deferred period with no payment at all, temporary benefit, stabilisation, and finally a permanent benefit or lump sum.InceptionFinding of unfitnessStabilisationWaiting periodDeferred periodTemporary benefitPermanent benefitno paymenttime
Three periods run in sequence before the first euro is paid. The waiting period runs from inception, the deferred period from the finding, and only stabilisation opens the permanent benefit: a claim can be recognised very early and paid very late.

The fourth clock is the only one that can be held against you personally: the notification period. It runs from the moment you become aware of the insured event, that is, in practice, from the written decision of the examiner or of the aeromedical centre. Many wait for the outcome of an appeal or of a waiver application before informing the insurer, out of reserve or out of hope. This is the most frequent mistake, and the easiest to avoid.

The four periods of a claim, and what each one penalises
Period Starting point What it measures Effect if it is not met
Waiting period Inception of the policy Initial period during which no insured event is covered An event occurring within it stays permanently outside cover
Deferred period Finding of unfitness Length of unfitness recognised but not indemnified Nothing is due for that period, even if recognised afterwards
Notification The insured’s awareness of the event Contractual time limit for informing the insurer Possible forfeiture of cover, if the insurer establishes its loss
Stabilisation Stabilisation of the state of health Moment when the permanent character can be established The claim stays temporary, up to the maximum duration

The right reflex. Notify on the day the written decision is handed to you, before even lodging an appeal or a waiver application. A notification commits you to nothing, it opens a file and stops the clock; the continuation of the fitness procedure is mentioned in the same letter. Keep the original decision: it is the only document that dates the insured event.

The catalogue of exclusions, and those that do not go by that name

The general exclusions are well known and rarely decisive: intentional acts, war, nuclear risk, the consequences of a criminally punishable act. Those that really hollow out the cover lie elsewhere, and fall into three categories.

The pathology exclusions come first. Psychiatric conditions and mood disorders are very often excluded, sub-limited in duration, or made subject to hospitalisation conditions. Yet the unfitness that follows from them is long and rarely disputed on medical grounds: this is the ground where the gap between the cover advertised and the cover actually granted is widest. Spinal conditions with no objective substrate on imaging receive the same treatment. Addictive behaviours are excluded as such, even where the unfitness pronounced is itself perfectly medical.

The activity exclusions come next: air sports, diving, motor sports, mountaineering. They target pursuits whose risk the insurer judges higher than that of everyday life, and which are readily found in this profession. A cover that excludes non-professional flying deserves particular scrutiny when you instruct at a flying club at the weekend.

The third kind are not called exclusions: they are the non-medical causes of loss of the licence. A failed proficiency check, a rating not revalidated, a withdrawal pronounced at the end of an administrative or disciplinary procedure, the end of a contractor agreement that cuts off access to the simulator: none of this is an insured event, in any policy. The cover bears on health, never on employability.

The trap. The pre-existing conditions clause does not target declared illnesses, but conditions “whose cause or origin predates” the inception. An abnormal test filed away with no follow-up two years earlier, a discomfort mentioned to a general practitioner, a brief course of treatment never declared because it had nothing to do with fitness: each can be enough to attach the insured event to a pre-existing condition. The policy is not voided for all that – it is the benefit that is refused, which leaves a policy paid for over years against a risk that was no longer covered.

The earnings basis: what you take in, what the policy retains

This is where being self-employed changes everything. The policy does not indemnify a standard of living but a declared professional income, generally that of the last completed financial year, sometimes the average of several. A company director who takes dividends for social-contribution reasons mechanically shrinks the earnings basis: the distributed share is not remuneration for work, and it drops out of the calculation. Expense reimbursements and rebilled travel meet the same fate.

Income received and earnings basis retained by the policyTwo vertical bars compared: on the left the income actually received, stacking remuneration, dividends and reimbursed expenses; on the right the earnings basis retained by the policy, limited to the declared remuneration alone. A horizontal dashed line marks the cover ceiling, set below the top of the left-hand bar.annual incomereimbursed expensesdividendsremunerationcover ceilingreceivedbasis retained
The benefit is calculated on what was declared as earned income, not on what the company distributed. Taking dividends lowers the earnings basis without anything flagging it, and the cover ceiling caps what remains.

Two configurations deserve checking before signature. That of the crew member who has just set up their company and has no completed financial year: the earnings basis is then self-declared, and will have to be substantiated at the time of claim. And that of umbrella company employment, which restores collective cover but only on the salary paid through the umbrella, often lower than turnover. In both cases the question to put to the distributor is a single one: on what documents will the earnings basis be established on the day of the claim – tax filing, tax assessment notice, payslips – and for which financial year?

The trap. Over-declaring your income at inception does not produce better cover: it produces a higher premium for a benefit that will be recalculated on the tax documents at the time of the claim. Conversely, omitting a medical history item on the health questionnaire is paid for dearly: intentional misrepresentation renders the policy void, with premiums retained by the insurer, while an unintentional inaccuracy discovered after the fact reduces the benefit in proportion to the premiums not collected.

Fixed benefit or indemnity: the clause that decides the amount

Two policies advertising the same annuity will not pay the same sum, and the distinction never appears in the brochure. A fixed-benefit cover pays the agreed amount as soon as the event is established, without regard to what the insured receives elsewhere: it stacks with the cash benefits of the self-employed scheme, with a group protection plan kept from a previous job, with the scheme specific to salaried professional aircrew for anyone still covered by it. An indemnity cover makes good only a proven loss: the other benefits are deducted, the total is capped at the actual loss, and the insurer can proceed against a liable third party.

Fixed-benefit policy and indemnity policyTwo stacked columns compared against a horizontal dashed line representing the income loss to be covered. The fixed-benefit column adds the annuity to the other schemes and rises above the line; the indemnity column pays only a top-up and stops exactly at the line.stacking possibleannuityother schemescappedtop-upother schemesincome lossfixed benefitindemnity
The same advertised cover does not pay the same thing. Under indemnity cover, everything the other schemes pay is deducted and the total stops at the actual loss; under fixed-benefit cover, the annuity is added, but the insurer requires the level taken out to be substantiated at signature.

The form of the benefit counts as much as its nature. A lump sum pays once, on stabilisation, and closes the file. An annuity pays until an age set in the policy, and its real value depends entirely on one discreet clause: indexation. An unindexed annuity paid over fifteen or twenty years loses an appreciable part of its purchasing power, without any clause having been breached. Waiver-of-premium options during unfitness, for their part, are worth their price: without them, you have to keep paying a policy while it is paying you.

What expires with age, and what expires with one line of the questionnaire

The cover has an end, and it comes sooner than one imagines. The sum insured decreases in steps from an age set in the policy, then cover ceases at a limiting age that is not always the age at which a career could still end. Meanwhile the premium, reviewable by age, rises. The ratio between what you pay and what you protect therefore deteriorates at exactly the moment when the probability of unfitness increases.

Decreasing cover and rising premium with ageThe sum covered, as a solid line, stays flat then steps down and falls to zero at the cover expiry age marked by a vertical dashed line; the premium, as a rising dashed line, crosses the cover before that age.amountcoverpremiumcover expiry ageage
The cover does not age the way the career does. The lump sum or the annuity decreases in steps before expiring at the age provided for, while the premium rises: check the cover expiry age before comparing two entry rates.

Another asymmetry deserves attention: can the policy be cancelled or amended without you? An individual policy stipulated as non-cancellable by the insurer, on guaranteed terms, can no longer be called into question once health has deteriorated. Membership taken out through an association, on the other hand, can be amended by an endorsement agreed between the insurer and that association: the cover you bought is not necessarily the one you will have in ten years. The question is asked at signature, never afterwards.

The right reflex. Ask for a copy of the completed and signed health questionnaire, and keep it with the policy schedule. It is the only document that will make it possible, years later, to show that the question put to you did not bear on the history now being held against you. Also ask for the written record of the advice given by the distributor, stating your self-employed status and the absence of collective cover: it engages their liability if the definition chosen does not match the need expressed.

The sentences to find in your own policy

A loss-of-licence policy can be re-read in half an hour if you know what you are looking for. Only six passages deserve to be highlighted:

A man in uniform signs a document under a desk lamp.
Always review exclusions before committing to any insurance policy.
  1. the definition of the covered event – look for the word “function” or “aircrew profession”, and beware of the word “any”;
  2. the clause that designates who establishes unfitness, and the medical arbitration procedure if the opinion of the insurer’s medical officer diverges from the aeromedical decision;
  3. the waiting, deferred and notification periods and the maximum duration of the temporary regime;
  4. the definition of the income basis and the documents required to establish it;
  5. the statement of the fixed-benefit or indemnity character, and the list of benefits deducted;
  6. the cover expiry age, the reduction schedule, the indexation of the annuity and the insurer’s right to amend or cancel.

One grey area remains, and it is better known before signing than discovered afterwards. A self-employed professional who keeps a residual activity compatible with their condition – simulator instruction, expert work, mentoring – sees that activity reduce their loss within the meaning of an indemnity policy, and therefore their benefit. Retraining is good for the career and bad for the claim. Only fixed-benefit cover, substantiated at inception, neutralises this conflict. That is a serious reason to prefer the narrowest wording, the one that targets the flying function, to the widest cover on paper; the experience of those who have had a claim paid is worth, on this point, every comparison site, and is shared on the FL330 professional forum.

For anyone self-funding a type rating or about to move to contractor status, the order of operations is the real subject: cover is taken out while the medical file is still clean, before the examination that will produce the first adverse entry. A recorded history item cannot be erased, and a named exclusion set at the time of joining is never renegotiated.

The general and particular terms of your policy, the applicable legislation and your operator’s approved documentation prevail in all cases over this article, which describes mechanisms and not your situation.

Questions fréquentes

Can a standard protection policy replace loss-of-licence cover?

Rarely, and never by chance. A general protection policy triggers on an incapacity for work assessed across all occupations, or on a functional disability percentage. A crew member declared unfit to fly but fit for a ground job crosses neither of those thresholds. Only a definition expressly targeting the flying function, or the loss of the medical certificate, covers the real risk.

Does a limitation entered on the medical certificate open the cover?

Only if the policy names it as a covered event. An operational multi-pilot limitation leaves the licence valid: administratively there is neither refusal nor suspension, hence no insured event within the meaning of most wordings. For a pilot whose activity is single-pilot, however, the loss of income is total. This clause is negotiated at inception, not at the time of the finding.

Should the claim be notified before the fitness appeals have been exhausted?

Yes. The notification period runs from awareness of the insured event, that is, from the written decision, and not from the outcome of an appeal or of a waiver application. Notifying interrupts no fitness procedure and commits you to nothing: it opens the file and preserves your rights. State in the same letter that the fitness procedure is continuing.

How is the benefit calculated when you take your remuneration mainly in dividends?

On the declared earned remuneration, not on distributions. The share paid in dividends is not professional income within the meaning of the policy and falls outside the earnings basis, as do expense reimbursements. A company director who optimises social contributions therefore reduces future benefit in the same proportion. The question to ask before signing bears on the documents used and on the reference financial year.

What difference does the fixed-benefit or indemnity wording make in the policy?

It decides the amount actually paid. Under fixed-benefit cover, the agreed annuity is due as it stands and stacks with the other benefits received. Under indemnity cover, the insurer makes good only a proven loss: benefits from other schemes are deducted, the total is capped at the actual loss, and a residual activity reduces the benefit further. For an identical advertised amount, the gap in payment can be considerable.

Can certifying staff take out loss-of-licence cover?

Yes, but not a policy modelled on the Class 1 medical certificate, which they do not hold. The wording must target the medical impossibility of performing the certification function or the workshop and ramp tasks, without requiring a decision from an aeromedical authority. Failing that, no administrative event will ever materialise the insured event and the cover will remain theoretical.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.