A refuelling “with sustainable fuel” changes nothing the crew can see: the bowser still delivers Jet A-1, the delivery ticket carries the same values, the density falls within the same window. What changes happens far upstream, and that is where the question becomes technical. A handful of production pathways are approved; only one delivers volumes that matter today, and it is not the one with the best potential. The reason comes down to three variables: the chemical form of the feedstock, the number of unit operations separating that feedstock from kerosene, and the size of the resource base.
Three meanings of the word “available”
When a supplier announces a sustainable fuel, three different claims can hide behind the same word. The pathway may be approved, meaning listed in an annex of the specification for aviation turbine fuels containing synthesized hydrocarbons, with its blending limit and its battery of receipt tests. It may be produced, which assumes an industrial unit is running somewhere and turning out barrels. It may finally be deliverable to the aircraft, which requires a blending point, batch recertification and a connection to the airport depot. The three conditions are almost never met in the same place at once, and the gap between them explains why a pathway long cited in the trade press may never have filled a single tank.
The recertification mechanism deserves a closer look, because it governs everything else. The synthetic component is never delivered pure: it is blended into fossil-derived jet fuel, and the blend is then tested again and re-designated as conventional jet fuel. From that moment on, there is administratively no more “sustainable fuel” in the system. There is Jet A-1, which meets the same specification, flows through the same pipelines and blends in the same tanks as everything else. That is precisely the definition of a drop-in fuel, and it is also what makes it impossible to say, for a given wing tank, what fraction of its content came from a biorefinery.
Hence mass-balance accounting and transferable (book-and-claim) certificates. The operator that buys a quantity of the sustainable component does not physically receive those molecules: it receives the environmental attribute attached to a batch produced and injected somewhere in the system, with no corresponding physical movement to its own station. For the crew, the practical consequence is nil. For the technical manager and the fuel department, it is not: batch traceability, the certificate of analysis and the declared blending ratio are the only documents that separate a real purchase from a claim.
The fuel you get is still regular Jet A-1, but some of it comes from sustainable sources. You can’t tell which part is sustainable just by looking, and the system tracks it through certificates, not physical tracking. The real difference happens in the supply chain, not in the plane.
An airline buys 10,000 litres of sustainable fuel attribute. The fuel delivered to its planes is regular Jet A-1, but somewhere in the system, 10,000 litres of sustainable fuel were produced and blended into the general fuel supply. The airline gets the environmental credit, but the actual fuel molecules may come from anywhere.
Several approved pathways, only one that delivers
Each pathway enters the specification through its own annex: there it receives a process definition, a list of admissible feedstocks, composition requirements stricter than those of the finished jet fuel, and a blending limit. That limit is not a commercial precaution; it is the direct consequence of what the process can or cannot do, particularly regarding aromatics and the distribution of chain lengths.
| Pathway | Feedstock | Maximum blending | Dominant constraint |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hydroprocessed esters and fatty acids (HEFA) | Used cooking oils, animal fats, vegetable oils | 50% | Lipid feedstock base, already contested |
| Fischer-Tropsch synthetic paraffinic kerosene (FT-SPK) | Gasified solid biomass, waste, gas | 50% | Capital, biomass logistics, syngas cleanup |
| Fischer-Tropsch with aromatics (FT-SPK/A) | Same as above, with alkylation of an aromatic cut | 50% | Very few units, an even more complex process |
| Alcohol-to-jet (ATJ) | Ethanol, isobutanol from agricultural or waste feedstocks | 50% | Capital, and the competing value of the alcohol as road fuel |
| Catalytic hydrothermolysis (CHJ) | Oils and fats, including highly degraded ones | 50% | Still thin industrial-scale demonstration |
| Synthesized iso-paraffins from fermented sugars (SIP) | Sugars | 10% | Low blending limit, fermentation cost |
| Hydroprocessed hydrocarbons from algae (HC-HEFA) | Micro-algae oil | 10% | Feedstock base virtually nonexistent at industrial scale |
Read side by side, these lines say something public debate rarely says: approval is not the limiting factor. Several pathways have been open for years, and volumes come almost entirely from the first line of the table. The constraint has shifted in nature. It was regulatory, then it became industrial, then agricultural — and each shift has made the problem harder to solve by the aviation sector’s will alone.
The matrix above explains why no simple strategy works. A pathway is only useful if it is simultaneously mature and supplied, and none is. The most deployed process works a scarce feedstock; processes backed by an abundant feedstock have not yet reached the first commercial unit stage, or reached it with difficulties that discouraged a second.
Chemistry does half the work, in only one pathway
A used cooking oil or an animal fat is a triglyceride: three fatty-acid chains, typically sixteen to eighteen carbon atoms long, attached to a glycerol backbone. A kerosene molecule is precisely a carbon chain of that length. The feedstock therefore arrives already built; all that remains is to strip its oxygen atoms by hydroprocessing, then to isomerize and branch the resulting chains to lower the freezing point, and to cut them to the right length. Two operations, both perfectly familiar to a refinery, on equipment whose sizing, metallurgy and catalysts are routine to the trade.
This kinship with conventional refining has a decisive financial consequence: the hydroprocessed-lipids pathway did not need to invent an industry. It moved in with a host, into converted or supplemented renewable diesel units, which cuts the investment and, above all, shortens its timeline. The other pathways have no host: land must be acquired, a site built, teams trained on a process with no nearby commercial version running, and the whole thing amortized on a product whose price is not guaranteed. So the comparison is not between two factories; it is between a workshop conversion and an infrastructure project.
One industrial detail weighs more heavily here than any announcement: a lipid-hydroprocessing unit produces mostly renewable diesel, not kerosene. To increase the kerosene cut, more hydrocracking is required, which consumes more hydrogen, degrades overall mass yield, and also produces lighter cuts with no aviation value. In other words, the same plant can steer its output toward aviation, but it does so against its own yield — and only if the price paid for the aviation cut compensates for that loss.
The ceiling is in the resource base, not in the plant
Used cooking oils, rendering fats and lipid residues are not grown: they are collected. Their volume is a function of food consumption and slaughter, not of fuel demand. Building more plants does not create a single extra litre of used oil; it only drives up the cost of collection and pulls in flows already used elsewhere — road biodiesel, oleochemistry, animal feed. A litre diverted to aviation is a litre missing from another use, and the net climate benefit must then be calculated against what that other use will consume instead.
Switching to purpose-grown vegetable oils lifts the collection constraint but reopens the land constraint: the area mobilized competes with food production, and land-use change, direct or indirect, can cancel out a substantial part of the gain. Sustainability schemes therefore restrict eligible feedstocks, and this restriction is as binding as the technical specification — a chemically flawless batch can be ineligible because its feedstock is not.
The trap. A batch that meets the specification and a batch eligible under a sustainability scheme are not the same thing. The first is proven by laboratory tests on the product; the second is proven by a documentary traceability chain running back to the feedstock. A fuel can be perfectly compliant and count for nothing toward the blending mandate, or toward an operator’s carbon balance, if the sustainability declaration does not follow. The two files are assessed by different actors and never overlap completely.
The relay pathways, and each one’s own constraint
Alcohol-to-jet
Feedstock is not the issue: ethanol is produced in bulk and transports easily. The process chains a dehydration into ethylene, an oligomerization that assembles these building blocks into chains of the desired length, then a hydrogenation. Each step is well known, but chaining them together in a single unit is costly, and the starting molecule carries an oxygen atom that must be discarded — meaning part of the mass paid for will never end up in the tank. Add to that a market constraint: alcohol already has a regulated road-fuel outlet, which sets a floor under its price.
Gasification followed by Fischer-Tropsch synthesis
Chemistry is not the problem: paraffin synthesis from syngas has run at industrial scale for decades, first from coal, then from natural gas. What blocks it is further upstream. Gasifying heterogeneous solid biomass produces a gas laden with tars and impurities that poison catalysts; cleanup is the trickiest technical step in the chain. And the logistics of a solid, low-energy-density fuel force either a narrow supply radius or a prohibitive transport cost. Viable unit sizes are therefore capped from above, denying the pathway the scale effect that would make it competitive.
Power-to-liquid fuel
This is the only pathway whose feedstock is not bounded by biology: carbon dioxide and hydrogen produced by electrolysis, assembled through the same Fischer-Tropsch synthesis. The price to pay is energetic. Every conversion loses something, and the chain of electrolysis, synthesis and refining requires feeding in a multiple of the chemical energy ultimately carried on board — on the order of two to three times, depending on the architecture chosen. Producing a significant tonnage therefore requires dedicated decarbonized electrical capacity with a high load factor, and a source of carbon dioxide whose own origin will itself be audited. This is not a chemistry problem: it is an electrical-system problem.
What the blend actually changes on board the aircraft
A synthetic paraffinic component is kerosene that is “cleaner” than kerosene: regular chains, very few aromatics, no sulfur, no polar compounds. That purity is an advantage in combustion and a drawback everywhere else, because several useful properties of conventional jet fuel come precisely from its impurities.
| Property | Conventional jet fuel | Pure paraffinic component | Effect on the recertified blend |
|---|---|---|---|
| Density at 15 °C | 775 to 840 kg/m³ required | On the order of 730 to 770 kg/m³ | Pulls the blend toward the low end of the window, without leaving it |
| Specific energy | Reference | Slightly higher | A bit more energy per kilogram, a bit less per litre |
| Aromatics | Naturally present | Virtually nil | A floor is imposed on the final blend, hence the blending limit |
| Sulfur | Below the cap, but present | Traces | Fewer non-volatile particles, less soot |
| Freezing point | Ceiling set by the specification | Generally lower | Increased margin, without changing the operational limit |
| Lubricity and conductivity | Provided by residual polar compounds | Low | Additivation needed, at the blender’s expense |
The critical point is aromatics. The elastomer seals of the fuel system, on airframes some of which are several decades old, swell on contact with aromatics; it is this swelling that ensures sealing. A fuel entirely lacking aromatics would let those seals shrink back, with seepage at the fittings. The blending limit guarantees a floor of aromatics in the final product: it protects the seals, not the engine. This is also what makes the move to a fully synthetic fuel far more than a matter of volume — aromatics must either be reintroduced through a synthesis route, or the entire fleet must be shown to tolerate their absence.
On the density side, the effect is real but modest: the paraffinic component pulls the blend toward the low end of the permitted window. For anyone calculating a mass from an uplifted volume, this is the usual reminder — the density of the delivered batch is what counts, not a remembered average value. On the combustion side, the drop in aromatics and the absence of sulfur reduce the non-volatile particles emitted, and thus the number of ice crystals formed in a contrail: the benefit there is immediate and independent of the carbon’s origin, which makes it the industry’s strongest argument, independent of the life-cycle balance.
The right reflex. Treat the batch’s certificate of analysis as a performance datum, not a paperwork item. Measured density, freezing point, declared blending ratio: these three values are enough to know whether the takeoff mass calculation is built on the right assumption, and whether the batch stayed within its limits at delivery. When an operator starts receiving blended batches, that is the moment to check what default density value the flight-planning system actually uses.
Approving a pathway: the invisible bottleneck
A new pathway does not become an annex just because it produces a liquid that burns. It goes through a tiered evaluation process: characterization of specification properties, then of fit-for-purpose properties that are not in the specification but govern real-world behaviour — material compatibility, thermal stability, low-temperature behaviour, behaviour in the presence of water. Then come component and engine-test-bed trials, then the research report submitted for review by engine manufacturers and airframers, who hold genuine oversight.
Two factors make this path longer than one might imagine. First, time: several years separate the first sample from the listing. Second, volume: the upper tiers require quantities of representative fuel that only a pilot unit can supply, creating a loop well known to project developers — a plant is needed to be approved, and approval is needed to finance the plant. It is this loop, far more than any scientific difficulty, that explains the length of the list of “promising” pathways stuck at the demonstrator stage. First-hand accounts of this can be found on the FL330 technical forums, where operations and maintenance staff exchange notes on the first blended batches received at a station.
What to check in your own documentation
The subject seems distant until the day it filters down into procedures. Three points deserve checking before being forced to. First, the flight manual and the engine documentation: they designate the approved fuels, and the wording used determines whether a blended batch is covered automatically or calls for a documentation update. Second, the operator’s refuelling procedures: quality control on receipt, the density values used, the course of action in case of a deviation on the certificate of analysis. Third, fuel policy and uplift calculation: nothing changes there in substance, but any fixed density assumption is worth revisiting.

A grey area remains, and it is a deliberate one. A station’s supplier cannot always say which production pathway supplied the component of the batch delivered, because blending happens upstream and the system runs on mass balance. In practice, the operator buys an attribute and receives compliant jet fuel: these are two distinct transactions, and trying to make them coincide physically is a reasoning error. For anyone preparing a qualification or a technical interview, this is precisely the distinction that separates a communications answer from an engineer’s answer — and it comes up regularly in the FL330 training modules devoted to operations and performance.
The type of operation changes the nature of the problem, not just its scale. An operator concentrated on a few main hubs can negotiate a physical supply, have a blending point connected to its depot and check the certificates of analysis of blended batches itself. A dispersed operator — business aviation, aerial work, a regional network with multiple stations — has no such leverage: its stations are served by depots that receive no component at all, and the only door open remains buying an attribute detached from the point of consumption. The consequence is as much budgetary as technical. The amount paid then covers no local delivery, and the real operational benefit — fewer non-volatile particles at the exhaust — applies only to flights actually refuelled with the blend, not to those whose attribute was purchased. Conflating the two amounts to crediting a fleet with an effect it did not produce.
Finally, a methodological remark. When reading a capacity announcement, one should immediately look for two figures that almost never appear: the fraction of output directed to the aviation cut, and the origin of the feedstock. Without them, a capacity announced in tonnes says nothing about what will actually reach an airfield — and it is precisely there that the difference between pathways is made.
The applicable texts, the fuel specifications in force, and the approved documentation of the operator and the manufacturer prevail over this article, which describes mechanisms and replaces no procedure.
Questions fréquentes
Does a sustainable fuel require a special refuelling procedure?
No. The synthetic component is blended in upstream, and the mixture is then tested and re-designated as conventional jet fuel. It then meets the same specification, is handled the same way, and blends without restriction with the fuel already in the tank. The only things that change are documentary: the batch’s certificate of analysis and its sustainability declaration.
Why is the blending limit capped when the fuel is compliant?
Because the synthetic component contains virtually no aromatics, and it is aromatics that swell the elastomer seals of the fuel system, this swelling being what ensures sealing. The limit guarantees a floor of aromatics in the final product. It protects the airframe and its fittings, not the engine, which would accept a much purer component.
Why does the hydroprocessed-oils pathway dominate to this extent?
Because it is the only one whose feedstock is already a carbon chain of the right length: it only needs to have its oxygen removed and its chains branched. Two operations, achievable in existing or converted refining units. All the other pathways must first build the molecule step by step, with the corresponding capital.
What limits the volumes delivered: plant capacity or feedstock?
Feedstock. Used oils and fats are collected, not grown: their volume depends on food consumption and slaughter, not on fuel demand. Building more plants does not create additional supply; it only drives up collection costs and diverts flows already used elsewhere.
Can power-to-liquid fuel lift this ceiling?
In theory yes, since it starts from carbon dioxide and hydrogen, a non-biological resource base. In practice, the chain of electrolysis, synthesis and refining requires supplying electricity equal to a multiple of the chemical energy finally carried on board, on the order of two to three times. The limiting factor becomes decarbonized electrical capacity, not chemistry.
Is the benefit of a blended fuel limited to the carbon balance?
No, and that is its strongest argument. The drop in aromatics and the near-total absence of sulfur reduce the non-volatile particles emitted, and thus the number of ice crystals formed in a contrail. This effect is immediate, measurable in flight, and independent of both the origin of the carbon and any life-cycle calculation.

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.