Recency and Currency Compared: Counting Acts or Revalidating a Privilege

Simulateur de vol complet sur vérins dans une halle d'entraînement

Four months off, resumption scheduled for Monday. In one case, the crew flies three circuits and the count checks out: nothing was taken away, nothing was given back, a counter simply climbed back above its threshold. In the other, the rating carried a date, that date has passed, and no number of circuits on earth will bring it back: it will take a training organisation, a refresher programme and an examiner’s signature. Both regimes claim to answer the same question — can this person still do it? — and they are not measuring the same thing.

Two Different Quantities, One Shared Word

Three mechanisms coexist under the generic label of currency, sharing neither the same unit, nor the same arbiter, nor the same consequence. The first counts recent acts within a rolling window: take-offs, landings and approaches are tallied, and the total is checked against a duration that recedes by one day every day. The second samples a performance in front of a qualified third party and attaches the result to a date carried on a document. The third belongs to the operator, whose programme layers its own checkpoints on top of the first two.

These mechanisms are not alternatives: every mature system uses all three. What distinguishes one regulatory regime from another is the relative weight given to each and where the breaking point is placed. The European model places it on the dated rating: the licence is a living document, on which each class, type or instrument rating carries its own expiry date. The North American model places it on the count: the pilot certificate itself never expires; it is the privileges it grants that switch on and off according to recent acts, medical fitness and a periodic review.

The consequence is immediate for anyone switching regimes, supervising a mixed crew or reviewing a recruitment file: the question « are you current? » does not call for the same kind of answer. On one side, a date; on the other, a logbook and a tally.

Some systems track how often you fly recently, while others check your skills at fixed dates. One lets you stay current just by flying, the other requires formal training and tests.

A European pilot with a type rating valid until 31 December must complete a proficiency check before that date to keep flying the aircraft. A North American pilot needs three take-offs and landings in the last 90 days, but no formal check unless they stop flying for too long.

Rolling recency window versus a dated expiryTwo timelines. At the top, a counter of acts: dots mark landings, a band covers the last 90 days. Only two dots fall within it instead of the three required: the band has slid forward and left the older acts outside it, without any date having been exceeded. At the bottom, a dated privilege: a vertical line marks the expiry, a band covers the last three months, and a check taken within that band opens a new period starting from the expiry date.Counter of acts90-day windowtoday90 days agoonly two actstimeDated privilegeexpirynew periodchecklast three months of validitytime
One of the two counters empties itself, the other does not. At the top, no date has been exceeded: the window has moved forward and left the older acts behind it, with no warning and no administrative act. At the bottom, the expiry is fixed, and a check taken within the last-three-months band does not push it back: the following period starts from the expiry date, not from the check.

The Act Counter: What It Measures, What It Misses

The most widely shared rule is also the simplest: three take-offs and three landings within the preceding ninety days to carry passengers, on an aircraft of the same type or class. It exists on both sides of the Atlantic with very similar thresholds — the European count also includes the associated approaches — and it is one of the rare provisions for which crews from different continents cite the same figure. The North American regime then breaks it down more finely: night landings are counted separately and must be to a full stop, and instrument recency is expressed as a number of approaches, holding procedures and intercepting-and-tracking exercises within a rolling six-calendar-month window.

Recent exposure is what an act counter measures: the freshness of a gesture, not its quality. Nobody has judged the three landings; it is enough that they took place. In exchange, the mechanism is continuous: no administrative step, no examiner availability required, and it restores itself through normal activity. A line crew stays current without even thinking about it.

Its flaw is symmetrical and vicious: the window slides without warning. No date is exceeded, no document changes appearance; the trailing edge of the window moves forward and leaves an act behind it. A pilot can therefore lose a privilege on a Sunday morning with no alert going off, simply because a flight ninety-one days old has stopped counting. It is the exact opposite of an expiry date, which can be seen coming from far away.

The trap: believing that an act counter can be read at a glance. On a rolling window, it is not the last flight that decides, it is the third one counting back from today: as long as it remains within the window, the count holds; the moment it falls outside, the privilege lapses even though one flew just the day before. A crew flying long sectors, with only one landing per rotation, can thus fly a great deal and no longer be current: it is the acts that count, not the hours.

The Dated Expiry: A Privilege That Lapses

The second mechanism works differently. A rating is a privilege bounded in time: a type rating for a multi-pilot aircraft and an instrument rating are typically valid for one year, a single-engine piston class rating for longer. Within the period, the holder exercises the privilege without having to prove anything; on the date itself, the privilege lapses, regardless of what the actual activity has been.

Restoring it requires a third party, and two paths are carefully kept distinct. Revalidation is the act taken within the period of validity: a proficiency check signed off by an examiner, which carries the privilege forward without interruption. Renewal is the act taken after expiry: the privilege no longer exists, and getting it back requires a refresher whose content is determined by a training organisation, followed by a check. The difference is not one of degree, it is one of nature: in one case you extend, in the other you rebuild.

What this mechanism measures is a performance judged, on a sample of exercises, at a given moment. It says what counting does not — someone has looked and validated — and it misses what counting captures: the continuity of practice. A holder can be perfectly current in the sense of their licence and not have touched the aircraft for eleven months.

Some ratings expire on a fixed date, no matter how much you fly. You must pass a check before the date to keep it, or take extra training if you miss it.

A pilot with a type rating valid until 30 June must complete a proficiency check before that date. If they fail to do so, they must complete a refresher course and a new check to regain the rating.

The Tipping Point: What Exceeding It Actually Costs

It is at the point of breach that the two philosophies diverge most. The counting-based regime withdraws privileges in stages: the right to carry passengers first, the right to fly on instruments next and separately, and the very ability to exercise the certificate much later, for lack of a periodic review. The document itself never disappears: it goes dormant. The expiry-based regime withdraws nothing until the date, then withdraws everything at once, and allows no way back without outside intervention.

A pilot in uniform writes in a notebook inside an aircraft cockpit at dusk.
Documenting actions ensures compliance with current regulations.
Gradual Loss versus Sudden Loss of Privileges During a Period of InactivityGraph of the extent of privileges as a function of time spent not flying. The counting-based regime, shown as a solid line, descends in successive steps: a first step around ninety days, a second around six months, a third much later, and the curve then levels off at a non-zero level, since the document itself never expires. The expiry-based regime, shown as a dashed line, stays flat at its highest level until the expiry date, then drops vertically almost to the bottom of the frame: the privilege switches off all at once and does not restore itself.extent of privilegesdated privilegeact counterthe document persistsprivilege extinguished90 dayssix monthstwelve monthstwenty-four monthstime spent not flying
A staircase on one side, a cliff on the other. The counting-based regime withdraws privileges in stages: carrying passengers first, instrument flying next, the very exercise of command much later; each step is climbed back by performing acts, often without a third party. The expiry-based regime withdraws nothing until the date, then withdraws everything at once, and climbing back necessarily goes through a training organisation and an examiner. The durations shown on the horizontal axis are indicative and depend on the privilege in question.
Two Ways of Measuring Currency, Row by Row
Question Counting-based regime Expiry-based regime
What is measured The freshness of a practice: number of recent acts A performance judged on a sample of exercises
Time unit Rolling window, anchored to the current day Fixed period, anchored to a date carried on the document
Who attests The holder, through their flight record; checked after the fact A qualified examiner, through a binding signature
End signal None: the window advances silently Explicit: the date is legible months in advance
Effect of exceeding it Partial and gradual loss; the document persists Complete extinction of the privilege concerned
Path back Redo the acts, alone or under supervision Revalidation before the date, refresher then check afterwards
What it costs An aircraft slot, a few circuits Simulator, examiner, administrative lead time
Blind spot The quality of the act is never judged Eleven months of inactivity change nothing about validity

One counter, however, runs through both regimes without belonging to either: medical fitness. It is dated everywhere, its duration depends on the certificate class, the holder’s age and the operation envisaged, and its expiry suspends the exercise of the privilege just as surely as a lapsed rating — with no amount of training able to substitute for it. It is this that ruins the convenient idea of a counting-based regime with no dates at all: it carries at least one. And it is this date that catches people out most often, not because the deadline is forgotten but because of the real lag between the visit, a specialist’s opinion and the issuing of the document: the appointment should be booked according to that lag, not according to the date printed on the certificate.

The Date Convention: Where Weeks Are Lost Without Anyone Noticing

Two details of how time is counted cause more confusion than the principles set out above. The first is rounding to the month: many provisions are counted in calendar months, with the period running not from the day of the event but from the end of the month in which it occurred, which grants a carry-over of anywhere from a few days to a few weeks. Other provisions, including the ninety-day recency windows, are counted in whole days from the exact date. The two conventions coexist within the very same file for the very same crew member.

The second is the anticipation window. In the European model, a revalidation check taken within the last three months of validity does not open the new period on the day of the check: it starts from the expiry date, and taking it early costs nothing. Outside that window, the same successful check restarts the counter from the day it was taken: one pays in validity time for having been too early. The same reasoning applies to the operator’s own checks, each with its own window.

The right habit: keep two separate columns, one of dates, one of counters, and never read one while believing you are reading the other. The date column is planned: every appointment within its anticipation window, never before. The counter column is monitored: do not look at the date of the last landing, but at the date of the third one counting back from today — the only one that announces the day the privilege will lapse.

In Commercial Air Transport, the Two Systems Converge

As soon as an operator steps in between the holder and the exercise of the privilege, the divergence narrows sharply. The European model requires, for a multi-pilot commercial-transport crew, two operator proficiency checks per twelve-month period — a spacing of roughly six months — and one line check per year: the former assesses normal, abnormal and emergency procedures, the latter the actual performance of the crew’s duties. On their own cycles, emergency equipment training and crew resource management are added on top.

The North American model of commercial air transport typically arranges, for the pilot-in-command, an annual proficiency check paired with an intermediate mid-cycle event, which may take the form of approved training rather than a check; the ninety-day recency rule remains unchanged alongside it. Operators running an advanced qualification programme go further still, abandoning fixed intervals altogether in favour of a continuous cycle, whose evaluation periods are approved together with the programme.

Twelve Months of Operations: Two Ways of Scheduling Crew ChecksTwo twelve-month timelines, with markers at the start, at six months and at twelve months. European timeline: a circle marks an operator proficiency check at all three markers, a square marks a line check at twelve months. North American timeline: a circle at the start and at twelve months, a square at six months for an intermediate event that may be an approved training session.Twelve months, two structurescommon six-month spacingEuropeoperator checkoperator checkline checkNorthAmericaone periodic check per yearintermediate eventstart of cyclesix monthstwelve months
The two systems keep the same beat as soon as an operator steps in. The circle marks a check, the square an event of a different nature: a line check on one side, approved training on the other. The periodicity is similar; what is sampled mid-cycle differs.

The major philosophical difference is therefore mostly visible at the licence level. At the operator level, everyone converges on the same setting: one in-depth session per year, an intermediate one at six months, a line observation, and act counting running in the background. A well-supervised airline pilot therefore almost never feels the difference; they feel it the day they step outside that supervision — a long leave, a change of employer, a spell without a contract.

What the Simulator Replaces, and Under What Conditions

Both regimes accept that a training device can carry part of the load, but not at the same point. For sampling performance, the full-flight simulator is the norm: on a multi-pilot aircraft, nobody reproduces an engine failure at take-off in real flight. For counting acts, the admission is more tightly framed: the required take-offs and landings may, depending on the regime and under conditions, be performed on a device qualified for that purpose, and it is the device’s qualification level that decides, not how realistic it feels.

Two points deserve to be checked rather than assumed. First, a credit opened by the regulation is not automatically opened by the operator: the operations manual can be more restrictive, and it is the manual that applies. Second, an act performed on a device does not tick every box at once: it may satisfy the recency attached to the rating without lifting a condition imposed by the operator for crew pairing or access to certain aerodromes.

What to Go and Check in Your Own Documentation

Four checks are worth more than a full reading of the regulation. The first concerns the date convention: for each line of the tracking table, knowing whether it is counted in whole days or in calendar months, and from which event. The second concerns the anticipation window for each check, the one that decides whether an early appointment costs validity time. The third concerns the credit given to the training device, as opened — or not — by the operations manual. The fourth concerns pairing restrictions: after a return from inactivity, many operators impose limitations absent from the regulation, yet these still decide the flight programme.

One grey area remains, and it is better to know about it than to discover it the hard way: switching from one regime to another does not transfer the counters. Experience gained is recognised as flight time; recency attaches to the privilege exercised, and a privilege issued by one state is not the same as one issued by another. An impeccable record on one side therefore opens, on the other, a conversion process sometimes accompanied by a full check. For anyone preparing a rating outside their home regime, the useful exercise is short: write down, privilege by privilege, the date or the counter that carries it, the document that proves it, and the authority that signed it. Cases of returning after a long absence and of conversion are discussed on the FL330 forums; modules to prepare for periodic checks are on the training side.

This article describes mechanisms of comparative regulation and does not replace any official source. The text applicable in the state that issued the licence, the operator’s approved documentation, and the decisions of the competent authority prevail under all circumstances over what is written here.

Questions fréquentes

If three landings have not been made in the last ninety days, is the rating lost?

No: recency and the validity of the rating are two separate counters. The rating keeps its expiry date and remains valid; what lapses is the right to carry passengers until the three acts have been redone within the window. They are redone in flight, or on a training device where the regime and the operations manual allow it, and the privilege returns without any administrative step.

What exactly is the difference between revalidating and renewing a rating?

Revalidation is taken within the period of validity: a successful proficiency check carries the privilege forward without interruption, and if it is taken within the anticipation window, the new period starts from the expiry date rather than from the day of the check. Renewal takes place after expiry: the privilege no longer exists, a training organisation determines the refresher needed for the individual case, and a check follows afterwards. The cost, the timeframe and the parties involved are not comparable.

Why does a North American pilot certificate carry no expiry date?

Because this regime does not place expiry on the document itself. The certificate and the ratings it carries are issued without a term; it is the privileges that open and close according to medical fitness, recent acts and a periodic review. The document therefore never needs redoing, but it does not by itself prove that its holder can fly today: the logbook must be read alongside the document.

Does taking a check early cost validity time?

It all depends on the anticipation window specific to the check in question. Taken within that window, it costs nothing: the new period starts from the old expiry date. Taken before the window opens, the same successful check restarts validity from the day it was taken, and the time between that date and the original expiry date is lost. This is why crew scheduling departments sometimes refuse to bring forward a slot that seemed convenient.

Do the operator's checks replace those required for the licence?

They work alongside them rather than replacing them: the same exercise can, under conditions and with the required qualifications, count both for the operator’s proficiency check and for the revalidation of a rating. This combination is common in commercial air transport, and it is what gives the misleading impression of a single counter. It requires the operator’s programme and the examiner’s qualifications to cover it explicitly; outside that framework, the two deadlines remain independent.

Do recency counters follow a holder who switches regulatory regimes?

No, and this is the costliest mistake in a conversion file. Flight time is recognised as experience, but recency attaches to the privilege actually exercised under the authority that issued it. A record that is perfectly current on one side therefore opens, on the other, a conversion process that can include training and a full check. This must be factored into the timeline of an application, not at the moment of taking up the position.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.