Contract pilot after an occurrence: where the operator’s cover stops

Table d’analyse avec fragments métalliques disposés sur un tapis quadrillé sous une lumière froide

A serious incident, a flight cut short, a crew taken off the roster that same evening. Three days later, the operator issues a statement referring to “our crews”, and the first officer discovers two things: his contract ties him to a crew leasing company registered somewhere else, and the insurance certificate he was shown when he was hired extends cover to employees. Between the certificate, the contract and the individual, liability and cover do not travel the same road.

The air operator certificate is issued in a single name and cannot be lent out. It designates one operator, which retains operational control of every flight: its manual sets the procedure, its rostering department assigns the crew, its management system answers to the authority for each person’s fitness to hold their position. None of this changes when the commander is not an employee. The regulatory regime ignores employment status: it recognises an operator and crew members assigned by that operator.

What does change is the route taken by money and by recourse actions. Three legal entities coexist: the operator, the structure that supplies you — an agency, an umbrella company, or your own company — and you, the natural person. The contractual chain runs in series: the operator contracts with the contractor, the contractor with you. The operational chain, for its part, short-circuits the middle link. Insurance policies are attached to one chain or the other, never to both by default.

Contractual chain and operational controlThree boxes aligned from left to right: operator holding the certificate, contracting company, natural person. Two solid arrows represent the successive contracts. A dashed line leaves the operator, passes beneath the contractor and rises back to the natural person: operational control skips the intermediate link.contractual chainOperatorAOC holderContractorcrew leasingIndividualyou, personallycontractcontractactual operational control
Regulatory liability follows the dashed line, insurance follows the boxes. The operator assigns you, commands you and answers for you before the authority without any direct contractual link tying you to it: that gap is what manufactures the holes in cover.

When you’re a contractor, the operator controls your work but doesn’t employ you. Insurance follows contracts, not operational control. If you’re not an “employee” in the policy, you might not be covered when things go wrong.

An A320 first officer working for a crew leasing company has an incident during a scheduled flight. The operator’s insurance covers the aircraft damage but not the pilot’s legal fees, because the policy only covers “employees” – and the first officer is technically a contractor.

As long as the flight goes well, the gap between these two chains stays invisible. It becomes perfectly legible the day someone has to pay: repairing an aircraft, compensating a third party, lawyers’ fees, lost income, requalification to be done again.

What the operator’s policy insures, and in whose name

An operator’s insurance programme comes in three blocks: the aircraft hull, with its deductible; liability towards third parties; liability towards passengers, baggage and cargo. The European regulation on insurance requirements for air carriers and aircraft operators imposes minimum amounts calculated on take-off mass and the number of seats. Those minima exist so that victims find a solvent debtor; they say nothing about protecting the crew member.

In these policies the policyholder is the operator, the insured is the operator, and the indemnity goes to the operator or to the victim. Crew members appear only through an extension clause, most often drafted in English, whose scope hangs on a few words: employees, or employees and any person acting on behalf of the insured. One word apart, two different regimes. In the first case a contractor is a third party to the policy; in the second, they are an additional insured and enjoy cover as if they were an employee.

Share of the risk carried by the operator’s programmeFive risks as rows. A solid bar shows the share taken by the operator’s policies, an outlined bar the share left with the individual. Third-party damage is covered in full, criminal defence in part, loss of income not at all.operator’s policiesborne by youthird-party damagedamage to the aircraftcriminal defenceloss of licenceloss of income
The more personal the risk becomes, the more the solid bar retreats. An operator’s policies are built to compensate victims and repair an aircraft, not to keep an individual afloat. The top of the chart barely concerns you, the bottom concerns you alone.

Asking for the exact wording is therefore not a lawyer’s affectation: it is the only way to know which side of the line you stand on. A generic certificate practically never says, because it lists amounts and dates, not capacities as insured.

Subrogated recourse, the mechanism that truly separates employee from contractor

An insurer that pays out steps into its insured’s rights and pursues that insured’s recourse against the person whose fault caused the damage. That is where status becomes a question of personal assets — not on the payslip.

Two pilots in uniform review documents near an airplane on a tarmac.
Operators' insurance may not cover post-occurrence pilot responsibilities.

Under French law, the employee enjoys a protection established long ago by case law: acting within the limits of the assignment entrusted by the employer, they do not in principle incur personal liability towards third parties, and the insurer that has paid turns against the employer, not against them. The exception lies in intentional misconduct and in a clear overstepping of the limits of the assignment — two narrow situations, but precisely the ones an investigation may set out to establish.

The contractor is not a servant of the operator: they are a counterparty, bound by an obligation whose extent is fixed by their contract, and that immunity does not apply to them. Nothing then prevents the operator’s hull or liability insurer, once it has paid, from pursuing its recourse against the contracting company, which will immediately look at what its own contract allows it to pass on to the natural person. Hence the importance of a waiver of subrogation in favour of the contractor and of the people it supplies — obtained not from the operator, which does not control it, but from its insurer.

The trap. A mutual hold-harmless clause signed with the operator does not bind its insurer. The operator may promise not to sue you: its insurer, subrogated to its rights, is not party to that promise and retains its own. Only a waiver of subrogation taken out at policy level, and visible on the certificate, really closes the door.

What status changes, item by item, after an occurrence
Item Employed crew member Contract crew member
Capacity under the operator’s policies Additional insured through the clause covering staff Depends on the wording: third party to the policy if it covers employees only
Insurer’s recourse after payment Servant’s immunity, save intentional misconduct or acting outside the assignment Recourse open against the contracting company, then possible contractual pass-through
Criminal defence of the individual Often covered by the employer or by a collective legal expenses scheme To be taken out personally, otherwise fees fall on the individual
Income while off the roster Salary maintained, possible ground assignment No assignment invoiced, unless a grounding compensation clause applies
Loss of licence and unfitness Usual collective scheme, company benefits plan Individual contract, with its own waiting periods and exclusions
Access to the file and follow-up of the occurrence Internal stakeholder in the safety management system Outside the system: information filtered by the client
End of cover Continues as long as the operator is insured for the period concerned May lapse with the contract if the policy is on a claims-made basis

This division shifts with the type of operation. In a wet lease where the provider supplies the aircraft, the crew, the maintenance and the insurance, operational control stays with the party operating the flight, but the policies follow the provider: a crew member at the end of the chain may find themselves covered by a contract taken out in a country whose language they do not read, under a law they did not choose and before a court they did not anticipate. In business aviation and aerial work the structure is smaller, the hull deductible weighs proportionally heavier on the balance sheet, and the incentive to pursue recourse after material damage is correspondingly stronger. The same question — who is insured, and against whom can the insurer turn — therefore does not receive the same answer depending on whether you fly for a large scheduled operator or for an operator running a handful of aircraft.

Three procedures, three clocks

A significant occurrence opens three of them, and the common mistake is to treat them as one. The safety investigation, conducted under the European regulation on investigations and the Annex to the Chicago Convention devoted to accident and incident investigation, has a single purpose: prevention. It seeks neither fault nor liability, and its material is protected against improper use. Judicial proceedings may open in parallel, with their own rules of evidence and their own timescales. Finally, the authority and the operator may act on fitness to exercise the privileges: suspension of the assignment, an out-of-cycle check, an additional medical examination.

Three procedures opened by a single occurrenceA horizontal time axis starts at the occurrence. Three bars of very different lengths represent the safety investigation, the judicial proceedings and the action on the licence: as orders of magnitude, action on the licence plays out in days, the safety investigation in months, the judicial proceedings in years.occurrencesafety investigationlegal proceedingsaction on the licenceweeksyearstime
The three clocks do not beat at the same rate. The shortest, the one governing fitness, decides your income long before the longest says who was wrong.

These three clocks run at incomparable speeds. The fitness clock is the fastest and the most decisive economically: a decision taken within a few days can be enough to interrupt the activity. The safety investigation is counted in months, the judicial route often in years. An employee crosses that interval under contract, with pay and a legal department; a contractor crosses it without an assignment, paying for their own advisers, often without receiving the documents that concern them.

The gap opens after the assignment, not during it

Nasty surprises almost never occur on the day of the occurrence, but months later, when a claim or a summons lands on a contract that has already ended. Two mechanisms concentrate this risk.

The first lies in the trigger basis of your professional liability policy. On an “occurrence” basis, it is the date of the event that governs: it does not matter that the claim arrives after termination. On a “claims-made” basis, it is the date of the claim that governs, and cover lapses with the contract unless there is retroactive cover and an extended reporting period. Crew leasing contracts are often counted in months; aviation claims know nothing of that timescale.

Occurrence or claims-made: cover after the assignmentTime on the horizontal axis, level of cover on the vertical axis. A solid line stays high without interruption: the occurrence-basis policy still covers after the end of the assignment. A dashed line drops at the end of the assignment and stays low when the claim arrives.coveroccurrence basisclaims-made basiscover endedclaimend of assignmenttime
The loss almost always arrives after the assignment, the cover almost always before. A claims-made policy answers only claims made while it is alive: without retroactive cover or an extended reporting period, the drop is abrupt on the day the contract ends.

The second lies in the continuity of fitness. A prolonged suspension eventually erodes the recent experience required to take the controls again, then catches up with check due dates. An operator puts its employee back on line because it has an interest in doing so and bears the cost within its own simulator slots. A contractor, by contrast, must fund their own recurrent training or convince another client to do it, with a file that bears the trace of an occurrence still under examination.

The right reflex. Demand the insurance certificate with three written mentions before the first rotation, never after the occurrence: the status of additional insured, the waiver of subrogation in favour of the contractor and the people it supplies, and the length of the extended reporting period of your own policy. They can be asked for in a single sentence; after an occurrence, they are no longer negotiable.

Just culture: protection follows the reporter, the contract follows the client

The European regulation on occurrence reporting protects the person who reports: it bars the use of a report to establish fault or liability and tightly frames the identification of its author, subject to the expressly provided reservation of wilful misconduct and of a manifest, severe and serious disregard of an obvious risk. That protection requires no employment contract. On this point, employee and contractor are treated alike, and rightly so, because the value of a reporting system rests precisely on everyone involved filing into it.

The difference appears on the employment side of just culture. What the texts guarantee is the absence of disciplinary sanction for a report made in good faith. But a contractor does not suffer a disciplinary sanction: they suffer a non-renewal of the assignment, a decision that need not be reasoned and does not fall under the same litigation. The protection exists, but the instrument for enforcing it is far harder to grasp. Only the wording of the service contract narrows this grey area, by providing that a safety report constitutes neither a ground for termination nor a ground for non-renewal.

A second point of friction: confidentiality. The secrecy clauses in crew leasing contracts are drafted to protect commercial know-how; applied to the letter, they come into tension with the duty to report an occurrence or to answer an investigator. An explicit exception for regulatory reports avoids having to arbitrate on your own, one evening, between two contradictory duties. The question keeps coming back on the FL330 forums, and rarely with the same answer from one operator to the next.

What to pull out of your own file before the next rotation

The check comes down to six written documents, to be gathered before signing and not after the occurrence. None of them can be replaced by the reassuring word of a recruiter in a hurry, and each can be requested in a single sentence.

Which written document carries which protectionA table with four rows and three columns. The rows are the protections: status of additional insured, waiver of subrogation, coverage of criminal defence, cover after the end of the assignment. The columns are the written documents: the operator’s insurance certificate, the service contract, the personal policy. A solid cell marks the document that must carry the wording. The first two rows are marked only in the certificate column; criminal defence is marked in the contract and in the personal policy; cover after the assignment is marked only in the personal policy.solid box: the document that must carry the wordingoperator'scertificateservicecontractyourpolicynamed additional insuredwaiver of subrogationcriminal defence coveredcover after end of assignment
Two protections are asked for, two are bought. The first two rows exist only in the certificate issued by the operator’s insurer: no service contract, however detailed, can create them in its stead. The last two depend on you alone, and are settled without asking anyone for anything.
  • The operator’s insurance certificate, with the clause defining the insured persons — and its exact wording, in the original language.
  • The mention of a waiver of subrogation for the benefit of the contractor and of the people it supplies.
  • Your own professional liability policy: trigger basis, retroactive cover, length of the extended reporting period.
  • A personal criminal legal expenses cover whose fee ceiling is compatible with a lengthy investigation.
  • The service contract, reread on three points: liability cap, clause on cooperation with investigations, confidentiality exception for regulatory reports.
  • The written record of your assignment by the operator, the one proving that you were operating under its control and according to its manual.

One area remains that none of this closes: the period during which an investigation is open without any decision being taken. No contract compensates it, no policy covers it, and it can last longer than the assignment that triggered it. For anyone preparing a type rating and hesitating between a salaried post and a contractor pool, that is the real term of the comparison: the day-rate differential can be worked out in a minute, the cost of several months on the ground far less easily — and yet it is the latter that decides how solid an independent career will be.

The applicable legislation, the policies actually taken out and the operator’s approved documentation prevail in every case over this article, which describes only a general mechanism and replaces neither reading your contract nor the advice of a professional.

Questions fréquentes

Am I covered by the operator's insurance if I fly as a contractor?

Everything hangs on the wording of the clause defining the insured persons, and on that alone. If it refers to the operator’s employees, a contractor is a third party to the policy and does not benefit from it. If they are named as an additional insured, or if the clause covers any person acting on behalf of the insured, they are protected like a member of staff. The only way to know is to read the exact wording, in the original language, before the first rotation.

Can the operator's insurer turn against me after paying out?

Yes, if you are neither insured under its policy nor protected by a waiver of subrogation. The insurer that pays is subrogated to its insured’s rights and may proceed against the person whose fault caused the damage. An employee is shielded by the servant’s immunity, save intentional misconduct or acting outside the limits of the assignment; a contractor, who is not a servant, does not enjoy that immunity.

Is a mutual hold-harmless clause signed with the operator enough?

No, because it binds only the operator. Its insurer, subrogated to its rights, is not party to that undertaking and retains its own recourse. What is needed is a waiver of subrogation taken out at the level of the insurance policy itself, shown on the certificate, and naming the contractor as well as the people it supplies.

Why does the trigger basis of my policy matter so much?

Because an aviation claim rarely arrives during the assignment. On an occurrence basis, it is the date of the event that triggers cover, even if the claim comes long after the contract has ended. On a claims-made basis, it is the date of the claim: without retroactive cover or a sufficient extended reporting period, cover lapses on the day the contract stops, while the risk is still running.

Does just culture protection apply to a crew member who is not an employee?

The protection of the reporter provided by the European regulation on occurrence reporting does not depend on an employment contract: it bars the use of a report to establish fault or liability and frames the identification of its author, apart from wilful misconduct and a manifest, severe and serious disregard of an obvious risk. Its employment side, however, targets disciplinary sanction, which does not exist in a contracting relationship. The practical risk becomes non-renewal of the assignment, and only an explicit clause in the service contract guards against it.

Who pays for my recurrent training if I am taken off the roster during an investigation?

For an employee, the operator normally bears the cost of regaining recent experience and of the checks, since it has an interest in putting the person back on line. For a contractor, no rule requires it: the burden falls on their company or on themselves, unless a grounding compensation clause has been negotiated in advance. This is the item most often forgotten in the comparison between day rate and salary.

Commentaires

Leave a Reply

Découvrez l’écosystème FL330

FL330, c’est toute l’aviation professionnelle — explorez nos autres espaces.