A fuel uplift advertised as « forty percent sustainable fuel » almost never contains forty percent synthetic molecules, and a blender aiming for the ceiling does not always have the right to reach it. The blending ceiling is neither a political trade-off nor a matter of principle-based caution: it follows from what a synthetic kerosene does not contain, is recalculated batch by batch, and will rise once we know how to replace what is missing.
The ceiling is not written in the flight manual
Look for an incorporation-rate limitation in the limitations section of a flight manual: you will not find it. What the manual designates is a fuel specification. The aircraft is certified for a product defined by its properties — density, freezing point, cold viscosity, mass-specific energy, thermal stability — not by its origin. As long as the delivered product meets that specification, it is the approved fuel, whether it comes from crude, used oil, or alcohol.
The ceiling lives one step upstream, in the specification for aviation turbine fuels containing synthesized hydrocarbons. This document does not describe a fuel: it describes a blending component, then the conditions under which that component, added to a conventional kerosene, yields a product entitled to be called jet fuel. Each production pathway — synthesis from synthesis gas, hydroprocessing of esters and fatty acids, alcohol conversion, hydrothermal cracking — has its own annex, its own criteria, and its own maximum rate. Most stop at half the volume; some, covering chemically narrower components, stop around a tenth.
Hence a consequence that operations often forget: after blending and verification, the batch changes identity. It is no longer « a blend at so many percent, » it is jet fuel, and no crew procedure or maintenance task depends on the rate. That is what « drop-in » means: the product loses trace of its origin the moment it becomes compliant.
What a synthetic paraffin is missing
The approved pathways converge on the same family of molecules: linear and branched paraffins, in the kerosene cut. Excellent news for combustion — a paraffin burns cleanly and fouls injectors little. A problem for everything else, because a conventional kerosene is not a paraffin: it is a mixture in which paraffins, naphthenes — the cycloparaffins — and aromatics coexist, each family contributing what the others do not.

Removing the aromatics removes four things at once. Density: they are the densest molecules in the cut, and a pure paraffinic component falls below the lower bound of the allowed range; since tanks fill by volume while performance is calculated by mass, a fuel that is too light shortens the full-tank range. Electrical conductivity: a very pure product conducts poorly, and the charge that builds up during high-flow transfers is dealt with by a static-dissipator additive. Lubricity, which depends on the polar compounds left by refining and on which high-pressure pumps rely. And above all elastomer swelling.
The asymmetry must be weighed. Two of these four properties show up on a batch’s certificate of analysis, density and conductivity, and are corrected at delivery: the batch is rejected, the base is adjusted, the additive dosing is tuned. The other two show up nowhere. Lubricity is not a routine finished-product requirement; it is handled upstream through the choice of base stock and, where needed, a protective additive. Elastomer swelling, for its part, is not a specification property but a fitness-for-purpose property: checked during a pathway’s qualification, never re-checked on a tanker truck. The ceiling is therefore the instrument that blindly guarantees the one of the four that no receipt inspection would ever catch.
Synthetic fuel lacks aromatics, which provide density, conductivity, lubricity, and elastomer swelling. The blending ceiling ensures the fuel remains safe for all aircraft systems, especially seals that rely on swelling to stay tight.
An Airbus A320 fueled with a blend containing 50% synthetic paraffinic kerosene (SPK) and 50% conventional jet fuel (Jet A-1) at a temperature of 15°C. The SPK has a density of 760 kg/m³ (below the minimum of 775 kg/m³), requiring adjustment with a denser base fuel to meet specifications. The blend’s conductivity is also checked, and a static dissipator additive is added to ensure safe handling.
| Property | Conventional kerosene | Synthetic paraffinic component | What the finished blend requires |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aromatics | Present, capped at the top | Practically absent | A minimum content, on the order of 8% by volume |
| Density at 15 °C | Narrow range, bounded on both sides | Generally below the lower bound | Mandatory return to within range |
| Electrical conductivity | Low, corrected by additive | Practically nil | Dissipator additive, dosed within range |
| Elastomer swelling | Ensured by aromatics | Practically nil | Not measured on the batch: guaranteed indirectly by the ceiling |
The O-ring is the real arbiter of the ceiling
A nitrile seal does not work only in mechanical compression. Put into service in a fluid containing aromatics, it absorbs a fraction of them and swells by a few percent in volume, durably. In parallel, it undergoes an irreversible phenomenon: under sustained stress and heat, it takes on a compression set and loses the spring-back force that pressed its lip against the groove. What keeps an aged fitting sealed is therefore no longer its stiffness — it is its swollen volume.
Make the aromatics disappear and the seal releases what it had absorbed: it shrinks. On a new seal, the spring-back force compensates; on a fatigued seal, a gap opens — enough for weeping at a hydrant fitting, a pump that seeps, a valve packing that no longer regains its seat.
Common sense aims at the wrong target. The engine is not the issue: it accepts a paraffin very well, test rigs showed that early on. The issue is the population of seals, hoses, sealants, and packings of the airframe, the fuelers, the hydrants, and the tanks: old, heterogeneous, not replaceable at the scale of a fleet-wide programme. The ceiling protects it without having to inventory it.
The real ceiling is often lower than the written ceiling
So where does the number come from? The finished blend must retain a minimum aromatic content, on the order of eight percent by volume, and those aromatics can only come from the base kerosene, since the synthetic component contributes practically none. The constraint fits in one line: the maximum rate equals one minus the ratio between the required minimum and the base’s aromatic content.
The exercise can be done in your head, taking eight percent as the minimum for the sake of argument. Base at sixteen percent aromatics: you just reach half, chemistry and ceiling agree. Base at twenty: chemistry would allow more, it is the ceiling that constrains. Base at fourteen — a perfectly compliant kerosene, poor in aromatics because it comes from a light crude: the real rate falls below forty-five percent, and the margin closes further still if the contractual minimum is stricter than the specification’s. Density plays the same game in parallel; depending on the batch, one constraint or the other bites first. A pathway’s « maximum rate » is a ceiling by right, not a recipe.
The trap: treating the advertised rate as a contractual target achievable everywhere. Promising a fixed physical rate across a season and several stations is promising something the composition of the base batches may refuse, through no one’s fault. The rate will have to come down, or the base will have to change, and that is not a decision made the night before.
Three rates that get confused
Much of the confusion comes from three quantities sharing the same name. The physical rate is that of the tank, fixed at the blending point: the only one with chemical meaning, the only one the ceiling constrains. The book rate is that of the contracts: since fuel is fungible, the synthetic component dilutes into the stock as soon as it enters the pipeline and is allocated by mass balance — a flight sold « at so many percent » may therefore have been fueled with conventional product, with no deception involved. The obligation rate, finally, is imposed on the supplier at an airport and is measured over a year, never over a single fill.
| What is meant | Where it is set | What it constrains | How it is verified |
|---|---|---|---|
| Physical rate | At the blending point | The batch’s actual composition | Batch analysis and certificate of quality |
| Book rate, by mass balance | In commercial records | An allocation, not a composition | Audit of the allocation system |
| Regulatory obligation rate | Supplier and airport | An annual share made available | Declaration and authority oversight |
The right reflex: before answering a question about « the rate, » ask which one is meant: a salesperson means the book rate, a quality manager the physical rate, an authority the obligation rate. The batch’s certificate of quality knows only the first, and it is the only document that settles a matter of compliance.
What must be shown to raise an existing ceiling
The evaluation procedure for a new fuel is public and structured in levels. The first checks the specification properties, measured on a batch anyway. The second tackles the fitness-for-purpose properties, which the specification does not measure because it takes them for granted: compatibility with elastomers and sealants, very-low-temperature behavior, oxidation stability in hot loops, spray pattern, soot. The third goes down to components: pumps, regulators, injectors, fuel-oil heat exchangers, gauging. The fourth goes to the full engine and the auxiliary power unit. Engine and airframe manufacturers then rule on the operating envelope.
The point to remember: the incorporation rate is not an input to the process, it is an outcome. It expresses how far the evidence supplied allows you to go; a pathway with a lighter case file goes through a fast-track route, but with a lower ceiling. Raising a ceiling does not require starting over: it requires completing, where the case file left off, the evidence the new rate makes necessary. The move to a fully synthetic product is therefore long without being uncertain.
Cycloparaffins rather than aromatics
A fully synthetic fuel therefore cannot simply be a very clean paraffin: it must give back what the aromatics gave, density and elastomer swelling. Nothing requires doing so with aromatics.
Cycloparaffins — the naphthenes — are the serious lead: for an equal carbon number they are denser than linear paraffins, they interact with elastomers, and they do not carry the aromatics’ main flaw. That flaw has a name: soot. Aromatic compounds, especially the two-ring ones, are the direct precursors of the non-volatile particles produced in the combustion chamber. Fewer aromatics means fewer particles; and since these particles serve as condensation nuclei, the contrail forms on fewer nuclei, with larger crystals and a shorter lifetime.
Hence the tension that structures the subject: aromatics are required at the bottom for seal durability and capped at the top for combustion cleanliness. The specification bounds them on both sides, which is rare and telling. A well-designed fully synthetic fuel would break out of this trade-off from above: density and swelling achieved another way, soot collapsed — that is the real stake behind « one hundred percent. » Fueling feedback can be compared on the forum.
The other trap: believing that blending can be done downstream. Pouring a synthetic component into an airport tank, a tanker truck, or an aircraft tank does not produce a compliant fuel but an off-specification product, whatever rate is obtained. Compliance is born of a blend made at a declared point, followed by analysis and documented re-identification.
What to check in your own documentation
Three checks are worth making, and none where you would expect. In the flight manual first, the approved-fuels section: it names one or more specifications, sometimes additives. If an incorporation rate appears there, it is an exception to be understood: the rule is that the rate belongs to the fuel, not the aircraft.
Next, in the fuel-quality procedures and the fueling-service contracts: that is where you find out who performs the blend, who issues the batch certificate of quality, and what it must state. These texts are being rewritten right now in many organizations, often without crews being informed.
Finally, in the maintenance documentation, the fuel-system materials chapter: that is where, when the day comes, what a move to an aromatic-free product would require in the way of replacements will appear. The grey zone is neither in the engines nor in recent airframes, whose elastomers are qualified over a wide range. It is on the ground: depots, hydrants, ground-service equipment, and older fleets, where no inventory of seals exists anywhere. For anyone preparing a qualification, that is the answer that separates reciting a figure from explaining a rule: the ceiling does not protect the engine, it protects the infrastructure. The reasoning is worked through in training.
This article sets out a mechanism and does not stand in for a procedure or a binding rule: the specification in force, the type’s flight manual, and the operator’s approved documentation prevail in all circumstances over what precedes.
Questions fréquentes
Why isn't a fully synthetic fuel yet authorized for routine operations?
Because the synthetic components approved today are almost pure paraffins, with no aromatics. Aromatics swell elastomers and add density: without them, old seals shrink and the product falls outside the allowed density range. A fully synthetic fuel will have to restore these two properties another way, for instance with cycloparaffins, and prove it through the full evaluation procedure.
Is the blending ceiling a limitation of the aircraft or of the fuel?
Of the fuel. The flight manual designates a product specification, not an origin or a rate. The ceiling appears in the specification for aviation turbine fuels containing synthetic components, annex by annex according to the production pathway. Once blended, checked, and re-identified, the batch is ordinary jet fuel and nothing on board depends on the rate any longer.
Can the maximum rate advertised by a pathway always be reached?
No, and that is the most misunderstood point. The finished blend must retain a minimum aromatic content, which can only come from the base kerosene. If that base is poor in aromatics, the achievable rate falls mechanically below the written ceiling. Density imposes a second constraint of the same type, and the blender applies whichever of the two is stricter, batch by batch.
Does the rate announced by a supplier match what is actually in the tank?
Usually not, and that is not deception. Fuel is fungible: once injected into a shared depot or pipeline, the synthetic component dilutes into the whole stock. Allocation is then done by mass balance, in the books, and a flight sold at a certain rate may have been fueled with conventional product. Only the batch’s certificate of quality states the physical rate.
What must be demonstrated to raise an existing ceiling?
There is no need to redo the entire evaluation chain, only to complete the file where it stopped. The fitness-for-purpose properties sensitive to the rate — compatibility with elastomers and sealants, cold-temperature behavior, hot-loop behavior — must be covered up to the new targeted rate, with the corresponding component and engine tests, then reviewed by engine and airframe manufacturers.
Must a crew do anything specific when fueling with a blend?
No specific action is required because of the blend, since the delivered batch is jet fuel compliant with the approved specification. The only useful checks are the ones that already exist: specification and additives named in the flight manual, fueling documents, and accounting for a slightly lower actual density in the uplifted-mass calculation.

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.