A night runway excursion on a wet runway, two passengers aboard a light twinjet. The aircraft belongs to a holding company, is managed by a management company, flies under a third party’s certificate, and the crew comes from an agency. Four contracts, one single question as soon as the investigation opens: who exercised operational control? The contractual structure does not answer it; it only makes the question harder to ask.
« Operator » is not a box on a contract
Air law does not define the operator by the title a contract gives, but by what it does: having the aircraft at its disposal and controlling its use. The AOC does not create this status, it records it — the authority verifies, before issuing it and at every audit thereafter, that the holder actually decides how flights are conducted. A contract that labels « operator » a company that does not build the crew rosters, does not arbitrate deferred defects and does not sign off flight preparation has no effect on this classification.
Three layers overlap, and the whole difficulty lies in not confusing them. Ownership is a title: registration, financing, security interests recorded on the international register of mobile aeronautical equipment. Management is a mandate: budget, purchasing, hangar, staff contracts. Operation is a function: the decision to depart, the MEL, fuel policy, crew training and checking, record keeping. Money flows one way, operational control flows the other, and the two streams meet only once: the day someone has to answer for it.
The operator is not just a name on a contract. It’s the entity that actually makes key flight decisions, like fueling, maintenance, and crew scheduling. Even if a contract calls someone an “operator,” if they don’t do these things, they’re not the real operator in the eyes of the law.
A Cessna Citation X is owned by a private equity firm, managed by a third-party company, and operated under an AOC held by a charter company. The manager books flights, but the charter company decides crew assignments and maintenance. If an accident happens, the charter company is the operator—even if the manager paid for the flight.
The distinction is anything but academic: it decides which operations manual applies, which policy responds, which liability regime the passenger benefits from, and which entity answers for crew training, checking and duty time.
Dry lease or wet lease: what the lease actually shifts
A dry lease transfers the aircraft, not the organisation. The lessee provides the crew, enters the aircraft on its own operations specifications, folds it into its maintenance programme and continuing airworthiness management, applies its own MEL and takes out its own policy: it becomes operator without reservation. A wet lease has the opposite effect — the lessor keeps the aircraft, crew, maintenance and insurance, and therefore operator status, while the lessee sells the flight without exercising operational control.
Between the two, the European regulation on air operations governs the arrangement and, in the cases it specifies, makes it subject to prior approval by the competent authority — which looks at substance, never at the label. A « dry lease » where the lessor keeps choosing the maintenance shop, arbitrating technical tolerances and appointing pilots in command is reclassified without difficulty; the reasoning works the other way round too.
A point often overlooked carries real weight afterwards: when the State of registry and the State of the operator differ, an agreement between them can transfer to the latter all or part of the oversight functions — airworthiness, licensing, radio. Knowing who oversees what determines which authority the operator reports to and which body of rules prevails. In an arrangement where the registry was chosen for tax reasons, the answer is never obvious.
The manager: an agent until the day it decides
The management company is the most mobile piece of the arrangement. On paper, it is the owner’s agent: budget, crew payroll, tracking of deadlines, placing the aircraft with a certified operator. In practice, it is often the aircraft’s only permanent point of contact, and it is through the manager that the owner’s requests, schedule changes and last-minute arbitrations pass.
The tipping point occurs at one precise moment: when the manager stops passing things on and starts deciding. Choosing the crew for a rotation, accepting a deferred defect to make a slot, negotiating departure time with the customer, arbitrating between two alternate airports: each of these decisions belongs to the operator. Made elsewhere, they bring into the causal chain an entity that appears on no certificate and has neither the management system nor the corresponding cover.
The trap. Grey charter never presents itself under that name: loan of an aircraft with cost participation, rebilling the owner for a flight requested by a third party, cost-sharing between companies of the same group. The flight is then public transport carried out outside the certificate: the policy covers a use that is not this one, the passenger does not have in front of them the carrier they believe they have, and the crew operates without the management system meant to protect them. The insurer needs no piloting fault at all to dispute cover.
If a company pays for a flight but doesn’t control it, they’re not the operator. But if they start making key decisions—like crew assignments or maintenance choices—they become the operator, even if they don’t have a certificate. This can leave passengers and crews without proper insurance coverage.
A private jet owner leases their aircraft to a charter company under a wet lease. The charter company books a flight for a corporate client, but the owner’s manager negotiates the departure time and accepts a deferred maintenance issue. If an accident occurs, the manager may be considered the de facto operator, even though they don’t hold the AOC.
The dividing line therefore depends neither on the nature of the flight nor on the status of the passengers, but on the crossing of a consideration and a title. It is rarely crossed all at once: it settles in through successive slippages, one invoice at a time.
One aircraft, two regimes: commercial on Monday, private on Tuesday
Many air taxi aircraft lead a double life: the owner uses only a fraction of the annual hours for their own account, the aircraft being placed the rest of the time under the certificate of an operator who charters it out. Same aircraft, sometimes even the same crew, but two rulebooks, two policies, two parties responsible for continuing airworthiness. The tipping point is entry into and exit from the operations specifications.

| Element | Commercial air transport (certified operator) | Complex non-commercial operation (declared operator) |
|---|---|---|
| Title required | Air operator certificate, aircraft entered on the operations specifications | Declaration to the authority, with no certificate or aircraft listing |
| Operational control | Certified operator, under its approved operations manual | Declared operator, most often the owner or their manager |
| Continuing airworthiness | Managed within the scope of the certificate, by the approved organisation attached to the operator | Owner’s responsibility, with a possible contract with an approved organisation |
| Minimum equipment list | Approved MEL, derived from the manufacturer’s master minimum equipment list | MEL established by the declared operator under its own management system |
| Flight and duty time | Prescriptive body of rules for commercial air transport, records kept by the operator | No equivalent prescriptive body of rules: fatigue management falls to the declared operator’s management system |
| Insurance | Public transport policy, European minima in SDR, tiered by mass for third parties and fixed per passenger | Private use policy, declared use to be revalidated at every change of regime |
| Liability to the passenger | Air carrier regime, with distinction between contracting carrier and actual carrier | Ordinary contract and tort law |
The most underestimated line is continuing airworthiness. As long as the aircraft appears on the operations specifications, its management lives within the scope of the certificate: the operator follows airworthiness directives, arbitrates deferrals, keeps the file and prepares the airworthiness review. On exit, responsibility reverts to the owner, who must either carry it themselves or contract it out to an approved organisation. The transition between two certificates is when files go astray: maintenance programme not transferred, justification for a structural repair left with the former manager, life-limited parts tracked in two different tools.
The MEL calls for the same vigilance. That of the certified operator was approved for its operation, its airports and its procedures; it has no value outside the certificate. A deferral accepted on a Friday evening under a commercial regime may have no basis left on Saturday morning under a declared regime. Departing with inoperative equipment without an applicable document is the hardest situation to defend: it is entirely documentary, therefore entirely verifiable.
The right reflex. Treat every change of regime as a return to service, not as a change of billing. A one-page form, signed by both entities, sets out the exact time, the flight’s status, the applicable MEL, who holds continuing airworthiness management, the policy and declared use, deferrals in progress and who signs the technical log. A few minutes to draft; its absence costs the entire discussion over cover.
Where the insurance turns
The insurance programme mirrors the contractual arrangement, and that is where the final allocation of the burden is decided. The operator’s policy names an insured party; owner, manager and financier are generally added as additional insureds, with cross waivers of subrogation. The effect is rarely explained: the insurer who has paid out can no longer, by subrogation, go after the parties thus protected. Recourse falls on those who are not.
Insurance contracts decide who pays after an accident. If the owner, manager, or financier are added as “additional insureds,” the insurer can’t sue them later. That means the insurer will go after whoever isn’t protected—like maintenance shops or engine manufacturers—even if they weren’t the main cause of the problem.
A Gulfstream G650 operated by a charter company crashes due to a maintenance error. The charter company’s insurer pays the passengers but then sues the maintenance shop. However, if the owner and manager were added as “additional insureds,” the insurer can’t go after them—even if they were involved in the decision to defer maintenance.
The battlefield is therefore in the technical contracts. Maintenance organisation, engine manufacturer, ground handler and fuel supplier all seek additional-insured status or a waiver. Whoever fails to obtain it becomes the target of recourse — not because they were the most at fault, but because they are the most exposed link. On the financing side, the standard endorsement that the London market attaches to financing and leasing agreements exists precisely to preserve the position of the lender and the lessor when the operator has breached a policy condition — the exact extent of that protection is read in the endorsement taken out, not in its title.
What remains is the clause that commands everything else: declared use. It fits in one line and conditions the very existence of cover. A commercial flight carried out under a private-use policy, an operator different from the one named in the contract, an excluded zone, a crew not meeting the minimum experience conditions written into the policy: each of these gaps opens a discussion in which hull and liability cover can be treated differently. European requirements impose minima in SDR; they do not require the policy to match the actual operation.
What an investigator reconstructs, and what a court retains
After the event, no one opens the file of contracts first. The decision chain is reconstructed from material traces: crew rostering and duty times, flight preparation and the weather file, the fuel order, the load sheet and who signed it, entries in the technical log, mention of the deferred defect, messages that shifted the departure by an hour. Each piece carries a name, a function and a timestamp. It is this set, not the contractual organisation chart, that identifies the entity that exercised operational control.
A safety investigation attributes neither fault nor liability, and its conclusions are not meant to; but its factual reconstruction is then read by others, who are looking for those responsible. On this ground, delegation of authority is never presumed: it only has effect if its beneficiary had the competence, the authority and the means. A person named responsible in a manual but denied a budget or the power to cancel a flight protects no one, starting with themselves.
The consequence is the same for the operator and for the crew: consistency between the written organisation and the real organisation is worth more than any liability-exclusion clause. Better to correct, before the event, a practice where the manager arbitrates departures than to explain it afterwards, notably on the FL330 technical forums, where the arrangements described look very much alike.
What to go and check in your own documentation
Four checks can be made on the record, without any special expertise, and change how an arrangement reads. Does the operations manual designate, by function, who authorises departure, and is that the person you call on a Sunday evening? Does the management contract give the manager a right to instruct on crew or on maintenance? Does the certificate of insurance name the same operator as the operations specifications, and does the declared use cover the profile actually flown? For agency or freelance crews, do the contracts place training, checking and records with the operator?
- Operations manual: Verify who is authorized to approve a flight. If the person you call in an emergency isn’t the one listed, there’s a problem.
- Management contract: Check if the manager has authority over crew assignments or maintenance decisions. If they do, they might be the de facto operator.
- Insurance certificate: Ensure the named operator matches the one in the operations specifications. Also, confirm the declared use matches the actual flight profile.
- Crew contracts: For freelance or agency crews, confirm that training, checks, and records are managed by the operator, not the manager or owner.
Two grey areas remain. The first is the fate of the passenger of a whole-aircraft charter with regard to the European passenger rights regime: the extent to which they benefit from it, having not contracted directly with the carrier, remains disputed. The second is the boundary of cost sharing, whose interpretation varies from one national authority to another and is tightening regularly. In both cases, prudence consists in documenting the classification adopted at the moment the flight is sold, not in reconstructing it afterwards.
For anyone preparing a type rating on a business aircraft, the useful information is not the name painted on the tail: it is the operations specifications, the list of aircraft actually entered on them, the share of flights carried out outside the certificate, and the entity that signs off line checks. These points are worth asking before the interview, and those working on freelance assignments have every interest in demanding them in writing: a freelance pilot does not have the protection of an employment contract when they find themselves, unknowingly, at the controls of a flight outside the certificate.
This article sets out general mechanisms and is no substitute for any official source: the applicable texts, the decisions of the competent authority and the operator’s approved documentation prevail over the foregoing, as do the particular conditions of the policies taken out.
Questions fréquentes
Who is the operator when an aircraft is dry leased?
The lessee. A dry lease transfers the aircraft without the organisation: it is the lessee who provides the crew, enters the aircraft on its operations specifications, applies its own manual and minimum equipment list, and takes out the corresponding policy. The lessor keeps ownership and its financial guarantees, but no longer operational control. If in practice the lessor keeps appointing pilots in command or arbitrating maintenance, the contractual label does not survive scrutiny.
Can an aircraft manager be held liable even though it appears on no certificate?
Yes, as soon as its involvement in the decision shows up in the reconstruction of the event. A manager who builds the rosters, negotiates departure time with the customer, or accepts a deferred defect enters the causal chain. It then finds itself there without the management system, without the records, and often without the cover available to the certified operator. It is the most exposed position in the arrangement.
What is actually at stake, on the insurance side, in a grey charter?
The discussion is not about fault but about the very existence of cover. The declared-use clause conditions cover: public transport carried out under a private-use policy puts the insurer in a position to dispute it, for both hull and liability. On top of that, the passenger does not have in front of them the carrier they believed they had, which also shifts their recourse.
What happens to continuing airworthiness management when the aircraft leaves the certificate?
It reverts to the owner. As long as the aircraft appears on the operations specifications, its management lives within the scope of the operator’s certificate. On exit, the owner must either carry it themselves or contract it out to an approved organisation. The transition period is when files go astray: maintenance programme, justifications for repairs, tracking of life-limited parts.
Does the air carrier liability regime apply to an air taxi flight?
It applies when the flight is air transport carried out by a carrier, which is the case for a charter operated under a certificate. The Montreal Convention then provides for the distinction between contracting carrier and actual carrier, allowing the passenger to act against either. A private flight by the owner, on the other hand, falls under ordinary contract and tort law.
Is authority approval required to place an aircraft at the disposal of another operator?
The European regulation on air operations governs leases of aircraft with or without crew and, in the cases it specifies, makes them subject to prior approval by the competent authority. The examination looks at the substance of the agreement: who provides the crew, who manages airworthiness, who insures, who decides. A contract’s title is never enough to determine the classification.

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.