Two quotes for the same programme, a few thousand euros apart, and it is the one advertising the most training-device hours that costs the most. The student concludes that substitution is a sales pitch, the school concludes that the student has misunderstood the whole subject, and both miss the actual mechanism. An hour on a device never replaces “an hour of flight”: it replaces a named exercise, in a named programme, within the limit that the approved syllabus grants it. What this permission shifts in the invoice, in the logbook and in a future candidate’s file follows three distinct logics, which are best kept separate before signing.
You do not substitute a duration, you substitute an objective
The word “hour” is the first trap. An approved programme is not an hour counter: it is a sequence of exercises, each carrying a training objective and a pass criterion. The volume of hours shown at the top of a syllabus is only a consequence — the duration statistically needed to bring an average student to standard across that sequence of exercises. When a text authorises part of the instruction to be carried out on a device, it does not say “so many hours may be done on the ground”: it identifies the exercises whose objective is still met outside the aircraft, and it sets a ceiling to stop the programme from drifting toward all-synthetic training.
The dividing line is sharper than people assume. On one side, exercises whose objective is procedural or cognitive: intercepting and holding a track, managing an engine failure in the cruise, an emergency descent, briefing and flying an instrument approach, a go-around, task-sharing, reading a complex failure. All of this is learned through repeating a sequence, and the sequence reproduces faithfully on the ground. On the other side, exercises whose objective is exposure: deciding to go or to turn back, facing deteriorating weather with only one airfield left ahead, discovering that one is the sole person responsible on board, feeling the fatigue of a long navigation flight. These objectives have nothing to do with the fidelity of the aerodynamic model. They depend on irreversibility, and a device, by its very design, can be paused.
Simulators can replace some flight hours, but only for specific exercises. They can’t replace real-life decision-making or physical sensations like fatigue or emergency reactions. The key is what the exercise is teaching, not just the time spent.
On an A320 type rating, a student might complete 10 instrument approaches in a single simulator session, while in an aircraft, weather and fuel constraints might only allow 3-4 approaches in the same time. However, the simulator can’t replace the first solo flight where the student experiences real responsibility for the aircraft.
This is why substitution is not negotiated across a counter. It is written, exercise by exercise, into the training organisation’s approved programme, and it holds only for that particular programme. The same device, at the same school, may credit a session in one programme and nothing at all in another.
Two gates to clear: qualification, then the programme
A training device is not certified like an aircraft, it is qualified. The authority assesses it against a set of specifications describing, level by level, what the machine must reproduce: flight-model fidelity, cockpit conformity, visual system, motion cueing, failure realism, overall latency. The outcome is a certificate carrying a level and a number, and a test guide that serves as the reference for every periodic evaluation. Qualification must be maintained: a device whose monitoring has lapsed stops crediting hours, even if it still works perfectly.
This first gate says what the machine can do. It does not say what the school is entitled to do with it. The second gate is the organisation’s approved programme, which ties each exercise to a designated device and justifies that link. A highly qualified device that is absent from the programme credits nothing; a device provided for in the programme whose qualification has expired credits nothing either. The effective credit is always the lower of the two ceilings, and for the student it is almost always the programme that sets the limit, not the machine.
What each device level actually buys
Device families do not differ by a percentage of realism, but by the nature of the objectives they can carry. A generic device reproduces a class of aircraft and procedures; a type-representative device reproduces a specific flight deck, its automation and its failures; a full flight simulator adds the visual system and motion, that is, the sensory loop that allows a rejected takeoff or a landing all the way to touchdown to be flown. It is this last step, and this one alone, that allows a school to conduct the bulk of a type rating and the check that sanctions it without the student ever touching the aircraft.
| Family | What it reproduces | What it commonly substitutes | What it will not carry |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basic Instrument Training Device (BITD) | A basic cockpit, a simplified flight model, the instruments | The first instrument-flying exercises, familiarisation with procedures | Anything requiring a conforming cockpit or realistic failure handling |
| Flight and Navigation Procedures Trainer, level one (FNPT I) | A generic single-engine cockpit, with no motion cueing | Part of the instrument instruction, with the family’s lowest ceiling | Procedures specific to multi-engine aircraft, crew coordination |
| Flight and Navigation Procedures Trainer, level two (FNPT II) | A generic twin-engine cockpit, with coherent systems and failures | The largest share of instrument instruction the programme allows | Credits tied to a specific aircraft type |
| Type-representative device (FTD) | The flight deck of a specific type, its systems, with no motion or limited motion | Instruction on a type’s systems and normal procedures | Takeoff and landing training with no reference to the actual aircraft |
| Full flight simulator (FFS) | The type, with visual system and motion cueing assessed | Nearly all of a type rating, recurrent training, and checks | Real exposure: solo flight, the decision that carries commitment |
Exercises that never get substituted
A few blocks resist substitution altogether, and it is more useful to understand why than to memorise a list. Solo flight comes first: its objective is not to fly, it is to exercise command with no safety net. No device can take away from the student the certainty that an instructor is sitting beside them, or that a button resets the exercise to zero. Qualifying cross-country flights come next, whose objective is conducting a complete flight in an environment one does not control: real airspace, real controllers, an airfield that had not been planned, fuel that is genuinely burned.
The aircraft portion of upset prevention and recovery training follows the same reasoning. Load factor, disorientation, the sensation of tipping over are not reproduced on hydraulic actuators; worse, a device that claims to reproduce them can install false cues. This is one of the rare cases where the regulator requires the aircraft not despite the device’s fidelity, but because of its known limitations.
Finally, basic cockpit training — touch-and-goes on the aircraft during a type rating — disappears only in a very tightly framed case: when the device reaches the highest qualification level, the operator’s programme provides for it, and the pilot presents a defined prior experience. The exemption is not a discount granted to the machine, it is a shift of the demonstration to the first line rotations, where a line instructor takes over.
The trap. A quote that advertises a large device volume without naming its family, its qualification level and the exercise each session is tied to promises you nothing enforceable. On exam day, it is the file that speaks: if a session was logged as “SIM” with no device identifier or reference to the programme, it does not credit, and the hour will have to be redone — on the aircraft, at full price, in an already tight schedule.
Why the invoice does not track the substitution
The intuition is simple: a device hour costs less than an aircraft hour, so the more you substitute, the less you pay. It runs into three facts. First, the cheapest devices are the ones with the lowest substitution ceiling, and the devices that substitute a great deal are billed at a rate that is anything but symbolic, once maintenance, qualification upkeep and the instructor are included. Second, a device session is rarely sold bare: the slot includes a preparation and a debrief that run longer than in flight, because the session is denser and there is more to go back over. Third, what substitution removes is often the cheapest hours of the programme — dual instruction on a single-engine aircraft — except where it bites into multi-engine instrument instruction, where the saving becomes real.

What remains is the main mechanism, and it is calendar-driven. The regulatory minimum is a floor, not a forecast: no one finishes a programme at the advertised minimum. The real invoice is decided by the overrun, that is, by the hours that must be added because a student has not reached standard, because a slot was lost to a low ceiling, because an aircraft was grounded. The device does not reduce the floor: it reduces the overrun. It depends neither on the weather nor on an aircraft’s availability, it allows a situation to be frozen, an approach to be repeated three times in a row, and so allows the student to arrive in flight already having the sequence installed. The gain shows up in the total duration of the programme and in the cost of living through that duration, two items that appear on no quote. Comparing two training programmes on the displayed hourly rate alone amounts to ignoring half the expense.
| Item | Minimal substitution | Maximal substitution | Direction of the gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aircraft hours | High, spread across the whole programme | Markedly reduced during the instrument phase | Favours substitution |
| Device hours | Marginal, on entry-level devices | Substantial, on high-end devices | Unfavourable, the hourly rate is not negligible |
| Ground instruction, briefings, theory | Identical | Identical, or even longer per session | Neutral to slightly unfavourable |
| Exams, administrative fees, materials | Identical | Identical | Neutral |
| Hours added for failing to reach standard | Frequent, at aircraft rate | Rarer, and recoverable on the ground | Markedly favourable |
| Calendar duration and weather risk | Long, exposed to cancellations | Compressed, less sensitive | Markedly favourable, off the quote |
What the logbook records, and what a recruiter reads into it
A device session goes into the logbook, but not in the same column as a flight. Time spent on a device is ground instruction time: it satisfies the programme’s requirement, it feeds instrument currency, and depending on the device’s level and the applicable text it may help re-establish recent experience, but it does not add to total flight time. Yet it is that total flight time that governs the issue of an airline transport pilot licence and that serves as the first filter in most selection processes. A highly synthetic programme therefore does not advance that particular counter by a single hour — and it does not claim to.
The practical consequence is documentary. A creditable session carries its date, the designation of the device and its level, the qualification identifier, the programme exercise it is tied to, the duration and the instructor’s signature. This precision looks bureaucratic as long as everything goes smoothly; it becomes decisive at two moments. First, when transferring to another organisation: the receiving head of training only credits what can be tied to their own approved programme, and a vague entry translates into hours that must be redone. Second, when sitting an examination, where the examiner checks that the programme was indeed followed as approved, device included.
Where the device outperforms the aircraft, and where it transfers poorly
On certain objectives, the device is not a fallback: it is superior. Density first — a single session can pack in a number of approaches that a morning of flying would not allow, and the failed portion can be repeated immediately instead of redoing the whole leg. Freezing the situation next, which lets the instructor stop time at the exact moment a decision was taken and dissect it in cold blood. Failures last: fire, depressurisation, a failure on takeoff at the critical speed, inoperative de-icing. No one triggers these in flight, and it is better to deal with them once on the ground than to discover them in the line.
The transfer, however, has its gaps, and an honest instructor names them in the briefing. The flare and control of the flight path near the ground are built on peripheral visual references that a device lacking a quality visual system does not provide. The rendering of acceleration is an illusion sustained by actuators of limited travel: it kicks off the sensation, it does not sustain it. Above all, the student knows a failure is coming and waits for it — which produces crews that are very quick on an announced failure and much slower faced with an ambiguous anomaly. The remedy is pedagogical, not technical: vary the timing, accept sessions where nothing happens, and debrief the surprise as much as the procedure.
The right instinct. Before signing, ask for three documents: the qualification certificate of the device(s) used, with their level and validity; the page of the approved programme that ties each device session to a programme exercise; and the clause stating what happens if the device is unavailable — who pays for the fallback to the aircraft, and whether that fallback is itself provided for in the programme. A serious school produces these three documents without hesitation; it is precisely what it is audited on.
What to check in your own file
Go back over your session records and check whether each one identifies the device by more than an in-house nickname. Verify that the sum of device hours logged in your file does not exceed your programme’s ceiling: an overrun is not creditable and is paid for twice, once on the invoice, once in aircraft hours that must be made up. Finally, check that the logbook column is the right one — a column error, discovered three years later when a total needs to be justified, costs weeks of reconstruction.
Two grey areas remain, and it is better to know them than to discover them. The first concerns personal equipment: a home-built rig or off-the-shelf software falls under no ceiling and credits nothing, which does not stop it from saving genuine time on learning scans and procedures — the benefit is pedagogical, never regulatory. The second concerns how an employer will read it: no one has ever been hired for their device hour volume, but a candidate who can say what exercise each session served and what their progression showed stands out from one who simply recites a total. Student feedback on a given organisation is often worth more than a brochure for finding out how these sessions are actually run there.
This article describes a mechanism and creates no entitlement: the applicable text, your organisation’s approved programme and the operator’s documentation prevail over everything above, and it is the version in force on the date of your session that governs.
Questions fréquentes
Do the hours done on a device count toward my total flight hours?
No. Time spent on a training device is entered in the logbook as ground instruction time, in a column separate from flight time. It satisfies the programme’s requirement and feeds currency, but it does not advance the total-hours counter that governs the issue of an airline transport pilot licence or hiring thresholds. A heavily synthetic programme shortens the calendar, not the path to that total.
If a school uses a higher-level device, will it save me aircraft hours?
Only if its approved programme provides for that substitution at that particular point in the syllabus. The device’s qualification says what the machine can carry, the programme says what the school is entitled to do with it, and the actual credit is the lower of the two. It is common for an organisation to hold a device capable of far more than its programme allows it to credit, simply because the corresponding use was never got approved.
Can I take a practical test on a device rather than in flight?
It depends on the licence or rating sought and on the device’s level. Checks tied to a type rating and an operator’s recurrent checks are commonly conducted on a full flight simulator, with device and programme approved for that purpose. Tests for the issue of first licences, on the other hand, include a portion in the aircraft, because they assess objectives that the ground does not reproduce. Always check what your organisation’s approved programme provides for the specific test you are preparing.
I am changing schools mid-programme: are my device hours carried over?
They are not transferred automatically. The receiving organisation’s head of training credits only what can be tied to their own approved programme, document in hand. A session documented with the device’s designation, its level, its qualification identifier and the relevant exercise credits well; a generic entry almost always translates into a reassessment, or even having to redo the hours. Obtain a complete, signed copy of your file before leaving the organisation.
Is training on a home flight simulator actually useful?
From a regulatory standpoint, not at all: unqualified equipment falls under no substitution ceiling and credits no hours. From a pedagogical standpoint, the benefit is real and measurable on scans, memorising sequences and preparing an approach, provided one works through written procedures rather than flying for pleasure. The matching risk is installing inaccurate flying habits, which the instructor will then have to undo.

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.