Type rating skill test candidates prepare as if for a single verdict, pass or fail, and it is not one. It is a set of sections, each made of items, and the outcome depends far less on how badly one manoeuvre went than on how the failures are distributed across the form. Understanding that structure is what stops a bad ten minutes from costing a whole course.
The unit of assessment is the item, not the flight
A type rating skill test under Part-FCL is conducted against a published appendix and a type-specific test form. The form is not a narrative report; it is a list of numbered items grouped into sections, and the examiner marks items. That is the first thing to understand, because it changes what a mistake means. A single mishandled item is a mark against that item. It becomes a failed section only through the section rules, and it becomes a failed test only through the rules that operate on sections.
The sections follow the flight rather than the syllabus: preparation before flight, take-off, airborne manoeuvres, instrument procedures, approaches and landings, abnormal and emergency handling. Asymmetric work is not a section of its own; each asymmetric item sits inside whichever section the appendix puts it in, which is precisely why an engine failure mishandled after take-off and an untidy one-engine-inoperative approach can register as two separate failures rather than one bad theme. The exact list, the numbering and which item sits in which section are fixed by the appendix and by the form your authority accepts for the type. Do not reconstruct them from memory or from a course handout: ask the ATO for the actual form before the test, because the form is the map of your exposure.
The right reflex. Read the test form before the last simulator session, not after the debrief. Knowing which section an item belongs to tells you which failures are recoverable inside one section and which two failures, apparently minor, would land in different sections and cost you the entire test.
How items become sections, and sections become an outcome
The chain is short and it only runs one way. Items that are not performed to the required standard fail. A section containing a failed item is a failed section. And the number of failed sections — not the number of failed items — determines whether you leave with a rating, with a partial pass, or with nothing.
That last step is where most of the misunderstanding lives. Three failed items inside one section is one failed section. One failed item in each of three sections is three failed sections, and a very different afternoon. The candidate who flew badly for a concentrated ten minutes is often in a better position than the candidate who was slightly untidy throughout, which is counter-intuitive and worth internalising before it is demonstrated to you.
| Outcome | What it means on the form | What has to happen next |
|---|---|---|
| Pass | Every section marked satisfactory | The examiner’s report goes to the authority; the rating is entered on the licence |
| Partial pass | Exactly one section marked unsatisfactory | Additional training as determined by the ATO or examiner, then a retest of the failed section only, within the elapsed-time limit the appendix imposes |
| Fail | More than one section unsatisfactory, or the test terminated because the performance seen requires a complete re-test | Additional training, then the entire test again — every section, including those already flown to standard |
The boundary Part-FCL draws is at one section. Fail a single section and, after whatever further training is required, only that section is flown again; fail more than one and the entire test is taken again. That is the construct inherited from the JAR era, and it is the whole reason the distribution of your failures matters more than their severity. The appendix has been amended over the years and the number and naming of sections differs between test forms, so read the rule on the edition your authority applies rather than accepting it from a colleague, an instructor or a forum post.
The test is divided into sections, and each section has multiple tasks. If you fail one task, the whole section fails. If you fail more than one section, you fail the entire test. If you only fail one section, you can retest just that part. It’s about how your mistakes are spread out, not how bad they are.
Imagine a test with three sections: takeoff, enroute, and landing. If you mess up one task in takeoff (like an unstable climb), that section fails. But if you make small mistakes in each of the three sections, all three sections fail, and you must retest everything. A big mistake in one section is often better than small mistakes everywhere.
Tolerances mark where attention starts, not where the verdict is written
The appendix carries a set of flight test tolerances, largely unchanged in shape since the JAR era, and candidates tend to treat them as a pass mark. They are not. They are the band inside which performance is not in question. Outside it, the examiner has to form a judgement, and the appendix explicitly tells them to take account of turbulence and of the handling qualities and performance of the aeroplane or simulator being used.

| Parameter | Normal condition | Why the asymmetry exists |
|---|---|---|
| Height, general | Around plus or minus one hundred feet | Symmetric because neither direction is inherently dangerous in level flight |
| Height at decision height, minimum descent height or missed approach point | Above the value only, never below | The figure is an obstacle-clearance floor; there is no such thing as an acceptable undershoot of it |
| Tracking on radio aids | A few degrees | Bounded by the protected area of the procedure, not by pilot skill |
| ILS azimuth and glide path | Half-scale deflection | Expressed in deflection, not degrees, because the sensitivity changes with range |
| Heading and speed with an engine failure simulated | Wider than with all engines operating | The appendix deliberately allows more latitude, because the aeroplane is harder to hold; what is assessed is control and the correct drill, not precision |
Two consequences follow. A deviation corrected promptly, with the examiner satisfied that control was never in doubt, is not automatically a failed item. And staying inside the numbers while demonstrating that you did not understand what the aeroplane was doing is not automatically a pass. Examiners assess the management of the flight, not the width of the trace, and the tolerance table exists to make that judgement defensible rather than to replace it.
The trap. Chasing a parameter back inside tolerance while abandoning the thing that put it outside. A quiet, correct diagnosis followed by a controlled recovery reads as competence. A fast recapture with no acknowledgement, no call and no cross-check reads as luck, and the item after it is usually the one that fails.
Discontinuation: the difference between an adequate and an inadequate reason
A test that stops before the end is not automatically a failure, and this is the mechanism most candidates have never had explained to them. The appendix distinguishes between discontinuation for reasons the examiner considers adequate and discontinuation for reasons considered inadequate.
Adequate reasons are the ones outside the candidate’s performance: weather that makes an item impossible, a technical failure of the aeroplane or the simulator, a medical problem, an air traffic constraint that removes the airspace needed. In that case only the sections not completed are flown on a later occasion. Everything already achieved stands.
Inadequate reasons are, in practice, the candidate’s own decision to stop when the flight is still capable of continuing. Then the entire test must be taken again. The distinction matters enormously in a training centre where a candidate who feels the session slipping away is tempted to call a halt and come back another day. That instinct, applied without the examiner agreeing that the reason is adequate, converts a recoverable position into a complete restart.
The examiner has a symmetrical power: they may terminate the test at any stage if the performance seen requires a complete re-test. That is not a punishment, it is a resource decision — there is no value in flying four more sections that will have to be repeated anyway.
The retest, and why a section you already passed can come back
A partial pass carries a condition that surprises people. On the retest, failure in any section — including a section passed on the earlier attempt — sends the whole test back to the start. The credit granted for the sections already flown is real, but it is provisional on the retest going cleanly.
The practical effect is that a retest is not a lighter event than the original test. It is shorter but less forgiving, and it has to be prepared as a whole-aeroplane exercise rather than as a drill on the one manoeuvre that went wrong. Candidates who spend their additional training hours polishing the failed item and nothing else are the ones who lose a previously passed section and start again.
Two clocks run at the same time. The appendix imposes a limit on the elapsed period in which all sections have to be passed. Independently, the ATO’s course has a validity, the medical certificate has an expiry, and any operator conversion course sitting behind the rating has its own timetable. Whichever of those expires first is the real deadline, and it is often not the one written in the regulation.
What a partial pass costs, in the currency that matters
The regulatory consequence of a failed section is additional training and a retest. The operational consequence is a full-flight simulator slot, an examiner, and a place in a queue that was built months ago. On a busy device the marginal slot is not cheap and it is not immediate, and a retest that slips by three weeks can push a line training start into a different month and a different roster.
This is why the difference between one failed section and two is not a technicality. One failed section is a device session and a short check. A full retest is the entire test profile again, often a device session plus the test itself, and it puts the candidate back in front of an examiner for every item they had already demonstrated. Anyone budgeting a type rating course should carry a contingency for the first case and treat the second as a schedule event, not a line item.
EASA and the FAA do not fail you the same way
The two systems reach a similar place by different routes, and the vocabulary does not transfer. Assuming that an American colleague’s account of partial credit describes your position under Part-FCL is a reliable way to be wrong.
| EASA Part-FCL | FAA | |
|---|---|---|
| Structure of the assessment | Items grouped into numbered sections on a test form tied to an appendix | Tasks grouped into areas of operation under the applicable airman certification standards |
| Record of a failure | Examiner’s report showing which sections were not passed | A notice of disapproval listing the areas of operation not passed |
| Partial credit | Retest of the failed section, conditional on nothing else failing on the retest | Credit for areas of operation already performed satisfactorily, subject to a time limit and to the examiner’s agreement |
| What triggers a full repeat | Failures spread beyond the appendix limit, or any failure on a retest | Expiry of the credit period, or a decision to retest in full |
The same care applies to the other checks in a professional career. A revalidation proficiency check and an operator proficiency check under Part-ORO are not skill tests, and the consequence of failing one is not a delayed rating but an immediate inability to exercise the privilege until it is passed. The section logic looks similar on the form; the operational effect is entirely different.
Flying so that a bad section stays one section
The structural insight has a direct behavioural translation. Contain damage. Once an item has gone wrong, the priority is not to recover the item — it is often already lost — but to prevent the disturbance leaking into items belonging to other sections. A rushed briefing after a poor departure section costs the approach section too, and that second failure is the one that changes the outcome.
Three habits do most of the work. Fly the aeroplane before explaining it, because a controlled deviation is assessable and an uncontrolled explanation is not. Reset deliberately between sections, out loud, so that the examiner sees the boundary as well as you do. And when the examiner offers a repositioning or a reset, take it and use the time, rather than treating it as a courtesy to be declined. None of that is examination technique in the pejorative sense; it is the same discipline that keeps a line flight from compounding, which is what the test exists to measure. Crews comparing preparation approaches will find plenty of first-hand accounts on the FL330 forums.

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.